HomeMy WebLinkAboutTBID_2016-03-15_Agenda Packet
ADVISORY BOARD FOR THE ATASCADERO TOURISM
BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT
AGENDA
Tuesday, March 15, 2016 at 2:00 P.M.
Atascadero City Hall - 6500 Palma Avenue, Room 306
Atascadero, California
CALL TO ORDER:
ROLL CALL: Chairperson Tom O’Malley, Portola Inn
Vice-Chairperson Amar Sohi, Holiday Inn Express and Suites
Board Member Deana Alexander, The Carlton Hotel
Board Member Jiten Patel, Best Western Plus Colony Inn
Board Member Lindsey Ridgeway, SpringHill Suites Marriott
APPROVAL OF AGENDA:
PUBLIC COMMENT: This portion of the meeting is reserved for persons wanting to
address the Board on any matter not on this agenda and over which the Board has
jurisdiction. Speakers are limited to three minutes. Please state your name for the
record before making your presentation. The Board may take action to direct the staff
to place a matter of business on a future agenda. A maximum of 30 minutes will be
allowed for Public Comment, unless changed by the Board.
A. CONSENT CALENDAR
1. Advisory Board Draft Action Minutes – February 16, 2016
• Action: Board approve the Draft Action Minutes of February 16, 2016. [City
Manager’s Office]
B. BUSINESS ITEMS
1. Atascadero Wine Festival: Presentation about this year’s festival and
discussion of shuttle support – Presentation by Linda Hendy
• Recommendation: Cover the cost of the shuttles during the Atascadero
Wine Festival.
• Fiscal Impact (GL 2903): $3,000
TBID 03.15.16 Page 001
2. Atascadero Cider Festival – Presentation by Stacie Jacob
• Recommendation: Receive update from the planning team regarding the
final details of the Festival and the ticket launch (today!)
• Fiscal Impact (GL 2903): None.
3. Selection of Host Hotels: Utilization of hotels in promotional contests –
Discussion led by Verdin Marketing
• Recommendation: Utilize previously adopted accommodation selection
guidelines.
• Fiscal Impact (GL 2502): None.
4. Visit Atascadero Brochures: Printing costs – Presentation by Terrie Banish
• Recommendation: Cover the cost of printing recognizing the City’s support
of distribution costs.
• Fiscal Impact (GL 2400): Up to $13,000
5. Promotional Items: Visit Atascadero items for utilization during promotions
such as CCTC Adventure Tour, FAM Tours, League of CA Cities Dinners
and others – Presentation by Terrie Banish
• Recommendation: Share with the City of Atascadero the cost of
purchasing promotional items for events and giveaways.
• Fiscal Impact (GL 2400): Up to $1,000
6. TBID Event Support: Development of TBID Event Support Guidelines to
Coincide with City Event Tier Categories – Presentation by Terrie Banish
• Recommendation: Adopt guidelines for consideration of any event support
requested of the TBID.
• Fiscal Impact (GL 2903): None.
7. Annual Marketing Report: Initial Draft of Report – Presented by Verdin
Marketing
• Recommendation: Receive draft of report and communicate edits and
adjustments prior to April 6 for inclusion in final version
• Fiscal Impact (GL 2201): None.
8. Industry Discussions: Initial discussion regarding short-term rentals and
Online Booking Scams Act – Discussion Led by Vice Chairperson Amar
Sohi
• Recommendation: Receive update from Amar Sohi and discuss if a formal
position from the Atascadero TBID should be communicated
• Fiscal Impact (GL N/A): None.
D. UPDATES
1. Visit SLO County TMD – JP Patel
2. Visit Atascadero Website – Amanda Diefenderfer
3. TBID Renewal Process – Amanda Diefenderfer
TBID 03.15.16 Page 002
a. Notification of board openings
b. Development of budget
c. Development of annual report and marketing plan
4. Deputy City Manager Update – Terrie Banish
a. TOT collection and reporting on a quarterly vs. monthly basis: results of
City Council February 23 vote
b. Billboard Update
c. Event Update
i. Chick City at the Zoo: March 20 – April 3 – Included with admission
to the Charles Paddock Zoo.
ii. Art & Wine Tour: March 25, 5:30 – 8:30 p.m. – Tickets available at
the corner of Entrada and El Camino Real for $15 each. Ticket
price includes a wine glass and tastings with participating
merchants in the downtown area. There will also be Historic City
Hall tours starting at 5:30 p.m. with the last tour beginning at 7:30
p.m.
iii. Brew at the Zoo: April 30, 5 – 8:30 p.m. – Early-bird tickets go on
sale April 1 at the Zoo for $30/ticket. Ticket price includes
commemorative glass, beer, cider and wine tasting, food for
purchase and live music.
iv. League of California Cities Channel Counties Division Dinner: April
15, 5 – 9 p.m. at the Historic City Hall – Evening to start with social
hour and tours of City Hall followed by dinner at 6:35 p.m. The
social hour will include wine, cider and beer sampling along with
appetizers.
v. Event Calendar: Now posted online at Atascadero.org and
VisitAtascadero.com
vi. Event Sponsors Update
5. Budget Report – Amanda Diefenderfer
6. Marketing Update – Verdin Marketing
a. Verdin Marketing Monthly Report
E. BOARD MEMBER COMMENTS
F. ADJOURNMENT
TBID 03.15.16 Page 003
Atascadero Tourism Business Improvement District (ATBID)
WELCOME TO THE ATBID MEETING
The ATBID Advisory Board meets in regular session on the third Tuesday of each month at 2:00 p.m.
Board meetings will be held at the Atascadero City Hall, 6500 Palma Avenue, Atascadero. Matters are
considered by the Advisory Board in the order of the printed Agenda.
Copies of the staff reports or other documentation relating to each item of business referred to on the
Agenda are on file in the office of the City Clerk and are available for public inspection during City Hall
business hours at the Atascadero City Hall, 6500 Palma Avenue, Atascadero, and on our website,
www.atascadero.org. All documents submitted by the public during Advisory Board meetings that are
either read into the record or referred to in their statement will be noted in the minutes and available for
review in the City Clerk's office.
In compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act, if you need special assistance to participate in
a City meeting or other services offered by this City, please contact the City Manager’s Office or the
City Clerk’s Office, both at (805) 470-3400. Notification at least 48 hours prior to the meeting or time
when services are needed will assist the City staff in assuring that reasonable arrangements can be
made to provide accessibility to the meeting or service.
TO SPEAK ON SUBJECTS NOT LISTED ON THE AGENDA
Under the Agenda item, “PUBLIC COMMENT”, the Chairperson will call for anyone from the audience
wishing to speak concerning any item not on the Agenda to approach the lectern and be recognized.
1. Give your name for the record (not required)
2. State the nature of your business.
3. All comments are limited to 3 minutes.
4. All comments should be made to the Chairperson and Advisory Board.
5. No person shall be permitted to make slanderous, profane or negative personal remarks
concerning any other individual, absent or present.
This is the time items not on the Agenda may be brought to the Advisory Board’s attention. A maximum
of 30 minutes will be allowed for PUBLIC COMMENT (unless changed by the Advisory Board). If you
wish to use a computer presentation to support your comments, you must notify the City Clerk's office at
least 24 hours prior to the meeting. Digital presentations must be brought to the meeting on a USB drive
or CD. You are required to submit to the City Clerk a printed copy of your presentation for the record.
Please check in with the City Clerk before the meeting begins to announce your presence and turn in
your printed copy.
TO SPEAK ON AGENDA ITEMS (from Title 2, Chapter 1 of the Atascadero Municipal Code)
Members of the audience may speak on any item on the agenda. The Chairperson will identify the
subject, staff will give their report, and the Advisory Board will ask questions of staff. The Chairperson will
announce when the public comment period is open and will request anyone interested to address the
Advisory Board regarding the matter being considered to step up to the lectern. If you wish to speak for,
against or comment in any way:
1. You must approach the lectern and be recognized by the Chairperson
2. Give your name (not required)
3. Make your statement
4. All comments should be made to the Chairperson and Advisory Board
5. No person shall be permitted to make slanderous, profane or negative personal remarks
concerning any other individual, absent or present
6. All comments limited to 3 minutes
The Chairperson will announce when the public comment period is closed, and thereafter, no further
public comments will be heard by the Advisory Board.
TBID 03.15.16 Page 004
Atascadero TBID
February 16, 2016
Page 1 of 6
ADVISORY BOARD FOR THE ATASCADERO TOURISM
BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT
DRAFT ACTION MINUTES
Tuesday, February 16, 2016 at 2:00 P.M.
Atascadero City Hall - 6500 Palma Avenue, Club Room
Atascadero, California
CALL TO ORDER:
Chairperson O’Malley called the meeting to order at 2:00 p.m.
ROLL CALL:
Present: Chairperson O’Malley, Board Members Alexander and Patel
Absent: Vice Chairperson Sohi (arrived later)
Staff Present: Destination Manager Amanda Diefenderfer, Marketing Consultant
Stephanie Goodwin, Marketing Consultant Ashlee Akers, Deputy
City Manager/ Outreach, Promotions, Events Terrie Banish and
Deputy City Clerk Lori Kudzma
APPROVAL OF AGENDA:
MOTION: By Board Member Patel and seconded by Board Member
Alexander to approve the agenda.
Motion passed 3:0 by a roll call vote.
PUBLIC COMMENT: None
TBID 03.15.16 Page 005
ITEM NUMBER: A-1
DATE: 03/15/16
Atascadero TBID
February 16, 2016
Page 2 of 6
A. CONSENT CALENDAR
1. Advisory Board Draft Action Minutes – January 19, 2016
• Action: Board approve the Draft Action Minutes of January 19, 2016. [City
Manager’s Office]
2. Atascadero TBID Nomination Draft Action Minutes – January 19, 2016
• Action: Board approve the Draft Action Minutes of January 19, 2016
Nomination Meeting. [City Manager’s Office]
MOTION: By Board Member Alexander and seconded by Board Member
Patel to approve the Consent Calendar.
Motion passed 3:0 by a roll call vote.
B. OATH OF OFFICE
1. Administration of Oath of Office – New Board Member Lindsey Ridgeway to
be sworn in by Deputy City Clerk Lori Kudzma
Deputy City Clerk Kudzma administered the Oath of Office to new Board Member
Lindsey Ridgeway.
Vice Chairperson Sohi arrived at 2:07 p.m.
C. BUSINESS ITEMS
1. Presentation from Paso Robles Wineries.net - Presentation from Lauren
Lekai
• Recommendation: Accept presentation and recommend to staff to connect
resource with selected web design firm for possible integration.
• Fiscal Impact (GL 2501): TBD based on selected resources and scope of
use.
Lauren Lekai from Paso Robles Wineries.net gave a presentation and answered
questions from the Board. Destination Manager Diefenderfer asked that the
information be sent to Verdin Marketing who will help make a recommendation to
the Board at a later date.
2. Directional Signage: Tesla Charging Station & Surrounding Activities -
Presented by Amar Sohi
• Recommendation: Recommend to staff and contractors to research
vendor options and associated costs to complete Tesla-related signage,
then to return to a future meeting with additional information.
• Fiscal Impact (GL 2403 & 2603): TBD
Vice Chairperson Sohi expressed interest in having signage at the charging
stations referring persons charging their vehicles to businesses downtown. There
TBID 03.15.16 Page 006
ITEM NUMBER: A-1
DATE: 03/15/16
Atascadero TBID
February 16, 2016
Page 3 of 6
was additional discussion regarding signage on the freeway alerting drivers of
the electric charging stations located in town.
Chairperson O’Malley asked that billboards be added to a future agenda.
There was Board consensus to
refer this item to staff for further review.
3. Community Event: Revisiting the Cow Parade – Discussion Requested by
Deana Alexander
• Recommendation: Pursue participation in the Cow Parade.
• Fiscal Impact (GL 2903): $3,500 - $20,000
Board Member Alexander had additional information and asked that the Board
reconsider participation in the Cow Parade.
PUBLIC COMMENT:
The following citizens spoke during Public Comment: Marie Ramey, Laure
Carlisle, Annie Weyrich, Marie Roth.
Chairperson O’Malley closed the PUBLIC COMMENT period.
There was Board discussion.
Chairperson O’Malley re-opened PUBLIC COMMENT.
The following citizens spoke during Public Comment: Marie Ramey and Laure
Carlisle.
Chairperson O’Malley closed PUBLIC COMMENT.
Chairperson O’Malley made a motion that was seconded by Board Member
Alexander to allocate $3,000 toward this project, with $2,000 going toward the
purchase of the cow and $1,000 to be leveraged with additional funds from the
City to specifically target out of area folks. Board Member Patel asked that the
maker consider amending the motion and there was further Board discussion.
Chairperson O’Malley withdrew his motion and made a new motion.
MOTION: By Chairperson O’Malley and seconded by Board Member
Alexander to allocate $2,500 to purchase a cow and that the
Board discuss the marketing dollars at a later date.
Motion passed 5:0 by a roll call vote.
TBID 03.15.16 Page 007
ITEM NUMBER: A-1
DATE: 03/15/16
Atascadero TBID
February 16, 2016
Page 4 of 6
4. Advertising Opportunity: Vintages Magazine – Report from Terrie Banish
• Recommendation: Pursue sharing placement in Vintages Magazine with
City of Atascadero including additional costs for design support from
Verdin.
• Fiscal Impact (GL 2603): $1,300 for ad placement. Design costs TBD.
Deputy City Manager Banish gave the staff report and answered questions from
the Board.
PUBLIC COMMENT:
The following citizens spoke during Public Comment: Linda Hendy and Annie
Weyrich.
Chairperson O’Malley closed the PUBLIC COMMENT period.
There was Board consensus to lean toward a bigger presence
in the publication and also coordinate with potential partners.
There will be no participation in this upcoming issue –
possibly next time with a full page integrated with other
partners and a call to action item for tracking purposes.
5. Visit SLO County Research Opportunity – Update from Amanda
Diefenderfer
• Recommendation: Participate in Visit SLO County visitor research survey
Destination Marketing Organization buy-in.
• Fiscal Impact (GL 2900): up to $2,500
Destination Manager Diefenderfer and Ashlee Akers from Verdin Marketing gave
an update and answered questions from the Board.
PUBLIC COMMENT: None.
There was Board consensus to partner with
the City and Chamber of Commerce on this opportunity.
6. Update on Visit Atascadero Website Progress – Update from Amanda
Diefenderfer
• Recommendation: Pursue contract with staff recommended firm resulting
from completion of second RFP process.
• Fiscal Impact (GL 2501): $35,000
Destination Manager Diefenderfer gave an update and answered questions from
the Board.
TBID 03.15.16 Page 008
ITEM NUMBER: A-1
DATE: 03/15/16
Atascadero TBID
February 16, 2016
Page 5 of 6
PUBLIC COMMENT:
The following citizens spoke during Public Comment: Linda Hendy, Annie
Weyrich, and Tamrah Michael.
Chairperson O’Malley closed the PUBLIC COMMENT period.
There was Board consensus to move on with the RFP process.
7. Atascadero TBID Renewal and Board Terms - Review Timeline and Next
Steps - Presentation from Amanda Diefenderfer
• Recommendation: Recommend to staff and marketing firm to complete
Atascadero TBID renewal information and board nomination process as
noted in the timeline.
• Fiscal Impact (GL 2201 & 2202): None
Destination Manager Diefenderfer gave the staff report and answered questions
from the Board.
PUBLIC COMMENT: None
The Board received and filed this update.
8. Event Tiers - Review Event Tiers as defined in the “Atascadero Tourism &
Promotion Game Plan” by the Coraggio Group and discuss how that
applies to the TBID Program- Discussion with Terrie Banish and Amanda
Diefenderfer
• Recommendation: Recommend to staff further clarification to event tier
definitions as well as qualification of the Event Tiers with regard to
communicating and promoting those events utilizing TBID resources.
• Fiscal Impact (GL 2903): None
Deputy City Manager Banish gave the staff report. Deputy City Manager Banish,
Destination Manager Diefenderfer and the consultants from Verdin Marketing
answered questions from the Board.
PUBLIC COMMENT:
The following citizens spoke during Public Comment: Annie Weyrich and Linda
Hendy.
Chairperson O’Malley closed the PUBLIC COMMENT period.
TBID 03.15.16 Page 009
ITEM NUMBER: A-1
DATE: 03/15/16
Atascadero TBID
February 16, 2016
Page 6 of 6
There was Board consensus to have staff
prepare a TBID screening packet for vendors and events.
D. UPDATES
1. Visit SLO County TMD – JP Patel
2. Visit SLO County Educational Symposium – Jessica Sohi
3. Confirmation of Appointment of Lindsey Ridgeway to ATBID Board - Amanda
Diefenderfer
Chairperson O’Malley welcomed Lindsey Ridgeway and she gave brief
comments about joining the Board.
4. Deputy City Manager Update – Terrie Banish
a. Results of City Council meeting: Update on TOT collection and reporting
on a quarterly vs. monthly basis
Deputy City Manager Banish let the Board know this will be going
to City Council on the February 23rd agenda.
b. SEO Keyword Update for www.VisitAtascadero.com
c. Results of SF Chronicle Placement
5. Budget Report – Amanda Diefenderfer
6. Marketing Update – Verdin Marketing
a. Verdin Marketing Monthly Report
Verdin Marketing gave a brief presentation and answered
questions.
Chairperson O’Malley suggested that Verdin’s presentation be
moved earlier on future agendas.
E. BOARD MEMBER COMMENTS
F. ADJOURNMENT
Chairperson O’Malley adjourned the meeting at 4:37 p.m.
MINUTES PREPARED BY:
Lori M. Kudzma, Deputy City Clerk
TBID 03.15.16 Page 010
ITEM NUMBER: A-1
DATE: 03/15/16
TBID 03.15.16 Page 011
ITEM NUMBER: B-1
DATE: 03/15/16
TBID 03.15.16 Page 012
ITEM NUMBER: B-1
DATE: 03/15/16
TBID 03.15.16 Page 013
ITEM NUMBER: B-1
DATE: 03/15/16
TBID 03.15.16 Page 014
ITEM NUMBER: B-1
DATE: 03/15/16
TBID 03.15.16 Page 015
ITEM NUMBER: B-1
DATE: 03/15/16
TBID 03.15.16 Page 016ITEM NUMBER: B-2DATE: 03/15/16
Cider Festival Updates
•May 7, 2016 - 5 – 8:30 pm
•Atascadero Lake Pavilion
•Chef Jeffery Scott, Vineyard Events
•Festival Announcement – March 2
•Press Release
•Paso Robles Daily News
•A-Town News
•Liquid Lunch on KRUSH Radio
•SLO Tribune
•KSBY
•Wine Industry Network
•Media interest is growing
•Visit Atascadero – consider opportunity to host media for the festival weekend
•Recent media coverage – 3/8 NBC Bay Area News, Worth the Trip
http://www.nbcbayarea.com/blogs/worth-the-trip/
•Feature 15 + cider vendors from across the Central Coast
•Bristols, Tin City, Reef Points, Scar of the Sea, Jean Marie,
See Canyon TBID 03.15.16 Page 017ITEM NUMBER: B-2DATE: 03/15/16
TBID 03.15.16 Page 018ITEM NUMBER: B-2DATE: 03/15/16
Cider Festival Marketing Updates
• Tickets on Sale – March 15
• $50 Tickets – March 15 – 31, 2016
• $60 – April 1 – Until Sold Out
• Media partnership – AGM Radio
• www.CentralCoastCiderFestival.com
• Email List – Growing
• Social Media Channels
• Facebook: CentralCoastCiderFestival
• Twitter: CCCiderFest
• Verdin – Collaboration for social media, eblasts, calendar of events,
etc.
• City of Atascadero – banner, website, etc. TBID 03.15.16 Page 019ITEM NUMBER: B-2DATE: 03/15/16
Cider Festival Updates
• Atascadero Economic Foundation – MOU – Complete
• Insurance – Complete
• City Contract – Working with Terrie on contract
• Sponsorships – discussing with other complementary
partners TBID 03.15.16 Page 020ITEM NUMBER: B-2DATE: 03/15/16
Cider Festival Next Steps
• Finalize Cider Producers
• Logistics
• Event Décor/layout
• Sponsorship commitments
• Shuttles – confirm route and schedule for Atascadero
Hotels
• Volunteer recruitment
• Questions? TBID 03.15.16 Page 021ITEM NUMBER: B-2DATE: 03/15/16
3/8/16, 9:40 PMNew: Central Coast Cider Festival | NBC Bay Area
Page 1 of 3http://www.printthis.clickability.com/pt/cpt?expire=&title=New%3A+Ce…%2Fworth-the-trip%2FNew-Central-Coast-Cider-Festival-371332551.html
THAT AMBER, APPLE-Y BREW: The Golden State is rich in gold-libation'd
gatherings that put the focus on foam, as in beer, as in the best quality brews that
are staples of California's top-notch craft breweries. But another brew is on the
rise-and-rise, a distinct but friendly cousin, if you will, to ale, but with whole fruit-
Powered by
New: Central Coast Cider Festival
Try a host of tawny elixirs in Atascadero in early May.
By Alysia Gray Painter
Central Coast Cider Festival
Try a host of tawny elixirs in Atascadero in early May.
TBID 03.15.16 Page 022
ITEM NUMBER: B-2
DATE: 03/15/16
3/8/16, 9:40 PMNew: Central Coast Cider Festival | NBC Bay Area
Page 2 of 3http://www.printthis.clickability.com/pt/cpt?expire=&title=New%3A+Ce…%2Fworth-the-trip%2FNew-Central-Coast-Cider-Festival-371332551.html
forward profile. It's cider of which we speak, that apple-amazing, powerful-to-the-
palate beverage that isn't just a deeper drink for autumn or winter. If beautiful core-
centered, seed-sweet apples are about, it is time for cider, whether the calendar
says it is fall or spring. A spring fling of the most flavorful sort is just ahead, in
Atascadero. If the notion of hard cider plus the pretty Central Coast town make
you think of Bristols Cider, well, you've raised the right glass: Neil Collins, the cider
pro behind Bristols, wanted "to celebrate the local cider movement," on that
continues to grow as wineries step beyond the grape and get to know the many
sippable sides to the apple. Mr. Collins is also a vintner at Lone Madrone and
Table Creek, so call the Central Coast Cider Festival, which will happen on
Saturday, May 7, a treat for those gourmands of both vino and beverages that
began with something sweet plucked from the branch of a tree. The pre-sale
begins on...
MARCH 15, when tickets'll go for fifty bucks (the end date on that deal is April 1).
After the first of April, tickets are available for sixty dollars. That ticket will put you
front-and-center before about 15 to 20 regional cider makers, including Tin City
Cider of Templeton, not to mention Scar of the Sea and See Canyon. The
Atascadero Lake Pavilion is the place, and a traditional pig roast, with Chef Jeffrey
Scott of Vineyard Events at the helm, will lend the day its centerpiece feast. Music,
that Atascadero charm, and apple-y bevs that would do California's craft brews
and fine wines proud will fill the first Saturday in May, a day that's quite far from fall
(further proving that a stellar cider is a year-round sip).
Published 6 hours ago
Copyright NBC Owned Television Stations
Find this article at:
TBID 03.15.16 Page 023
ITEM NUMBER: B-2
DATE: 03/15/16
!
!
!FOR!IMMEDIATE!RELEASE!!
!
MEDIA!CONTACT!
Joel!Peterson,!Solterra!Strategies!
805?610?2204,!joel@solterrastrategies.com!!
!
New$Central$Coast$Cider$Festival$Debuts$in$Atascadero$on$May$7$
Pre$Sale$Savings$Begins$March$15$
$
March!2,!2016!(Atascadero,!CA)!–!Cider!producers!on!California’s!Central!Coast!announced!a!new!
festival!to!be!held!Saturday,!May!7!at!the!Atascadero!Pavilion!on!the!Lake.!The!Central!Coast!Cider!
Festival,!a!vision!of!Neil!Collins,!co?owner!of!Bristols!Cider,!is!dedicated!to!celebrating!the!local!
cider!movement,!a!complement!to!the!area’s!fine!wine!country.!A!partnership!with!Visit!Atascadero,!
the!local!tourism!board!and!the!City!of!Atascadero!provided!a!three?year!commitment!to!launch!the!
new!festival!embracing!the!cider!movement.!Presale!savings!for!attendees!begins!March!15.!Tickets!
are!available!for!$50!until!April!1!when!they!go!up!to!$60.!Space!is!limited!for!the!inaugural!event.!!
!
The!cider!revolution!happening!across!America!is!growing!at!a!tremendous!rate!with!cider!sales!
now!accounting!for!more!than!one?percent!of!all!sales!in!the!vast!beer!category.!Locally,!it’s!all!
about!winemakers!making!cider!to!embrace!the!trend.!Collins,!a!winemaker!for!Lone!Madrone!and!
Tablas!Creek!wanted!to!make!a!hard!cider!reminiscent!of!the!traditional!beverage!of!his!homeland,!
Bristol!–!located!in!the!West!Country!of!England.!Andrew!Jones,!winemaker!of!Field!Recordings!is!
the!co?owner!and!cider!maker!of!Tin!City,!a!new!cider!product!that!hit!shelves!in!2015.!!
!
“I’ve!been!making!cider!since!1994!then!in!2014!we!saw!the!trend!taking!off!which!led!to!our!
expanded!production!facility!and!Bristols!Cider!House!tasting!room!in!Atascadero,”!said!Collins.!
“We!moved!in!just!in!time!for!2014!harvest!and!found!ourselves!expanding!in!2015!to!a!second!
space!next!door!giving!us!more!than!5,000!square!feet!of!production!space.”!!
!
Tin!City!Cider!is!opening!a!new!expanded!space!in!Templeton’s!Tin!City!in!spring!2016.!The!new!
Central!Coast!Cider!Festival!will!feature!15?20!cider!producers!each!with!his/her!own!unique!story.!
Producers!who!have!already!signed!up!for!the!inaugural!event!include:!Bristols,!Jean!Marie,!Reef!
Points,!Scar!of!the!Sea,!See!Canyon!and!Tin!City.!Producers!interested!in!participating!should!
contact!Jennifer!Bravo!with!Solterra!Strategies.!!
!
The!cider!revolution!is!happening.!The!new!Central!Coast!Cider!Festival!is!a!culmination!of!this!craft!
beverage!giving!attendees!a!great!opportunity!to!taste!a!variety!of!ciders,!meet!the!cider!makers,!
enjoy!a!traditional!pig!roast!prepared!by!Chef!Jeffrey!Scott!of!Vineyard!Events,!listen!to!live!music!
and!enjoy!the!community!of!Atascadero.!!
!
Date:!!!Saturday,!May!7!at!5!pm!
Location:!!Atascadero!Lake!Pavilion!!
Tickets:!!Pre!Sale!–!March!15?31;!$50;!April!1!–!$60!
Website:!!www.centralcoastciderfestival.com!!
Social!Media:!!Facebook:!Central!Coast!Cider!Festival!!
Twitter:!CCCiderFestival!https://twitter.com/CCCiderFestival!!
Instagram:!CCCiderFestival!https://www.instagram.com/ccciderfestival/!!
TBID 03.15.16 Page 024
ITEM NUMBER: B-2
DATE: 03/15/16
!
!
About$Visit$Atascadero:!!
Atascadero,!CA!is!located!midway!between!Los!Angeles!and!San!Francisco!along!the!famed!Highway!
101.!Conveniently!located!near!all!San!Luis!Obispo!County!has!to!offer,!Atascadero!hosts!the!best!of!
the!Central!Coast!with!its!strong!historical!roots,!sweeping!pastoral!vistas!and!Americana!charm.!
For! more! travel! information! visit!www.visitatascadero.com!or! follow! Atascadero! on!Facebook,!
Twitter!and!Instagram.!!
!
#!#!#!
TBID 03.15.16 Page 025
ITEM NUMBER: B-2
DATE: 03/15/16
ATBID Protocol for Reimbursing Accommodation Support
ACCEPTED: October 20, 2015
Goal: Make hosting outreach as convenient and productive as possible while giving ATBID
members the opportunity to showcase their property through media and promotional
opportunities.
Media Hosting Opportunity Outreach:
1. Send media hosting opportunity through eBlast resource to all accommodations. If the
situation allows, request that hoteliers respond within three business days of the
release of the opportunity. Request 20% off rack rate or comp rooms.
2. Destination Manager to receive list of offers and rates and will choose a hosting
property based on comp vs. reduction of rack rate, previously awarded opportunities
and story angle which property is best fit.
3. Destination Manager to maintain a list of awarded opportunities so as to answer any
retrospective inquiries about the selection process.
Hosting Informational Guidelines:
1. Property to be provided with media hosting form that includes full media contact
information and media instructions/guidelines.
2. Hosting property may send hotel confirmation to journalist along with a brief
introduction.
3. Possible coordination of property tour with a manager position should the situation
allow and be a good fit.
TBID 03.15.16 Page 026
ITEM NUMBER: B-3
DATE: 3/15/16
2015-16 Marketing Plan
Event Guidelines & Update
ATBID
Board Meeting
March 15, 2016 TBID 03.15.16 Page 027ITEM NUMBER: B-6DATE: 03/15/16
Coraggio Tourism & Promotion Game Plan
Event Tier Review TBID 03.15.16 Page 028ITEM NUMBER: B-6DATE: 03/15/16
Event Tier Guidelines - ATBID
Tier 1 Events: Large Signature Events
◦ Multi day stay (2+ days)
◦ Draws People from outside the county
◦ Supports vision and goals of ATBID
◦ Significant ROI
◦ 5000+ people
◦ Established Event
◦ ATBID Focus
◦ Examples: Cruisin’ Weekend expansion of “Dancing in the
Streets”, Atascadero Wine Festival
TBID 03.15.16 Page 029ITEM NUMBER: B-6DATE: 03/15/16
Event Tier Guidelines - ATBID
Tier 2 Events: Signature Event
◦ Single Day with potential for Multi Day (1-2 days)
◦ Draws People from outside the city
◦ Supports vision and goals of ATBID and City
◦ Positive ROI
◦ 400- 5000 people
◦ Established or a New Event
◦ ATBID Focus
◦ Examples: Cider Festival, Tamale Festival TBID 03.15.16 Page 030ITEM NUMBER: B-6DATE: 03/15/16
Event Tier Guidelines - ATBID
Tier 3 Events: Single Day Events
◦ Single Day Event
◦ Draws People visiting the county as well as local and county
residents with the potential to spend the night in a hotel in the
future
◦ Supports vision and goals of ATBID and City
◦ Positive ROI
◦ 400-1000 people
◦ Established or a New Event or a One Time Event
◦ ATBID Potential
◦ Examples: Brew at the Zoo, Cow Parade, Community labeled
events like Tuesday BBQ in the Park TBID 03.15.16 Page 031ITEM NUMBER: B-6DATE: 03/15/16
t (805) 541-9005 f (805) 541-9007
3580 Sacramento Drive #110, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401
VERDINMARKETING.COM
MARKETING ANNUAL REVIEW
ATBID MARKETING MARCH 2015 – FEBRUARY 2016
March 7, 2016
SUMMARY
Verdin began working with the Atascadero Tourism Business Improvement District (ATBID) in March 2015 and since
then this partnership has made tremendous strides forward in marketing Atascadero to visitors. In collaboration with
the city, new branding was developed after a long, thoughtful process, which included a new logo, brand guidelines and
clear messaging. The implementation of the new brand was rolled out through advertising, social media and public
relations.
GOALS
Verdin’s goal was to create and implement a marketing strategy to position Atascadero as a desirable destination on
the Central Coast.
1. Increase overnight stays in Atascadero, for hotel/motel accommodations.
2. Build Atascadero, California brand awareness.
3. Target new visitors to engage in programs and increase awareness.
STRATEGIES
Marketing Plan
A Marketing Plan was created for the destination outlining key goals, metrics, tactics and research.
1. Outline of personas
a. Identified target audience both geographic markets
i. Bay Area, Los Angeles, Central Valley
b. Behavioral markets
i. Millennials, families, retirees, couples and “bleisure” travels (business/leisure travel)
2. Creative concepts, messaging and points of differentiation
3. Brand Blueprint - A brand blueprint was created as an internal guideline for all outward destination
communications
TBID 03.15.16 Page 032
ITEM NUMBER: B-7
DATE: 03/15/16
t (805) 541-9005 f (805) 541-9007
3580 Sacramento Drive #110, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401
VERDINMARKETING.COM
2
Identity and Branding
Verdin assessed old branding and made recommendations on how to more accurately represent Atascadero.
1. New logos created for regional and out of town marketing
2. Tagline created – “Simply Genuine”
3. Brand guidelines created – Appendix A
a. Font selections
b. Proper use of logos
4. Internal Brand Tone sheet for use in all online communications – Appendix B
5. Established icons and treatments for branded social media posts
Advertising
Verdin created and launched two marketing campaigns during the shoulder season. The first campaign, for Quarter 4
2015, was “California as it used to be,” a general introduction to Atascadero to our target audiences. The second
advertising campaign for Quarter 1 2016 was the “101 Road Trip.” Verdin also created print ads for Savor, the SF
Chronicle, Visit SLO County Visitors Guide and Access Publishing’s Visitor Guide.
DIGITAL ADVERTISING
The digital media outlets used for both campaigns were Facebook, Trip Advisor and Pandora.
QUARTER 4 – 2015
TBID 03.15.16 Page 033
ITEM NUMBER: B-7
DATE: 03/15/16
t (805) 541-9005 f (805) 541-9007
3580 Sacramento Drive #110, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401
VERDINMARKETING.COM
3
QUARTER 1 – 2016
PROMOTION
Verdin is currently running the 101 Road Trip contest for Q1 advertising. The contest has three different creative aspects
(see above) each targeting separate demographics: couples, families and group travelers. The contest is being
promoted through social media, Facebook ads and the monthly e-newsletter. The goal of the contest is to collect email
contacts for the e-newsletter list. We currently have 226 entries. The contest prize is a $500 value including two nights
of winner's choosing (via http://www.visitatascadero.com/lodging), and a gift card for the remaining amount from the
$500 total (e.g. if two night stay is $300, a $200 gift card will be included). Prize will be awarded on or about May 7,
2016 and must be used by winner no later than July 31, 2016.
PRINT ADVERTISING
The print publications were Vintages Magazine (Savor), the SF Chronicle, Visit SLO County Visitors Guide and Access
Publishing’s Visitor Guide.
TBID 03.15.16 Page 034
ITEM NUMBER: B-7
DATE: 03/15/16
t (805) 541-9005 f (805) 541-9007
3580 Sacramento Drive #110, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401
VERDINMARKETING.COM
4
DIGITAL METRICS
Facebook Advertising November 2015–February 2016
1. Total Impressions: 301,931
2. Total clicks to website: 7,397
3. Average Click Through Rate: 2.46%
Trip Advisor December 2015–February 2016
1. Total Impressions: 203,838
2. Total clicks to website: 265
3. Average Click Through Rate: .14%
Pandora December 2015–February 2016
1. Total Impressions: 1,177,521
2. Total clicks to website: 3,769
3. Average Click Through Rate: .62%
TBID 03.15.16 Page 035
ITEM NUMBER: B-7
DATE: 03/15/16
t (805) 541-9005 f (805) 541-9007
3580 Sacramento Drive #110, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401
VERDINMARKETING.COM
5
Social Media
Verdin executed a robust social media strategy using Facebook, Instagram and Twitter. The below summary is for
activity from July 2015–February 2016.
FACEBOOK
1. Facebook Fans: Increased fans by
1,209 (3,398 v. 4,607)
2. Total Referrals: 3,371
3. Total Reach: 40,186
4. Average Engagement Rate: 8%
INSTAGRAM
We created a branded Instagram page and
engaged with a total of 185 followers and
followed relevant travel bloggers, writers
and influencers.
TWITTER
Our strategy for Twitter is to post events,
activities and promotions between 4–5 times
per week. We have gained 75 new followers
since July 2015.
TBID 03.15.16 Page 036
ITEM NUMBER: B-7
DATE: 03/15/16
t (805) 541-9005 f (805) 541-9007
3580 Sacramento Drive #110, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401
VERDINMARKETING.COM
6
Website
Verdin began updating the VisitAtascadero.com website in July 2015. Below is a summary of activities through
February 2016.
1. Full website assessment with recommendations on SEO and content enhancements
2. Background color and logo based on new brand
3. Updated restaurant listings
4. Added 101 Road Trip contest landing page
METRICS
1. Total Traffic to Site: 28,416
2. Total Mobile Visits: 12,389
3. Total Desktop Visits: 11,947
4. Total Unique Visitors: 25,485
5. Top Geographic Referrals
a. September 2015: Atascadero, San Francisco, Los Angeles, San Luis Obispo, Paso Robles
b. February 2016: San Francisco, Los Angeles, Atascadero, San Luis Obispo, Sacramento
TBID 03.15.16 Page 037
ITEM NUMBER: B-7
DATE: 03/15/16
t (805) 541-9005 f (805) 541-9007
3580 Sacramento Drive #110, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401
VERDINMARKETING.COM
7
Public Relations
PRESS RELEASES
Verdin sent two press releases the first, in October 2015, as a general introduction to Atascadero to travel writers and
the second, in February 2016, with a romantic angle highlighting activities for couples.
Received coverage from two travel sites, Luxurystandard.com and Minnesota Girl in the World travel blog.
MEDIA RELATIONS
Verdin sent responses to the media interested in writing about Atascadero and put writers through a vetting process
for potential FAM visits in Atascadero. Verdin also managed reactive pitches for Atascadero when opportunities arose.
E-newsletter
Verdin created an e-newsletter template and began
distribution December 2015. Below are all activities through
February 2016.
1. Crafted and distributed monthly e-newsletters
content, promotions and images
2. 2,000 recipients to date
3. Average open rate: 20.6% (Industry avg. 16.6%)
4. Average click through rate: 5.2 % (Industry avg. 1.8%)
TBID 03.15.16 Page 038
ITEM NUMBER: B-7
DATE: 03/15/16
t (805) 541-9005 f (805) 541-9007
3580 Sacramento Drive #110, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401
VERDINMARKETING.COM
8
APPENDIX A
TBID 03.15.16 Page 039
ITEM NUMBER: B-7
DATE: 03/15/16
Brand Identity Guidelines
OCTOBER 2015
TBID 03.15.16 Page 040
ITEM NUMBER: B-7
DATE: 03/15/16
2
Become a
Visit Atascadero
brand ambassador.
The two most important ingredients of a successful brand
identity are consistency and time.
Your new brand identity is warm, classic and friendly with
a color palette reflective of the vibrant feel of the location
it serves. The following guidelines will help you build
and maintain your new brand identity, helping you make
choices that, with time, will solidify your brand.
TBID 03.15.16 Page 041
ITEM NUMBER: B-7
DATE: 03/15/16
BRAND IDENTITY STANDARDS Visit Atascadero
Logo
Full Color
The full color Visit Atascadero logo should be used as
often as possible to build a strong brand identity.
Black
8se this version of the logo when it is represented at very
sPall si]e under . in. :henever possible please defer to
the other options.
Grayscale
Use this logo when printing in black and white, for
example, in a newspaper publication.
Full Color Reverse
8se this logo when the logo is placed over a darN
background. This is the second most preferred logo option.
White
,f the logo is ever placed on a darN bacNground or
darN photo and the full color reverse logo doesnot
worN the white version of the logo could be used. ,n
all other scenarios, defer to the full color or full color
reverse versions to properly coPPunicate warPth and
friendliness of the Visit Atascadero brand.PREFERRED TBID 03.15.16 Page 042
ITEM NUMBER: B-7
DATE: 03/15/16
4
Logo
Visit Atascadero—California
8se the p&aliforniaq version on Paterials
with potential to be seen from out of
San Luis Obispo County. This is important
in establishing Atascadero as a classic
California town.
Visit Atascadero—Simply Genuine
The p6iPply *enuineq version is for use on
materials that will be seen within San Luis
Obispo County to properly express the
personality of the Visit Atascadero brand
to SLO County residents who are already
familiar with Atascadero.
Variations
There are two versions of the 9isit $tascadero logo. The logo usage guidelines as
e[plained on the previous page apply to both versions. /ogo usage for these two
versions is e[plained below.
TBID 03.15.16 Page 043
ITEM NUMBER: B-7
DATE: 03/15/16
BRAND IDENTITY STANDARDS Visit Atascadero
Logo
White Space
When placing the logo with other artwork, please maintain a padding of white space
around the logo the height of the “A” all the way around the logo. No image or other text
should extend into this padding.
Enough
white space
around logo
Crowded by
elements
CORRECT
INCORRECT
TBID 03.15.16 Page 044
ITEM NUMBER: B-7
DATE: 03/15/16
6
Logo
Logo Sizing
The minimum sizes below show the smallest size the Visit Atascadero logos should be used.
Logo Usage
$lways use 9isit $tascadero logos in their original proportions and never stretch the
logos. To Neep the integrity of the logo design never alter color shape or elePent.
Angled
Incorrect colors
6tretched vertically
Altered logo integrity
Stretched horizontally
INCORRECT
FULL COLOR
ONE COLOR.35” height
.5” height
CORRECT
TBID 03.15.16 Page 045
ITEM NUMBER: B-7
DATE: 03/15/16
BRAND IDENTITY STANDARDS Visit Atascadero
Logo
Backgrounds
6oPetiPes the logo will be placed over iPages or visually coPple[ bacNgrounds. $lways
make sure the logo can be easily seen. The full color logo is preferred, but the full color
reversed logo is acceptable over photos if there is enough contrast so can be easily seen.
The left column shows incorrect logo usage, the right column shows correct usage.
TBID 03.15.16 Page 046
ITEM NUMBER: B-7
DATE: 03/15/16
8
Typefaces
Sans Serif
Ubuntu - all styles are acceptable for use in copy, headers, subheads,
display styles. Use “Regular” for body copy.
Serif
Lora - all styles are acceptable for use in copy, headers, subheads,
display styles. Use “Regular” for body copy.
All of the brand typefaces can be downloaded from http://www.google.com/webfonts
and are free for personal or commercial use. See bottom of page for an example of how
the fonts can be used together.
Header Example
SUBHEAD EXAMPLE
+iciaP voluptas siPusdanto voluptatet aceperio teP Tuo dolora doluptatet
volestibus aliTuat lant elianduntior si aut oƯciusdae e[cero Tue volupta testiuP
antiis ipsaP oPnitiuP Tuodi occus dus dolor Podiat a niaeruP estia dipsapis
reptasped ullaP Tuis sero Paio. (t autePporibus dolupta tiuriberis aute voluptaTui
res si veniandit totas PodipsuP sapic totat optae. 1aP aut et oPPoloruP labo. (t
Polupta pe eturia vellore ptiunt volupta nissecto beat TuaP ipsaPe voluptatur re
neP TuissitiuP lat harunt.
TBID 03.15.16 Page 047
ITEM NUMBER: B-7
DATE: 03/15/16
BRAND IDENTITY STANDARDS Visit Atascadero
E.G. Lewis
Red
PANTONE 7417C
C 1 | M 83 | Y 85 | K 0
R 224 | G 78 | B 57
HTML #E04E39
True
Blue
Denim
Blue
Sky
Blue
Gold
Stone
Earth
Color Palette
E.G. Lewis Red and True Blue are the two primary colors in the Visit Atascadero color
palette. Denim Blue, Sky Blue, Stone and Earth are secondary colors that are used to
support the priPary colors. 6tone should never be used for copy. )or body copy only use
90% black.
Secondary Colors
Primary Colors
PANTONE 7697C
C 76 | M 34 | Y 21 | K 09
R 78 | G 138 | B 160
HTML #4E87A0
PANTONE WARM GRAY 1
C 3 | M 3 | Y 6 | K 7
R 215 | G 210 | B 203
HTML #D7D2CB
PANTONE WARM GRAY 5
C 11 | M 13 | Y 16 | K 32
R 172 | G 163 | B 154
HTML #ACA39A
PANTONE 7545C
C 58 | M 32 | Y 18 | K 54
R 66 | G 85 | B 99
HTML #425563
PANTONE 544C
C 27 | M 4 | Y 1 | K 1
R 189 | G 214 | B 230
HTML #BDD6E6
PANTONE 143C
C 0 | M 32 | Y 87 | K 0
R 241 | G 180 | B 52
HTML #F1B434
TBID 03.15.16 Page 048
ITEM NUMBER: B-7
DATE: 03/15/16
t (805) 541-9005 f (805) 541-9007
3580 Sacramento Drive #110, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401
VERDINMARKETING.COM
9
APPENDIX B
TBID 03.15.16 Page 049
ITEM NUMBER: B-7
DATE: 03/15/16
ATASCADERO: AT A GLANCE
Imagery
Tone
Notes
YES
Down-home
Local
Salt of the Earth
Warm
Friendly
Welcoming
Casual
NO
Pretentious
Sarcastic
Quirky
Tongue-in-cheek
Weird
Cheesy
YES
Compelling
High quality
People engaging
in activities
NO
Low quality
Unprofessional
Obvious
photoshopping
• Only link to city site if absolutely necessary.
Otherwise, link to visitatascadero.com
Atascadero is a beautiful and authentic city of outdoor recreation, culinary adventures, and welcoming
hospitality. It’s a safe place where the arts and history thrive, and the diversity of experience, generosity
of spirit, and small-town ambiance are here to be enjoyed by visitors and residents alike.TBID 03.15.16 Page 050ITEM NUMBER: B-7DATE: 03/15/16
02.08.2016
ATBID
PROPOSAL
PO BOX 4310 • PASO ROBLES • CALIFORNIA • 93446
p 805.434.9994 • f 805.434.9995 • WWW.CLEVERCONCEPTS.NET
Terrie Banish
Atascadero Tourism Business Improvement District
6904 El Camino Real
Atascadero, CA 93422
Dear Terrie,
Thank you for the opportunity to present a proposal for the design and development of the VisitAtascadero.com web site.
INTRODUCTION
Clever Concepts is a high-end web development company based in Paso Robles, CA. We specialize in custom web sites
that look professional, are functional, and fully meet each clients’ needs and expectations. Clever Concepts was started
in 1998. We have since created nearly 1,000 web sites. When you choose Clever Concepts you are guaranteed excellent
programming, design, and customer service.
Our team is comprised of:
Dennis Clevenger - Dennis is responsible for all of the business dealings of the business and handles the majority of
interaction with the customer. He also handles all of the programming of the web sites. Dennis has been building web
sites since 1994. He graduated from Cal Poly with a degree in Graphic Communication in 2000. He lives in Templeton
with his wife, Jeni, and daughters, Ella and Emma.
Nolan Henderson - Nolan is responsible for creating the design and ensuring it maintains his original vision throughout
the web development process. Nolan has been designing web sites since 2006. He graduated from Cal Poly with a
degree in Graphic Communication in 2007. He lives in Atascadero with his wife, Rebecca, and daughters, Abigail and
Annabella.
While our team only consists of two people, our process has been refined over the years to allow us to be extremely
productive and efficient. We work right along side each other and are constantly looking out for each other to ensure we
deliver the best product possible. We do not outsource any of the development of the web site.
PORTFOLIO
Our portfolio can be found online at:
TBID 03.15.16 Page 051
ITEM NUMBER: D-2
DATE: 03/15/16
02.08.2016
ATBID
PROPOSAL
PO BOX 4310 • PASO ROBLES • CALIFORNIA • 93446
p 805.434.9994 • f 805.434.9995 • WWW.CLEVERCONCEPTS.NET
http://www.cleverconcepts.net/portfolio/
Some similar projects that we have created include:
Atascadero Chamber of Commerce - http://www.atascaderochamber.org/
Paso Robles Wine Country Alliance - http://www.pasowine.com/
Temecula Valley Winegrowers - http://www.temeculawines.org/
Note: these web sites are a few years old and do not represent the latest in design trends, mobile viewing, etc.
Examples of some more recent web sites include:
Hope Family Wines - http://www.hopefamilywines.com/
Paderewski Festival - http://www.paderewskifest.com/
Luna Red - http://www.lunaredslo.com/
LAYOUT AND DESIGN
The design and layout of the web site will be the first step of the project. In order to design the site, Clever Concepts will
need copies of any current promotional materials, logo(s), photos, and other materials in order to get a feel of the image
you are looking for. We will set up a time to discuss the design and get a feel for your organization. The design will be
clean, professional and will be both information and visual appealing. It will be designed to be responsive so it will nicely
display on all devices. It will contain an area for social links, mailing list signup, and any other items you want to feature
on all pages. A basic layout will be created and reviewed before development of the content begins.
The design process includes one major revision and 5 minor revisions. A major revision is defined as completely
disregarding the initial design and developing a new one. A minor revision is defined as a change of colors and fonts,
rearranging design elements, and other minor changes. Clever Concepts will work in close contact with you throughout
the design process to ensure your complete satisfaction.
CONTENT
We will work with you to determine the best organization of the web site. We will use the existing VisitAtascadero.com
web site as a starting point and plan for the best organization of the information. We will populate all of the initial web
site content, delivering you a 100% complete web site. Content can either be taken from the current web site or new
content can be supplied electronically.
TBID 03.15.16 Page 052
ITEM NUMBER: D-2
DATE: 03/15/16
02.08.2016
ATBID
PROPOSAL
PO BOX 4310 • PASO ROBLES • CALIFORNIA • 93446
p 805.434.9994 • f 805.434.9995 • WWW.CLEVERCONCEPTS.NET
CONTENT MANAGEMENT SYSTEM
We have a solid reputation of building completely custom Content Management Systems (CMS) for our customers. Many
customers come to us after having used other CMS tools that are too complex. We highly recommend a custom CMS so
we can build out tools that perfectly fit your web site needs. If a custom CMS is not desired, we also are happy to build
the site in WordPress. We will set up a meeting to demonstrate our tools and compare them to WordPress to allow you
to make an informed decision on the approach that will work best for your organization.
Based on going with a custom CMS, the below custom tools will be created:
BASE CONTENT MANAGEMENT SYSTEM
The base installation of our CMS drives all of the navigation and static content on the web site. You will be able to add,
edit, and delete pages. The CMS also allows you to define URLs for pages, page titles, and meta data, all of which are
important for your search engine visibility. Each page will also likely have a header photo and the CMS will allow you to
easily manage the header photos. You will be able to define if pages should show in the main navigation, subnavigation,
and any other navigational elements the site ends up having.
To edit the content of each page, we will set up a web-based WYSIWYG web page editor that works on Internet Explorer,
Firefox, Chrome and Safari and functions much like Microsoft Word.
The web page CMS will be used for all of the web pages that have what we call “static content”, which is content that’s
not necessarily suited to go in to a database. For pages that are suited to be database-driven, we will create additional
custom tools to easily manage these pages as outlined below.
HOME PAGE SLIDESHOW
The home page will likely feature a slideshow of images, possibly with some content overlaid on them and a link to
another page. We will create an administration tool to allow you to easily add, delete and sort the slides. Slides will be
able to be flagged as hidden so you can archive slides and easily re-enable them later.
BUSINESS LISTINGS
A good portion of the web site will be business listings for lodging, dining and beer and wine. We will create a custom
business listing system to drive these section. The business listings tool will allow you to define 2 levels of categories.
Each category will be able to have an unlimited number of businesses within it. Each business will have various
TBID 03.15.16 Page 053
ITEM NUMBER: D-2
DATE: 03/15/16
02.08.2016
ATBID
PROPOSAL
PO BOX 4310 • PASO ROBLES • CALIFORNIA • 93446
p 805.434.9994 • f 805.434.9995 • WWW.CLEVERCONCEPTS.NET
information associated with it, include:
• Name
• Address
• Phone
• Fax
• Web Site
• Email
• Description
• Photo
Each listing can have events associated with them. Each event will have a name, start date, optional end date (for multi-
day events), and description. We will likely set up the web site to have events hide after they pass. We can also have
the current/latest events show up on the home page to keep it fresh.
Each listing can also have promotions associated with them. Each promotion will have a name, start date, end date, and
description. We will have promotions disappear after they are over. We can also have a random promotion featured on
the home page to keep it fresh.
NEWS
The web site will likely feature a page for news or press. The news section will be driven by a custom CMS tool. There
will be a title, date, short description/teaser, and either a link to a file, another URL or additional content. News will
display chronologically with the latest news item first. We can also have the latest news show up on the home page to
keep it fresh.
TWITTER FEED
We will integrate a custom Twitter feed in to the home page. It can either pull from a specific twitter account or a search
term.
MAILING LIST
We will integrate a third party mailing list service in to the web site. We recommend MailChimp but can work with any
service. Each page will feature a simple mailing list sign-up form to help drive people to join the mailing list.
TBID 03.15.16 Page 054
ITEM NUMBER: D-2
DATE: 03/15/16
02.08.2016
ATBID
PROPOSAL
PO BOX 4310 • PASO ROBLES • CALIFORNIA • 93446
p 805.434.9994 • f 805.434.9995 • WWW.CLEVERCONCEPTS.NET
EMAIL TEMPLATE
We will design an email template that is a slimmed down version of the web site design. We will test the email template
in all major email clients to ensure it looks as best as possible on that email client. For the purpose of this proposal, the
email design will consist of one editable content area. We will create an administration tool to allow you to easily create
your own email blasts. You will be able to edit the content of the email template and our system will take that template
and place it in to the email template design. You will then be able to import that email blast in to the mailing service of
your choice. We will train you on the process of creating the email blast and loading it in to the mailing list service.
MOBILE
The web site will be built the be responsive so it will adapt to all device sizes and display nicely on mobile devices.
PRINT
We will set up print styles so that when you print a page, it will remove unnecessary elements such as navigation items.
ADA COMPLIANCE
We will design and program the web site to be ADA compliant. We have experience with building Section 508 compliant
web sites and will either adhere to those standards or the web site standards of your choice.
REDIRECTS
We will set up a tool to allow you to define 301 redirects, which are important for your search engine presence. URLs of
pages may change with the new web site, so to maintain your search engine rankings, we will set up a 301 redirect to
redirect the old URL to the new URL.
ANALYTICS
We recommend Google Analytics, which is a free web analytics service provided by Google and is the industry standard.
PROGRAMMING
The web site will be hand-coded using a combination of HTML, CSS, Javascript, and PHP. The web pages will be valid
XHTML 1.0 Transitional.
TBID 03.15.16 Page 055
ITEM NUMBER: D-2
DATE: 03/15/16
02.08.2016
ATBID
PROPOSAL
PO BOX 4310 • PASO ROBLES • CALIFORNIA • 93446
p 805.434.9994 • f 805.434.9995 • WWW.CLEVERCONCEPTS.NET
CONSULTATION
Throughout the entire project, we will make recommendations on your web site that we see would be in your best
interest in terms of design, content, functionality, usability, and search engine optimization.
TRAINING
We will set up a meeting to train on the tools we create so that you can maintain the web site yourself. We will also
advise you on techniques to help with your search engine visibility. This training session should take approximately 2
hours.
OWNERSHIP
You will own the license to all the software used on the web site for the life of the web site. The software can not be shared,
distributed or resold to other parties.
GUARANTEE
While we do our best to deliver a 100% functional web site, bugs are bound to happen. As long as we host the web site, we
guarantee all of our work and will fix any problems that were 100% our mistake for the life of the site. We can not, however,
guarantee any browser functionality for web browsers that are released after the completion of the web site. The site will
be tested on Internet Explorer 8-11, Microsoft Edge, Firefox, Safari and Chrome.
WEB HOSTING
We work exclusively with Unix-based servers running Apache, PHP, and MySQL. The web site will need to be hosted
on a Unix server with Apache, PHP and MySQL installed. While we do not require you to host the web site with us, it is
recommended as it is much easier for us to diagnose problems with the site on our own servers.
Clever Concepts provides web hosting solely for our web development customers. We have redundant Dell PowerEdge
servers in our private cabinet at Digital West in San Luis Obispo, CA. We run Redhat Enterprise Linux with Apache/PHP/
MySQL. Data is backed up daily and weekly. The base web hosting package is priced at $37.95/month. Web statistic
reports are provided. 1 GB of bandwidth is provided each month. Additional bandwidth is $5/GB. Shared SSL usage is $5/
month. Dedicated SSL usage is $30/month.
TBID 03.15.16 Page 056
ITEM NUMBER: D-2
DATE: 03/15/16
02.08.2016
ATBID
PROPOSAL
PO BOX 4310 • PASO ROBLES • CALIFORNIA • 93446
p 805.434.9994 • f 805.434.9995 • WWW.CLEVERCONCEPTS.NET
MAINTENANCE/UPDATING
While we will provide tools for you to easily maintain the content on the site, we are also available for maintenance.
We take pride in offering very responsive maintenance service. Updates are typically completed with 24 hours.
Maintenance is charged at $120/hour with a 15 minute minimum. We typically don’t establish maintenance contracts
with our customers as our CMS tools are very intuitive, allowing our customers to do all of the maintenance themselves.
Most customers only rely on us to help add new functionality to their web site. If a maintenance contract is desirable,
we will work with you to determine your estimated number of hours required each month and will price the maintenance
based on a $100/hour rate.
TIMELINE
This project can be completed within 8-10 weeks of agreement and delivery of materials. Development will be completed in
individual steps to ensure that the final product meets your expectations.
COST AND TERMS
The cost of the project is $28,000. 25% is to be provided up-front, 25% upon design approval, 25% upon build out of
design and CMS tools, and remaining 25% upon completion of the project. Any additional development outside this scope
of work will be charged at $100 per hour. An invoice will be presented upon completion of the project and payment is in
Net 15 terms.
CONCLUSION
We look forward to working with you on this exciting project. If you have any questions regarding this proposal, please
feel free to contact us by email at dennis@cleverconcepts.net or by phone at (805) 434-9994.
Sincerely,
Dennis Clevenger
Clever Concepts, Inc.
TBID 03.15.16 Page 057
ITEM NUMBER: D-2
DATE: 03/15/16
02.08.2016
ATBID
PROPOSAL
PO BOX 4310 • PASO ROBLES • CALIFORNIA • 93446
p 805.434.9994 • f 805.434.9995 • WWW.CLEVERCONCEPTS.NET
WEB DEVELOPMENT CONTRACT
This agreement is made by Clever Concepts, Inc. and
Atascadero Tourism Business Improvement District
6904 El Camino Real
Atascadero, CA 93422
1. Clever Concepts agrees to provide the Client web development services as described in proposal issued on February 8, 2016.
2. Invoices are due and payable within 15 days of presentation. Additionally, a late payment fee of 1.5% per month (18% Annual
Percentage Rate) will be assessed on all accounts 30 days or more past due. Checks returned for any reason are subject to a $50.00
service charge. We reserve the right to cease any service or development, for nonpayment of delinquent balances owed Clever
Concepts. Such cessation will continue until the account is brought current. Client agrees to pay any collection costs incurred by Clever
Concepts in collecting any past due accounts, including but not limited to attorney’s fees.
3. The Parties agree that in keeping with Federal Regulations, Client is solely and fully responsible for the content of the electronic
information that it places on the Clients web site.
4. Termination in the Event of Material Breach. Either party can terminate this Agreement immediately following breach of this Agreement
by the other party and failure of the breaching party to cure within thirty (30) days after written notice of the breach, except that in the
event of non-payment by Client, Clever Concepts may terminate upon failure of Client to fully cure the non-payment.
5. Termination at will. In the event any party to this Agreement desires to terminate its Agreement, notice of that decision should be
submitted in signed writing to the other party at least thirty (30) days prior to the desired date of termination, provided all work paid
by the client shall be completed prior to termination; if not Clever Concepts shall refund the appropriate amount to client for work
not performed. In addition, any work that Clever Concepts has completed that has yet to be paid by the client shall be paid to Clever
Concepts.
6. This Agreement constitutes the entire Agreement, including any Exhibit(s) attached hereto, understandings and representations,
expressed or implied, between Clever Concepts and Client with respect to services to be furnished hereunder; and it supersedes all prior
communications between the Parties. Oral statements made by representatives shall not be relied on by client and are not part of this
Agreement.
7. Each person signing below represents that he/she has read the Agreement in their entirety; understands the terms; is duly authorized
to execute this Agreement on behalf of the Party indicated below by his or her name; agrees on behalf of such Party that such Party will
be bound by those terms.
CUSTOMER
Name:
Date:
CLEVER CONCEPTS, INC.
Name:
Date:
TBID 03.15.16 Page 058
ITEM NUMBER: D-2
DATE: 03/15/16
1BTP3PCMFT&YJU8PGGUIF'8:#JMMCPBSEMPDBUFEJO-PTU)JMMTPO8GBDJOH
XFTUCPVOEUSBGGJDUPXBSET1BTP3PCMFT
TBID 03.15.16 Page 059
ITEM NUMBER: D-4(b)
DATE: 03/15/16
City
Object #GL #Notes
INCOME PROJECTIONS July August September October November December January February 2015/2016 PROJECTED INCOME
1100 2% BID Revenue July 2015 - June 2016 -$ 75,302.00$ 32.00$ 1,169.00$ 49,917.00$ 90.00$ 126,510.00$ 183,030.00$ Adjusted based on EOY actual
1200 Cash Rollover 289,333.00$ 276,102.00$ Adjusted based on EOY actual
1300 Investment Earnings 2,690.00$
Total 459,132.00$ Revenue Projections TBID = $183,307 and Interest $2670
Expenses ACTUAL 2015/16 Budget
Remaining
Budget
% total
budget
Categorical
Contingency
2100 Admin 35.27$ 5,000.00$ 4,964.73$ 1.09%1,169.70$
6900000 2101 City Admin Fees 25.27$ 25.27$ 1,830.30$ 1,805.03$
6050000 2102 Office Expense 10.00$ 10.00$ 2,000.00$ 1,990.00$
2200 Contracting Firm Fees 29,645.15$ 40,000.00$ 10,354.85$ 8.71%-$
6500000 2201 Big Red Marketing - Destination Manager 2,500.00$ 2,500.00$ 2,500.00$ 2,500.00$ 2,500.00$ 2,500.00$ 2,500.00$ 17,500.00$ 30,000.00$ 12,500.00$
6500000 2202 Verdin Marketing - Marketing Firm 826.10$ 765.20$ 809.00$ 768.00$ 821.00$ 773.00$ 7,382.85$ 12,145.15$ 10,000.00$ (2,145.15)$
2300 Marketing Plan -$ 12,500.00$ 12,500.00$ 2.72%2,500.00$
6500000 2201 Development and update -$ 10,000.00$ 10,000.00$
2400 Visual Assets 20,930.70$ 17,500.00$ (3,430.70)$ 3.81%2,500.00$
6500000 2401 Photography -$ 7,500.00$ 7,500.00$
6500000 2402 Creative Services - Verdin Scope 2,832.00$ 2,892.00$ 528.00$ 1,245.00$ 7,497.00$ 7,500.00$ 3.00$
2403 Creative Services - Outside of Scope 427.00$ 214.80$
2500 Digital Marketing -$ 50,000.00$ 50,000.00$ 10.89%5,000.00$
6500000 2501 Website Updates 352.10$ -$ -$ 961.00$ 686.00$ 500.00$ 572.00$ 3,071.10$ 30,000.00$ 26,928.90$
6500000 2502 Social Media 739.80$ 1,505.80$ 1,498.00$ 1,758.00$ 1,387.00$ 1,392.00$ 2,082.00$ 10,362.60$ 15,000.00$ 4,637.40$
To include budget for boosted
activity and $12000 for retainer
2600 Advertising 19,028.94$ 65,000.00$ 45,971.06$ 14.16%3,500.00$
6070000 2601 Print -$ 1,500.00$ 1,500.00$
6070000 2602 Digital 195.44$ 304.00$ 54.00$ 780.00$ 5,541.00$ 4,968.00$ 11,842.44$ 26,000.00$ 14,157.56$
6070000 2603 Reactive Advertising 687.50$ 6,499.00$ 7,186.50$ 34,000.00$ 26,813.50$
2700 Public Relations 3,909.00$ 12,500.00$ 8,591.00$ 2.72%1,000.00$
6500000 2701 Group FAM -$ 5,000.00$ 5,000.00$
Includes $3000 retainer and $2000
hard costs
6500000 2702 Individual Itineraries -$ 5,000.00$ 5,000.00$
Includes $3000 retainer and $2000
hard costs
6500000 2703 Wire Fees -$ 1,500.00$ 1,500.00$
6500000 2704 Firm Fees 146.00$ 167.00$ -$ 1,657.00$ 642.00$ 28.00$ 1,269.00$ 3,909.00$ -$ (3,909.00)$
2800 Tour & Travel -$ 10,000.00$ 10,000.00$ 2.18%1,000.00$
6500000 2801 CCTC Co Op Fams -$ 4,500.00$ 4,500.00$
6500000 2802 Visit CA Co Op Fams -$ 4,500.00$ 4,500.00$
2900 Consumer Outreach 17,424.55$ 65,000.00$ 47,575.45$ 14.16%3,500.00$
6500000 2901 Consumer Show Presence 5,000.00$ 5,000.00$ 5,000.00$ -$
50% of Savor the Central Coast
Sponsorshihp
6500000 2902 Consumer Event Support 5,537.36$ 67.44$ 5,604.80$ 5,000.00$ (604.80)$
50% of anticipate Savor the Central
Coast costs
6900000 2903 Event Support Program 708.00$ 2,126.75$ 1,000.00$ 3,834.75$ 50,000.00$ 46,165.25$
6500000 2904 Email Marketing 1,097.00$ 846.00$ 538.00$ 504.00$ 2,985.00$ 1,500.00$ (1,485.00)$
TOTAL EXPENSES 10,272.00$ 12,797.55$ 5,823.77$ 12,694.44$ 10,991.00$ 12,014.80$ 27,021.85$ 91,615.41$ 277,500.00$
4001 Cash Reserves 45,913.20$ 10.00%
Contingency
5001 Contingency Fund (unallocated)$135,718.80
TOTAL Budget $459,132.00
ATBID 2015/16 BUDGETED P&L TBID 03.15.16 Page 060ITEM NUMBER: D-5DATE: 03/15/16
t (805) 541-9005 f (805) 541-9007
3580 Sacramento Drive #110, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401
VERDINMARKETING.COM
FEBRUARY STAT SUMMARY
ATASCADERO TBID
March 3, 2016
WEB ANALYTICS (2015 V.2016)
WEBSITE TRAFFIC
Website Visits: 1,755 v. 5,096
Mobile Visits: 667 v. 2,563
Desktop Visits: 862 v. 2,112
Total Unique Visitors:
1,533 v. 4,163
PPV (Page Per Visit): 2.71 v. 1.74
TOS (Time on Site): 1:47 v. 1:01
Bounce Rate: 50.60% v.
70.84%
ACQUISITION
Total Traffic to Site:
5,096
Direct: 170 v. 1,500
Referral: 557 v. 1,577
Organic: 1,019 v. 1,490
Social Media: 8 v. 529
PAGE VIEWS
Home Page: 1,233 v.
3,935
Lodging: 115 v. 269
GEOGRAPHIC REFERRALS
San Francisco: 182 v. 528
Los Angeles: 161 v. 428
Atascadero: 201 v. 339
San Luis Obispo: 81 v. 168
Sacramento: NA v. 156
SOCIAL MEDIA ANALYTICS (2015 V.2016)
TOP REFERRING URLS
adspreview.simpli.fi: 541
m.facebook.com: 339
atascadero.org: 325
ads.simpli.fi: 157
westads.simpli.fi: 140
SOCIAL MEDIA
Facebook Fans: 3,061 v. 4,607
Facebook Referrals: 0 v. 474
Total Reach: NA v. 19,384
Engagement Rate: NA v. 6%
New Instagram Followers: +57
Instagram Followers YTD: 185
New Twitter Followers: NA v. 19
Twitter Mentions: NA v. 3
Twitter Referrals: 5 v. 1
Retweets: NA v. 0
TBID 03.15.16 Page 061
ITEM NUMBER: D-6
DATE: 03/15/16
t (805) 541-9005 f (805) 541-9007
3580 Sacramento Drive #110, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401
VERDINMARKETING.COM 2
ADVERTISING ANALYTICS
E -NEWSLETTER
The February e-newsletter went out on February 19, 2016 and performed well. We added the
previous e-newsletter list to the current e-mail recipient database and the open rate, as expected,
decreased. However, our click through rate is very strong.
2,000 Recipients
13.7% Open Rate (Industry Average is 16.6%)
3.6% Click Through Rate (Industry Average is 1.8%)
FACEBOOK
Facebook ads for February focused on the “101 Road Trip” contest that launched February 1.
Total Impressions: 76,518
Total Clicks: 1,654
Actions (including likes, shares, comments): 12,888
CTR: 2.16%
TRIP ADVISOR
Trip Advisor ads focused on the “101 Road Trip” beginning February 1. The results are as follows:
Total Impressions: 68,653
Total Clicks: 100
CTR: .15%
PANDORA
Pandora began on January 1. The 101 Road Trip campaign targeted the Visalia, Tulare and Hanford
communities. Results were very impressive and improved from January results.
Total Impressions: 542,477 Total Clicks: 1,762 CTR: .84%
TBID 03.15.16 Page 062
ITEM NUMBER: D-6
DATE: 03/15/16
t (805) 541-9005 f (805) 541-9007
3580 Sacramento Drive #110, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401
VERDINMARKETING.COM 3
METRICS GLOSSARY
DEFINITIONS OF KEY DIGITAL & SOCIAL MEDIA METRICS
Last updated February 2016
WEBSITES
Sessions/Website Visits: A session is a group of interactions that take place on your website
within a given time frame. For example, a single session can contain multiple screen or page views,
events, social interactions, and e-commerce transactions. A single user can be responsible for
multiple sessions, which may span days, weeks or months. A session ends based on two methods:
time-based expiration (either thirty minutes of inactivity or the arrival of midnight local time), or a
campaign change (if a user arrives via one campaign, leaves, then comes back via a separate
campaign.
Users/Unique Visitors: The number of unique visitors to your site determined by individual IP
address, including new and returning users.
PPS/PPV (Pages Per Session/Visit): The average number of pages viewed during a session on
your website. Repeated views of a single page are counted.
TOS (Time On Site): The average length of visitors’ sessions on your website.
Bounce Rate: The percentage of single-page sessions (i.e. sessions in which the person left your
site from the entrance page without interacting with the page, regardless of time spent on that page).
There are a number of factors that contribute to a high bounce rate. For example, users might leave
your site from the entrance page if there are site design or usability issues. Alternatively, users might
also leave the site after viewing a single page if they've found the information they need on that one
page, and had no need or interest in going to other pages.
Geographic Referrals: The top five locations from which the data originated.
Acquisition – Social Media: The traffic to your site that came from a social media network.
Acquisition – Direct: Direct traffic is counted as any time Google Analytics cannot determine
another referrer. (Clicking a link from an email or PDF, access from a shortened URL, clicking from a
mobile social media app, etc.) Whether or not a session is counted as direct depends on the
application/program they are using.
Acquisition – Organic: The traffic that comes to your website from unpaid search results (i.e.
searching “Atascadero” in Google.)
Acquisition – Referral: The traffic that comes to your site from sources outside of Google. When
someone clicks on a hyperlink to go to a new page on a different website, it is a referral visit.
TBID 03.15.16 Page 063
ITEM NUMBER: D-6
DATE: 03/15/16
t (805) 541-9005 f (805) 541-9007
3580 Sacramento Drive #110, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401
VERDINMARKETING.COM 4
SOCIAL MEDIA
Likes: The total number of individual Facebook users who have “liked” your page. This number does
not factor in users who have deleted or suspended their accounts after “liking” your page, nor does it
include users that have become deceased after “liking” your page.
Reach: The number of individual users to whom content associated with your page is displayed.
Engagement Rate: The percentage of users who were served your content that liked, shared,
clicked or commented on it.
Referrals: Visits to your website that originate from a source outside of a search engine or direct
URL input (i.e. Facebook, Twitter, TripAdvisor, email blast, etc.).
DIGITAL ADVERTISING
Total clicks: Numeric value assigned to the number of times an advertisement was clicked. While
tracking users who follow ads to a landing page is important, engagement for some businesses is
more important. Please note, some types of ads, like video or cinemagraphs, have the goal of
engaging or entertaining a user while building brand awareness rather than to have them click on the
ad. In this case, lower clicks and a lower click through rate is expected and not an indication of poor
performance.
Impressions: The number of times an advertisement is served. For most digital advertising,
impressions is the element that is paid for or guaranteed based on budget.
Click Through Rate: Percentage of users who were served your advertisement that clicked
through to the advertiser’s website. Whereas total clicks is just the numeric value of the number of
times an ad is clicked, the click through rate (CTR) is the percentage calculated in relationship to the
number of impressions. CTRs do not always reflect the whole story, because if a user was influenced
to learn more about the advertising message because they saw the ad but didn’t click on the ad itself,
the campaign does not get credit for generating that lead.
View Through Totals or Percentages: How many users (or what percentage of users, depending
on vendor preferences) were served an ad and went to visit the website within a few days or weeks.
These numbers can only be captured when a tracking pixel or UTM code is embedded into a website
with correspondingly embedded ads.
Engagement rates: Usually reflect any activity surrounding a digital ad, such as hovering,
replaying a video, sharing, liking, or commenting. While not available from all vendors, engagement
rates are helpful when tracking digital ad performance.
A NOTE ON MOBILE ADS WITHIN APPS:
The vast majority of smart phone users see ads within their favorite apps. Those app vendors
(Pandora, Facebook, Trip Advisor) provide certified performance reports, but they often are not
TBID 03.15.16 Page 064
ITEM NUMBER: D-6
DATE: 03/15/16
t (805) 541-9005 f (805) 541-9007
3580 Sacramento Drive #110, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401
VERDINMARKETING.COM 5
reflected in website stats, particularly when using Google Analytics. Google Analytics (GA) is an
excellent tool for website optimization, such as tracking site page visits, link activity, and some traffic
sources, but it is not accurate when it comes to advertising tracking. Business owners who use GA to
track ad campaigns need to know it’s not uncommon for GA to under report web advertising by 20%-
30%,, and by 50%-90% for mobile in-app advertising. This miscalculation can be confusing when
compared to the vendor-reported success of an ad campaign. This is an industry-wide issue and the
following are recommended to ensure accurate reporting:
• Don’t rely on Google Analytics to determine your digital advertising campaign’s success.
• Use UTM codes and Tracking pixels whenever possible and have a website expert install them.
• Partner with reputable vendors whose tracking has been accredited by the Interactive
Advertising Bureau (IAB) and trust their reports.
DIGITAL MEDIA BENCHMARKS
• Generally, the overall banner display ad click through rate average is .06% to .08%.
• Rich media (meaning animated, video or other more engaging ads) average CTR is .15% to
.22%.
• Pandora tends to have a higher CTR than traditional banner ads when the correct targeting is
in place. Pandora will normally have between .30% and 1% CTRs, but variations are standard
in the industry.
• Within Facebook, paid advertising has the highest CTR normally, assuming quality content, of
1.2% to 1.5%. Promoted or Boosted posts traditionally show lower numbers, with an average
CTR of .5% to .8%.
• Facebook drives 23% of all website traffic and continues to be one of the best platforms for a
strong ROI. It accounts for 18% of all digital advertising across all platforms in all countries.
• Open rates of email blasts and newsletters vary dramatically based on industry, with the
highest (29% and over) going to personal hobbies and entertainment-based industries and as
low as 15% to 17% for some medical- or insurance-based industries. Most experts report 10%
to 15% as the average CTOR (click to open rate). Average click through rates from content to
website are 4.8% to 1.5%.
TBID 03.15.16 Page 065
ITEM NUMBER: D-6
DATE: 03/15/16