Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutResolution 2015-007 City of Atascadero Housing Element 2014-2019 Public Review Draft: July 31, 2014 City of Atascadero 6500 Palma Avenue Atascadero, CA 93422 www.atascadero.org Prepared by: Lisa Wise Consulting, Inc. 983 Osos Street San Luis Obispo, CA 93401 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element This Page Intentionally Left Blank Public Review Draft Page 1 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element Table of Contents A. INTRODUCTION .......................................................................................................................................... 5 1. OVERVIEW ........................................................................................................................................................ 5 2. PUBLIC PARTICIPATION ..................................................................................................................................... 6 3. CONSISTENCY WITH OTHER GENERAL PLAN ELEMENTS ................................................................................... 9 B. EVALUATION OF PREVIOUS HOUSING ELEMENT ........................................................................ 10 C. POPULATION AND EMPLOYMENT TRENDS .................................................................................... 22 1. POPULATION ................................................................................................................................................... 22 2. EMPLOYMENT ................................................................................................................................................. 23 D. HOUSING CHARACTERISTICS.............................................................................................................. 26 1. HOUSEHOLDS .................................................................................................................................................. 26 2. HOUSING UNITS .............................................................................................................................................. 28 3. HOUSING CONDITIONS .................................................................................................................................... 29 4. HOUSING COSTS .............................................................................................................................................. 29 5. HOUSING AFFORDABILITY .............................................................................................................................. 32 6. AT-RISK UNITS ............................................................................................................................................... 33 E. SPECIAL HOUSING NEEDS ..................................................................................................................... 34 1. SENIOR HOUSEHOLDS ..................................................................................................................................... 34 2. PERSONS WITH DISABILITIES ........................................................................................................................... 36 3. LARGE FAMILIES AND OVERCROWDING .......................................................................................................... 38 4. SINGLE -PARENT HOUSEHOLDS ....................................................................................................................... 39 5. PERSONS IN NEED OF EMERGENCY SHELTER .................................................................................................. 40 6. FARMWORKERS ............................................................................................................................................... 41 F. HOUSING RESOURCES ............................................................................................................................ 42 1. REGIONAL HOUSING NEEDS ALLOCATION ...................................................................................................... 42 2014 – 2019 Regional Housing Needs Allocation ............................................................................................................ 42 2. SITE INVENTORY AND ANALYSIS .................................................................................................................... 43 Vacant Sites ...................................................................................................................................................................... 43 3. INFRASTRUCTURE RESOURCES ........................................................................................................................ 44 4. ADMINISTRATIVE RESOURCES ........................................................................................................................ 45 5. FINANCIAL RESOURCES ................................................................................................................................... 49 6. OTHER RESOURCES ......................................................................................................................................... 50 G. CONSTRAINTS ON HOUSING PRODUCTION .................................................................................... 53 1. GOVERNMENTAL CONSTRAINTS ...................................................................................................................... 53 2. NON-GOVERNMENTAL CONSTRAINTS ............................................................................................................. 76 H. HOUSING ELEMENT GOALS, POLICIES, AND PROGRAMS .......................................................... 79 I. REFERENCES ............................................................................................................................................. 93 Appendix I ........................................................................................................................................................................ 95 Appendix II .................................................................................................................................................................... 108 Public Review Draft Page 2 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element List of Tables Table V-1. Progress During Previous Planning Period, 2007-2014 ............................................................. 10 Table V-2. Evaluation Of Previous Housing Element .................................................................................. 11 Table V-3. Trends In Population Growth ....................................................................................................... 22 Table V-4. Trends In Population Age ............................................................................................................. 22 Table V-5. Trends In Race And Ethnicity ....................................................................................................... 23 Table V-6. Industry Trends In Atascadero ..................................................................................................... 23 Table V-7. Trends In Occupations ................................................................................................................... 24 Table V-8. Class Of Worker Trends ................................................................................................................ 25 Table V-9. Trends In Households .................................................................................................................... 26 Table V-10. Trends In Household Income Groups ..................................................................................... 27 Table V-11. Trends In Housing Tenure ........................................................................................................ 27 Table V-12. Trends In Housing Type ........................................................................................................... 28 Table V-13. Housing Units By Age ............................................................................................................... 28 Table V-14. Housing Problems For All Lower Income Households ........................................................ 30 Table V-15. Gross Rent As A Percent Of Income 2012 ............................................................................... 31 Table V-16. Monthly Owner Costs As A Percentage Of Household Income ......................................... 31 Table V-17. San Luis Obispo County Income Limits ................................................................................. 32 Table V-18. San Luis Obispo County Maximum Sales And Rental Prices .............................................. 32 Table V-19. Special Needs Populations, 2000 And 2010 ............................................................................ 34 Table V-20. Senior Households, 2010 ........................................................................................................... 34 Table V-21. Households By Income Level, 2006-2010 ................................................................................ 35 Table V-22. Senior Housing Facilities, 2014 ................................................................................................. 35 Table V-23. Persons With Disabilities By Type ........................................................................................... 36 Table V-24. Number Of Persons With Developmental Disabilities, 2014 ............................................... 38 Table V-25. Household Size By Tenure In Atascadero .............................................................................. 38 Table V-26. Overcrowded Households In Atascadero, 2010 .................................................................... 38 Table V-27. Single Parent Households, 2010 ............................................................................................... 39 Table V-28. Female Headed Households, 2010 ........................................................................................... 40 Table V-29. City Share Of Regional Housing Need, 2014-2019 ................................................................ 43 Table V-30. Summary Of Vacant Parcels, Atascadero 2014 ...................................................................... 43 Table V-31. Rhna Summary, 2014-2019 ........................................................................................................ 44 Table V-32. General Plan Land Use Designations And Zoning District Comparison ........................... 56 Table V-33. Zoning District’s Permitted Land Uses In 2014a .................................................................... 57 Public Review Draft Page 3 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element Table V-34. Residential Zones Development Standardsa .......................................................................... 59 Table V-35. Downtown Zones Development Standardsa .......................................................................... 59 Table V-36. Parking Requirements A ............................................................................................................ 65 Table V-37. Planning And Development Feesa ........................................................................................... 66 Table V-38. Development Fees For New Housing, 2014a .......................................................................... 67 Table V-39. Proportion Of Fee In Overall Development Cost For A Typical Residential Development, 2014 ................................................................................................................................................... 67 Table V-40. Permit Processing Proceduresa ................................................................................................. 69 Table V-41. Timelines For Permit Proceduresa ........................................................................................... 69 Table V-42. Constraints On Housing For Persons With Disabilities ........................................................ 71 Table V-43. Strategies To Address Energy Conservation And Global Climate Change ....................... 75 Table V-44. 323bsummary Of Quantified Objectives, 2014-2019 .............................................................. 92 Table V-45. Vacant Land Inventory ..............................................................................................................95 List of Figures Figure V-1. Median Home Price, 2003-2013 Atascadero And Slo County .............................................. 29 Figure V-2. Vacant Land Inventory Map ................................................................................................... 108 Public Review Draft Page 4 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element A. Introduction 1. Overview California planning law provides more detailed requirements for the housing element than for any other element of the General Plan. The State Legislature has found that "the availability of housing is of vital statewide importance and that the early attainment of decent housing and a suitable living environment for every California family is a priority of the highest order." The housing element establishes policies for the community to ensure safe, decent housing for its current and future residents. Article 10.6 of the California Government Code requires each city and county to analyze housing needs and establish goals, policies, programs, and quantified objectives to meet the identified needs. The analysis must address all economic segments (extremely low-, very low-, low-, moderate- and above moderate-incomes) of the community, the City’s share of the regional housing need, and the housing needs of special groups such as the elderly, disabled, homeless, large families, and single parents. The City must either identify vacant or re- developable sites that can provide sufficient housing to meet these needs or include programs in the housing element to identify additional residential sites. In addition, housing elements are subject to State review and certification. This Housing Element includes the following information as required by State law: 1. Analysis of Atascadero’s housing needs. 2. Information on the existing housing stock, including the number, type, cost, tenure, and structural condition of the units. 3. Analysis of land available to accommodate unmet housing needs. 4. Analysis of potential barriers to housing development, including governmental and non-governmental constraints. 5. Information on existing subsidized or below market-rate housing units. 6. Information on energy conservation opportunities for housing construction or rehabilitation. 7. Specific goals, measurable objectives, policies, and programs to address the housing allocation, as required by the County Regional Housing Needs Plan. Major housing issues and opportunities identified in Atascadero include: 1. Adequate sites for the development of housing for all economic segments of the community. Public Review Draft Page 5 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element 2. Incentives to encourage private market and non-profit development of affordable housing. 3. Integration of affordable housing into new above-moderate income residential projects or payment of fees in-lieu of affordable housing inclusion. 4. Special needs of seniors and families. 5. Maintenance of existing housing, rehabilitation of substandard units, and removal and replacement of substandard housing that cannot feasibly be rehabilitated. 6. Financial resources and programs to help subsidize development, maintenance, and rehabilitation of extremely low, very-low, low-, and moderate-income housing. 7. Local governmental constraints on the production or rehabilitation of housing. 8. Housing and services for the homeless population. 2. Public Participation Government Code §65583(c)(6)(B) requires the City to “make a diligent effort to achieve public participation of all economic segments of the community in the development of the housing element.” Accordingly, this document incorporates input received from the general public, City Council, Planning Commission, and other stakeholders. Public Workshops The City facilitated a stakeholder workshop on April 29, 2014, to solicit input by citizens from different geographic areas and economic segments in the City, non-profit associations, financial and real estate professionals, decision-makers, and others to provide policy guidance. Comments brought up during public meeting included:  Housing options for extremely low and very low-income households, including housing for the homeless, transitional housing, and group housing.  Explore use of using hotel facilities for housing  What are the penalties of not having a certified Housing Element?  Coordination of homeless services, such as warming shelters  Overnight camping in City parks and/or permanent camping site(s)  San Luis Obispo County Homeless Services Oversight Council policy recommendations  Is there any City owned land for use for affordable housing?  Use of City’s Low-Moderate Housing Fund  Zoning allowing alternative housing types for group housing facilities. Public Review Draft Page 6 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element April 20, 2014 Stakeholder Workshop On May 20, 2014 the City held a Planning Commission workshop. The purpose of the meeting was to provide an overview of the Housing Element update process, present the results of the April 29, 2014 stakeholder workshop, and solicit Planning Commission feedback and direction on policy recommendations. Policies presented for consideration and Commission direction included: 1. Review and consider modifying the City’s Inclusionary Housing Policy 2. Establish a program to work with additional non-profit groups to facilitate establishment of transitional housing 3. Encourage the ability to construct ‘micro homes’ consistent with the California Building Code 4. Adjust development impact fees for second units based on size of the second unit 5. Other Planning Commission policy recommendations The community and Planning Commission were given the opportunity to ask questions about each policy recommendation. Comments included: • Ensure the City’s current Inclusionary Housing Policy complies with State law with regard to rent control Public Review Draft Page 7 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element • There are different types of ‘affordable housing’, not only emergency shelters • Recognize the growing trend in micro-homes, especially for aging baby boomers • How to address density and sewer requirements for micro homes, should it be different? • Second units are a great way to provide housing on large single family lots • Supportive of reducing fees based on actual impact- smaller units have less impact • Consider other incentives to encourage affordable housing/second units • Need for senior housing, all levels of care Organizations Contacted To ensure that the interests of all economic segments of the community, including low- and moderate-income households, were represented in the Housing Element update, the City specifically contacted and sought participation by representatives from the following organizations: • Atascadero Association of Realtors • Atascadero Chamber of Commerce • Atascadero Community Link • Atascadero Unified School District • California Department of Housing and Community Development • Caltrans • Central Coast Commission for Senior Citizens • Community Action Partnership, San Luis Obispo (CAPSLO) • Cooperation for Better Housing • El Camino Homeless Organization (ECHO) • Habitat for Humanity • Housing Authority San Luis Obispo (HASLO) • Homeless Services Oversight Council (HSOC) • Local Agency Formation Commission (LAFCO) • North County Connection • North County Women’s Shelter • People’s Self Help Housing • Salvation Army • San Luis Obispo Council of Governments (SLOCOG) • San Luis Obispo County Air Pollution Control District (APCD) • San Luis Obispo County Housing Trust Fund (SLOHTF) • San Luis Obispo County Planning and Building • Transitions Mental Health Association (THMA) • Transitional Food and Shelter • Tri-Counties Regional Center (TCRC) Public Hearings The public and stakeholders were notified of the availability of the Public Review Draft Housing Element on June 4, 2014. Public Review Draft Page 8 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element On XXX, 2014, a public hearing was held before the City Council. The main issues/comments received included: [to be completed] The Housing Element is posted on the City’s web site (www.atascadero.org). 3. Consistency with Other General Plan Elements State law requires that the General Plan and all of its elements comprise an "integrated, internally consistent, and compatible statement of policies." The goals, policies, and programs of this Housing Element are consistent with the goals, policies, and programs contained in other elements of the General Plan. The Housing Element is Chapter V of the existing General Plan. As other elements of the General Plan are updated or amended, the City will review the Housing Element to ensure General Plan consistency is maintained. Public Review Draft Page 9 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element B. Evaluation of Previous Housing Element The previous 2007-2014 Housing Element brought the City’s Housing Element into compliance with State law, including an amendment to the City’s Zoning Ordinance to provide adequate sites at a minimum density of 20 dwelling units per acre and an emergency shelter overlay zone to satisfy the requirements of Senate Bill 2, which addresses emergency and transitional shelters, as well policies for reasonable accommodation, density bonus, and single room occupancies. Another priority of the previous Housing Element was conservation and rehabilitation of existing homes. Table V-1 summarizes the City’s previous RHNA for the period from January 2007 through December 2014 and the number of housing units built or approved during that planning period. As the City did not have a certified Housing Element for the 2001-2006 period, the City needed to account for the 769 units during the 2007-2014 period. From January 2007 through December 31, 2013, the City constructed or approved 480 units, including 31 second units. Additionally, the City worked with People’s Self Help Housing on the construction and permitting of 24 homes for ownership, available to very-low and low-income residents. the City met the above moderate income housing needs for the 2007-2014 planning period. Table V-1. Progress During Previous Planning Period, 2007-2014 Very Low Low Moderate Above Moderate Total Unaccommodated 2001-2006 RHNA 312 193 264 0 769 2007 - 2014 RHNA 106 74 88 194 462 2007 – 2014 Total 418 267 352 194 1,231 Units constructed/approved 28 22 134 265 449 Second units constructed/approved* 0 12 12 7 31 2007 - 2014 Remaining RHNA 390 233 206 0 829 *Second units constructed and approved were classified by income category based on square footage. According to the San Luis Obispo Multi-Family Housing Rental Survey Summary, typical rent in Atascadero is approximately $1.09/sf. Affordability was determined by multiplying the cost per square foot by the square footage of a second unit. Source: CA Dept. of Housing and Community Development, SLOCOG, City of Atascadero The goals and policies contained in the previous Housing Element were generally appropriate to meet the housing needs of the City. This updated Element builds on that foundation, while focusing on in-fill development along the El Camino Real corridor to increase housing opportunities. Table V-2 indicates what has been achieved and which programs should be carried forward or deleted. However, to improve on the implementation and usability of the document some of the policies and programs have been reworded or combined with other programs. Public Review Draft Page 10 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element Table V-1.Table V-2. Evaluation of Previous Housing Element Program Summary Quantified Objective Achievement Further Progress Needed Goal 1: Promote diverse and high quality housing opportunities to meet the needs of all segments of the community. Policy 1.1 – Encourage new housing, including mixed-use projects in commercial land use areas, to meet the needs of all household types in the City. Program 1.1 - 1. To address the 2001 - 2006 RHNA, the City shall amend the General Plan and the Zoning Ordinance, as necessary, to provide adequate sites for 505 very low and low-income units at a minimum of 20 dwelling units per acre “by right” (without a Conditional Use Permit or other discretionary action) on certain sites or in certain zones 505 units (Programs 1 and 2 total 651 units) The City amended the General Plan and the Zoning Ordinance to provide adequate sites for 505 very low and low- income units at a minimum of 20 dwelling units per acre “by right” (without a Conditional Use Permit or other discretionary action) on certain sites or in certain zones. At least half (50 percent) of these sites were zoned for residential uses only as a part of the housing element adoption. None. Program Complete. Program 1.1 - 2. To address the 2007 – 2017 RHNA, the City shall amend the General Plan and the Zoning Ordinance, as necessary, to provide adequate sites for 146 very low and low-income units at a minimum of 20 dwelling units per acre “by right” (without a Conditional Use Permit or other discretionary action) on certain sites or in certain zones. 146 units (Programs 1 and 2 total 651 units City Council amended the Zoning Code and General Plan to provide adequate sites. None. Program Complete. Program 1.1 - 3. Continue street and infrastructure improvement projects to benefit existing high density residential areas. N/A On-going on a per project basis. Continue program into next Housing Element. Program 1.1 - 4. Continue to require the use of specific plans for residential projects of 100 or more units. N/A Only one project (Eagle Ranch) meets this criteria at this time. Applicants are completing a Specific Plan. Continue program into next Housing Element. Program 1.1 - 5. Continue to allow manufactured housing and group housing in accordance with State law. 20 units Since 2007, 11 manufactured units have been issued. Continue program into next Housing Element. Public Review Draft Page 11 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element Program Summary Quantified Objective Achievement Further Progress Needed Program 1.1 - 6. Support the extension and expansion of sewer service for the Eagle Ranch annexation area by allocating the funding necessary 100 affordable units The City is currently working with the developers of the Eagle Ranch Specific Plan to identify location for affordable housing units within the project area. . Continue program into next Housing Element and clarify the Eagle Ranch project will include affordable housing units. Program 1.1 - 7. Continue to allow mixed residential and commercial development and promote second- and third-story residential development in the City’s downtown zoning districts. Taking into account market conditions and development costs, the City will provide, when possible, developer incentives such as expedited permit processing and fee deferrals for units that are affordable to lower income households. The City will publicize these incentives on the City’s website (www.atascadero.org) within one week of a confirmed decision to make them available in a timely fashion. 20 units Staff will continue to work with developers of the Colony Square project for redesign of the residential units. This component of the project remains undeveloped. Additional interest in residential development downtown remains. Continue program into next Housing Element. Replace ‘fee deferrals’ with ‘flexible development standards.’ Program 1.1 - 8. Continue to encourage, where suitable, Planned Unit Development (PD) Overlay Zones, particularly the PD-25 zone of small lot subdivisions, for higher density attached or row-house style housing in the RMF- 10 and RMF-16 zoning districts. 75 units Staff continues to encourage use of PDs for high quality design. Continue program into next Housing Element. Program 1.1 - 9. Adopt a Rural Residential Zone in the Zoning Ordinance consistent with its designation on the Zoning Map and standards that distinguish it from the Residential Suburban zone (to facilitate the development of a variety of housing types N/A Staff has yet to begin work on this ordinance. Continue program into next Housing Element. Program 1.1 - 10.Adopt an affordable housing density bonus ordinance that establishes procedures for obtaining and monitoring density bonuses in compliance with State law. Following adoption the City shall regularly update the ordinance to be in compliance with Government Code §65915 and develop an outreach program to ensure its successful implementation. The City should consider exceeding State requirements if projects meet City housing goals, such as compact high density housing, architectural quality, or green building. 25 units Completed in 2013. None. Program Complete. Public Review Draft Page 12 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element Program Summary Quantified Objective Achievement Further Progress Needed Program 1.1 - 11.Update feasibility analysis of inclusionary housing policy to reflect current market conditions. As part of the feasibility study explore options to streamline and clarify the various options available to a developer. The City will also evaluate impacts to market rate housing related to current market conditions, project applications, estimated affordable housing requirements, fee collection, and actual construction of affordable housing units. If the policy presents an obstacle to the development of the City's fair share of regional housing needs, the City will revise the policy accordingly. N/A City staff has reviewed work from consultant. Based on market trends and the uptick on older projects, the affordable housing policy in place is working. Additional work may be directed by the City Council. Consider program modifications to direct review to City Council. Program 1.1 - 12. Adopt an inclusionary housing ordinance that requires residential and commercial developments to provide deed-restricted, affordable units or an in-lieu fee. 70 units At this time, Staff feels the inclusionary policy provides the flexibility necessary to provide affordable units. Council may direct staff to continue to explore adoption of an inclusionary housing policy. Continue to consider adoption of an inclusionary housing ordinance. Remove linkage requirement for commercial development. Program 1.1 - 13.To encourage the development of second units, the City will evaluate the development standards and update the Zoning Ordinance for second units (secondary residential units). For example, the City will explore incentives such as reducing fees and eliminating the covered parking requirement for a secondary residential unit. The City will also work with Atascadero Mutual Water Company to investigate the possibility of reductions to water connection fees for second units and consider an amnesty program that would reduce or eliminate fees for unpermitted second units. 40 units City did not evaluate second unit ordinance. 2nd Unit ordinance will need to be reviewed as a part of the 2014 housing element. Consider splitting program into two separate programs, one to evaluate development standards and another to evaluate impact fees for second units as part of an AB1600 study process. Public Review Draft Page 13 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element Program Summary Quantified Objective Achievement Further Progress Needed Program 1.1 - 14. Continue to maintain Chapter 12 of the Zoning Ordinance (Condo Conversion Ordinance) in order to reduce the impacts of condo conversions on lower cost rental housing. N/A The City plans to maintain this ordinance. Continue program into next Housing Element to ensure no changes to Condo Conversion Ordinance. Program 1.1 - 15. Adopt an ordinance to allow vertical multi-family residential on the second floor in General Commercial land use designations with a Conditional Use Permit and horizontal mixed-use subject to a PD and General Plan Amendment N/A Completed in 2013. None. Program Complete. Program 1.1 - 16. Continue to work with non-profit agencies, such as the County Housing Authority, Habitat for Humanity, the San Luis Obispo County Housing Trust Fund and Peoples’ Self- Help Housing, to preserve existing affordable housing and to pursue funding for new units for extremely low-, very low-, low-, and moderate-income families. 50 units Staff is working with these organizations and providing support, where necessary. Continue program into next Housing Element. Program 1.1 - 17. Continue to encourage developers to work with agencies such as the California Housing Finance Authority (CHFA) and the Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) to obtain loans for development of new multifamily rental housing for low income households. This will be accomplished by working with appropriate non-profit organizations, such as People’s Self Help Housing and the San Luis Obispo County Housing Trust Fund to identify opportunities. N/A Staff provides necessary assistance in completing applications for funds. Continue program into next Housing Element. Program 1.1 - 18. Continue to contract with the San Luis Obispo Housing Authority for administration of the Section 8 housing voucher program. The City utilizes this relationship for program implementation and income verifications, and will apply for additional Section 8 vouchers, as appropriate. N/A The City continues its contract with the San Luis Obispo Housing Agency. Continue program into next Housing Element. Program 1.1 - 19. Amend the Zoning Ordinance to establish minimum required densities in the medium and high density residential zones to preserve the limited supply of multi-family zoned land for multi-family uses. N/A Completed in 2013. None. Program Complete. Public Review Draft Page 14 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element Program Summary Quantified Objective Achievement Further Progress Needed Program 1.1 - 20. Amend the Zoning Ordinance to allow a waiver of the two story height limit in the RMF Zone through the Minor Use Permit process. This option applies to projects that are not using the Planned Development option. N/A Staff has yet to commence this ordinance. This will be reviewed and carry over into next housing element cycle. Continue program into next Housing Element. Goal 2: Protect and conserve the existing housing stock and neighborhoods. Policy 2.1 – Encourage conservation and preservation of neighborhoods and sound housing. Program 2.1 – 1. As new projects, code enforcement actions, and other opportunities arise, the City will investigate ways to meet its housing needs through rehabilitation and preservation of existing units (see also Program 4.3.3 for potential rehabilitation funding). Utilize code enforcement to identify housing maintenance issues and expedite rehabilitation of substandard and deteriorating housing by offering technical assistance to homeowners and occupants. 30 units While this is on-going, the City has lost its primary funding tool when the RDA was dissolved. The City will continue to find ways to rehabilitate structures. Modify program and continue program into next Housing Element. Program 2.1 – 2. Continue to participate in federal grant programs, such as Community Development Block Grants (CDBG), to obtain loans and/or grants for housing rehabilitation. Apply an appropriate amount of the City’s annual share of CDBG funds toward rehabilitation of existing housing units 25 units The City will continue to participate in grant programs and will seek opportunities for additional grant funds to supplement the loss of the RDA. Continue program into next Housing Element. Program 2.1 – 3. Continue to maintain the sliding density scale for sloped lots in the Zoning Ordinance. N/A The City will continue to maintain its sliding scale of density for sloped lots. Continue program into next Housing Element. Program 2.1 – 4. Allocate funds in the RDA housing set aside to rehabilitate existing housing stock within Redevelopment Project Areas with special emphasis on the Downtown Commercial zone. 40 units The City's RDA was dissolved on 2/1/2012 because of State legislation. RDA dissolved, Remove Program. Program 2.1 – 5. The City shall continue to monitor the status of subsidized affordable projects, rental projects, and mobile homes in the City and provide technical and financial assistance, when possible, to ensure long-term N/A City Staff continues to monitor the status of affordable housing rental units and for sale units in partnership with the SLO County Housing Continue program into next Housing Element. Public Review Draft Page 15 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element Program Summary Quantified Objective Achievement Further Progress Needed affordability. This will involve contacting owner/operators of subsided projects annually to determine the status of the units and their potential to convert to market-rate. If projects are at-risk, the City will maintain contact with local organizations and housing providers who may have an interest in acquiring at- risk units, and, when feasible, keep track of and apply for funding opportunities to preserve at-risk units, and assist other organizations in applying for funding to acquire at-risk units. Authority. Policy 4.2 – Encourage conservation and preservation of houses that have historical and architectural significance. Program 2.2 – 1. Continue to implement the Historic Site (HS) overlay zone to help preserve and protect historic Colony homes. N/A The City will continue to maintain this overlay zone to preserve and protect historic colony homes. Continue program into next Housing Element. Program 2.2 – 2. Continue to maintain a GIS based map of protected sites. N/A The City continues to maintain GIS data in regards to historic buildings and sites. Continue program into next Housing Element. Goal 3: Encourage energy conservation and sustainable building measures in new and existing homes Policy 3.1- Continue to make residents aware of available energy saving techniques and public utility rebates Program 3.1 – 1. Promote environmentally sustainable building practices that provide cost savings to homeowners and developers N/A City staff continues to work with developers and homeowners to avoid environmental impacts and promote sustainable building practices. Continue program into next Housing Element. Program 3.1 – 2. Make available in the Community Development Department brochures from PG&E and others that detail energy conservation measures for new and existing buildings. N/A In partnership with PG&E and San Luis Obispo Green Build, there are various brochures available to homeowners that detail energy conservation. Continue program into next Housing Element. Program 3.1- 3. Continue to strictly enforce the State energy standards of Title 24. N/A The City's Building Department continues to enforce Title 24 requirements upon review of building plans that require energy reports. Continue program into next Housing Element. Program 3.1-4. Continue to implement AB 811 by providing an assessment district for homeowners wishing to N/A This program has been suspended due to pending litigation Remove. Public Review Draft Page 16 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element Program Summary Quantified Objective Achievement Further Progress Needed install energy efficiency improvements. This will allow the homeowners to spread the cost of the photovoltaic systems out over a number of years on their annual tax bill, thus reducing the upfront cost. because Fannie Mae and Freddie NMac would not issue loans. Goal 4: Ensure equal access to sound, affordable housing for all persons regardless of race, religion, age, sex, marital status, ancestry, national origin, color, familial status, or disability. Policy 4.1 - Support equal housing opportunities and enforcement of State and federal anti-discrimination laws. Program 4.1 – 1. Cooperate with non- profit groups and local religious organizations to allow the temporary use of churches as homeless shelters. N/A The City continues to encourage local churches to provide temporary shelters for the homeless population. Continue program into next Housing Element. Program 4.1 – 2. Continue to support local motel voucher programs for temporarily displaced and extremely low-income persons. The motel voucher program is funded through the City’s CDBG funding. Motel vouchers are available to aid residents experiencing emergency situations, such as a house fire, in finding temporary housing. The City works with non-profit organizations (such as Loaves and Fishes) to aid the residents in need and provide technical support for the motel voucher program. N/A The City will continue to work with local non- profits and obtain CDBG grant funding for this program Continue program into next Housing Element. Program 4.1 – 3. Continue to allow group housing (residential care facilities) in accordance with State law. Additionally, the City will update the zoning regulations to clarify that both small (6 or fewer) and large (7 or more) residential care facilities are permitted by right in the Residential Multi Family (RMF) zone. N/A The City continues to support proper permitting of group housing in accordance with State law. The City completed changes to the RMF Zoning that clarifies that both small and large residential care facilities are permitted by right. Modify to consider allowing large residential care facilities in more zones. Program 4.1 – 4. Amend Zoning Ordinance to comply with SB 2, permitting emergency shelters without a conditional use permit or other discretionary permits in the Commercial Service (CS), Commercial Park (CPK), Public (P) zoning districts, or other appropriate zones or sites. These three zoning districts have sufficient capacity to house emergency shelters with over 74 acres available N/A Completed in 2013. City adopted Emergency Shelter Overlay Zone. The overlay is applied to one site currently operating as an emergency shelter. The shelter, operated by the El Camino Homeless Organization, has an existing capacity of 50 beds. As of 2014, there is excess capacity. Public Review Draft Page 17 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element Program Summary Quantified Objective Achievement Further Progress Needed The program will be modified to monitor capacity of the ECHO shelter and expand the ES zone allow more shelters if need arises. Policy 4.2- Ensure that persons with disabilities have adequate access to housing. Program 4.2 – 1. Continue to ensure full compliance with the California Disability Guidelines and enforce the complementary provisions of the Uniform Building Code. The Zoning Ordinance will be evaluated on an ongoing basis and amended as necessary, to ensure ADA compliance and remove governmental constraints on the production of housing for persons with disabilities. N/A City Staff continues to comply with ADA standards for new and change of occupancy building projects. Continue program into next Housing Element. Program 4.2 – 2. Pursuant to the Fair Housing Amendments Act of 1988 and the requirements of Chapter 671, Statues of 2001 (Senate Bill 520), the City will establish a policy or ordinance to provide reasonable accommodations (i.e. modifications or exceptions) in their zoning laws and other land use regulations and practices when such accommodations may be necessary to afford disabled persons equal access to housing. The purpose of the reasonable accommodation ordinance or policy is to remove constraints to the development, improvement and maintenance of housing for persons with disabilities. The City will promote its reasonable accommodations procedures on its web site and with handouts at City Hall. N/A Completed in 2013. None. Program Complete. Policy 4.3- Leverage redevelopment set-aside funds with other State and Federal loans and grants, to assist in providing affordable housing, preserving existing housing, and rehabilitating unsound housing structures. (This policy assumes that housing set aside funds are not affected by State budget take aways.) Program 4.3 – 1.Consider developing a first-time homebuyers program to enable lower-income households (up to 80 percent of AMI) to purchase their first homes. Assistance could be provided in the form of a loan secured by a deed of trust. 5 units This program has been suspended due to the dissolution of the RDA. Staff will seek grant funding available to continue this program. Remove program, no funding or staff to administer. Program 4.3 – 2.Leverage redevelopment housing set aside funds and partner with developers on projects funded with HOME funds, tax credits, and other 40 units This program has been suspended due to the dissolution of the RDA. This program may be Remove program. Public Review Draft Page 18 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element Program Summary Quantified Objective Achievement Further Progress Needed financial assistance programs for construction of houses affordable to lower-income households. Financial assistance to developers could include payment of impact fees and write down of land costs. continued once direction is given by the State on the future of the City's Housing set aside fund. Program 4.3 – 3. Consider establishing a housing rehabilitation program that provides loans and rebates to income- qualified households to correct Health and Safety Code violations and make essential repairs and retrofits. The maximum loan limit could be $20,000 with 0% interest and could be limited to lower-income households (<80 percent AMI). 75 units This program has been suspended due to the dissolution of the RDA. This program may be continued once direction is given by the State on the future of the City's Housing set aside fund. Remove Program. Program 4.3 – 4. Continue to use the Affordable Housing Participation Checklist and corresponding ranking system to evaluate and prioritize affordable housing developers and projects in the City. N/A The City will continue to utilize the checklist to evaluate affordable housing projects for any potential future funding that may become available. Continue program into next Housing Element. Program 4.3 – 5. Establish a program to assist building owners in converting upper floor residential space in the downtown to deed restricted extremely low-, very low- and low-income units 10 units The City created 2 units through this program. At this time the program has been suspended due to the dissolution of the RDA. Remove program. Program 4.3 – 6. Work with nonprofits and identify funding to address the housing needs of extremely low-income households and totally and permanently disabled persons. 5 units RDA funds are no longer available. City Staff will work with non-profits for any grant funding opportunities. Modify program and continue program into next Housing Element. Goal 5: Decrease non-governmental constraints on housing production Policy 5.1 – Encourage interplay between lending institutions, the real estate and development community, and the City to better understand and address non-governmental constraints and facilitate production of affordable housing. Program 5.1 – 1. Continue to facilitate understanding of the impacts of economic issues, employment, and growth on housing needs among financial, real estate, and development professionals in formalized settings, such as the Economic Round Table. N/A City Staff attend economic roundtables and other events as continuing education of these impacts. Continue program into next Housing Element. Public Review Draft Page 19 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element Program Summary Quantified Objective Achievement Further Progress Needed Program 5.1 – 2. Continue to work with development community to identify and mitigate any constraints on access to financing for multi-family development. The City will conduct regular stakeholder meetings with members of the development community including representatives from local non-profit housing organizations, developers, and real estate brokers to solicit feedback. N/A City Staff continues to work with developers, key stakeholders, and property owners on overcoming constraints in project design to help facilitate financing. Continue program into next Housing Element. Policy 5.2 – Help lower development costs where feasible, especially for low- and moderate-income housing units. Program 5.2 – 1. Continue to monitor and evaluate development standards and advances in housing construction methods. N/A As City staff identifies issues with the municipal code and advance construction methods, the City will amend the code as necessary. Continue program into next Housing Element. Program 5.2 – 2. Continue to track the affordability of housing projects and progress toward meeting regional housing needs. Reports should be provided semi-annually to the Planning Commission and annually to the City Council and the California Department of Housing and Community Development. N/A The City tracks all housing projects and provides status updates to both the Council and Planning Commission. Continue program into next Housing Element. Goal 6: Decrease governmental constraints on housing production Policy 6.1 – Review projects in as timely a manner as possible, while maintaining adequate public involvement and fulfilling the appropriate requirements of State and local laws. Program 6.1 –1.Continue to consolidate all actions relating to a specific project on the same Council or Commission agenda N/A Staff continues this practice for ease of tracking. Continue program into next Housing Element. Program 6.1 – 2. Continue to review minor modifications through an adjustment procedure and more substantial changes through a conditional use permit. N/A Staff utilized the DRC to make determinations that may necessitate further entitlement such as a CUP. Revise program to account for Design Review Committee role in review of residential projects and continue into next Housing Element. Program 6.1 – 3. Continue to review and revise local review procedures to streamline the process N/A The City created the Design Review Committee in 2010 to help with project streamlining and review. The DRC has been helpful in working out issues that normally would have been dealt by Planning Commission or Continue program into next Housing Element. Public Review Draft Page 20 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element Program Summary Quantified Objective Achievement Further Progress Needed simply at a staff level. Program 6.1 – 4. Continue to maintain pre-approved stock development plans to streamline the plan check process. . N/A Stock plans are available for larger projects. Continue program into next Housing Element. Program 6.1 – 5. Provide pre-application technical assistance to affordable housing providers to determine project feasibility and address zoning compliance issues in the most cost-effective and expeditious manner possible. N/A Staff provides pre- application and technical assistance to all projects when requested. Continue program into next Housing Element. Program 6.1 – 6. Provide, when possible, developer incentives such as expedited permit processing and fee deferrals for units that are affordable to lower income households. Atascadero will promote these incentives to developers on the City’s website (http://www.atascadero.org) and during the application process. N/A The City's process streamlining is already expediting projects. Developers can defer development impact fees until final occupancy. Continue program into next Housing Element. Program 6.1 –7. The City shall establish policies, standards, and procedures that encourage and facilitate the development of single-room occupancy units (SROs). N/A Completed in 2013. Program Complete. Consider modification of standards to allow SROs by right in MFR zones. Program 6.1 –8. The City shall review impact fees and the capital facility fee schedule to reduce fees and barriers to housing development, particularly affordable units. (See also Program 4.3-2 for the potential use of Redevelopment Agency Set-Aside Funds for fee waivers.) N/A City Staff solicited a proposal for completion of this. Modify program to allow for continued monitoring of fee schedule to mitigate constraints to affordable housing and consider revision to fees based on unit size to encourage affordability by design. Continue program into next Housing Element. Public Review Draft Page 21 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element C. Population and Employment Trends 1. Population The Atascadero population grew 7 percent from 2000 to 2010, for a total of 28,310 persons. Growth in Atascadero increased at a slower rate than that of San Luis Obispo County and Paso Robles, which grew 9 percent and 18 percent, respectively, during the same period. . The San Luis Obispo Council of Governments (SLOCOG) estimates the population in Atascadero to grow to 32,486 by 2040, a 14 percent increase from 2010. See Table V-3 for detailed population information for Atascadero and surrounding communities. Table V-2.Table V-3. Trends in Population Growth 2000 2010 Number Number Change Atascadero 26,411 28,310 7% Paso Robles 24,297 29,793 18% San Luis Obispo 44,174 45,119 2% San Luis Obispo County 246,681 269,637 9% Source: U.S. Census, 2000 and 2010 Age Characteristics As of 2010, Atascadero had a median age of 41, slightly above the median for San Luis Obispo County at 39.4. Substantial growth can be seen in the 55-64 and 25-34 age groups from 2000 to 2010, while the population in the 35-44 age group decreased by 37 percent over the same period. This is similar to trends seen across the state, in which the proportion of individuals over the age of 50 has increased significantly over the past 10 years, while the age group 35-44 declined. See Table V-4 for additional information on age trends in Atascadero. Table V-3.Table V-4. Trends in Population Age Age Group 2000 2010 Percent Change Number of Persons Percent of Total Number of Persons Percent of Total < 15 5,389 20% 4,970 18% -8% 15-24 3,562 13% 3,378 12% -5% 25-34 2,892 11% 3,805 13% 24% 35-44 4,713 18% 3,439 12% -37% 45-54 4,518 17% 4,682 17% 4% 55-64 2,293 9% 4,350 15% 47% 65+ 3,044 12% 3,686 13% 17% Total 26,411 100% 28,310 100% 7% Source: U.S. Census, 2000 and 2010 Public Review Draft Page 22 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element Race and Ethnicity As of 2010, the population for the City of Atascadero was 86 percent white, down 3 percent from 89 percent in 2000. The next highest racial category represented in Atascadero is other/two or more races. Of the total population, 16 percent are Hispanic in origin, an increase of almost 60 percent between 2000 and 2010. Refer to Table V-5 for detailed figures on race and ethnicity. Table V-4.Table V-5. Trends in Race and Ethnicity Race/Ethnicity 2000 2010 Number Percent Number Percent White 23,451 89% 24,457 86% Black or African American 623 2% 585 2% Asian or Pacific Islander 336 1% 685 2% American Indian 247 1% 295 1% Other/Two or More 1,754 7% 2,288 8% Total 26,411 100% 28,310 100% Hispanic (all races) 2,783 11% 4,429 16% Source: U.S. Census, 2000 and 2010 2. Employment According to SLOCOG (2011), in 2010 there was an estimated 8,400 jobs in Atasacadero, with an expected increase to 10,900 by 2040. Professional and business services and education services, health care, and social assistance are the two job sectors with the highest anticipated growth by 2040 (See SLOCOG 2040 Regional Growth Forecast). The major industry and occupation sectors of Atascadero residents are shown below. Industry employment in Atascadero was spread over a number of sectors in both 2000 and 2010. From 2000 to 2010 the total number of employed residents increased 3 percent from 12,456 to 12,828. As of 2010, the Education, Health, and Social Services industry accounted for the largest share of Atascadero employment, accounting for 29 percent, a 4 percent increase from 2000. Retail trade is the second largest industry, offering 12 percent of total jobs, followed closely by Professional, Scientific, Management, Administrative, and Waste Management services at 10 percent of the jobs, a 35 percent increase from 2000. Whole Sale Trade had the largest job loss from 2000 to 2010, down 34 percent. See Table V-6 for additional information on industry trends in Atascadero. Table V-5.Table V-6. Industry Trends in Atascadero Employment Sector 2000 2010 Percent Change Number Percent Number Percent Educational, health and social services 3,041 25% 3,717 29% 22% Retail trade 1,502 12% 1,481 12% -1% Public Review Draft Page 23 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element Professional, scientific, management, administrative, and waste management services 979 8% 1,317 10% 35% Construction 1,221 10% 1,129 9% -8% Public administration 1,027 9% 1,089 8% 6% Arts, entertainment, recreation, accommodation and food services 1,098 9% 821 6% -25% Manufacturing 747 6% 760 6% 2% Transportation and warehousing, and utilities 649 5% 691 5% 6% Finance, insurance, real estate, and rental and leasing 598 5% 641 5% 7% Other services 875 7% 583 5% -33% Wholesale trade 408 3% 268 2% -34% Agriculture, forestry, fishing and hunting, and mining 139 1% 180 1% 29% Information 172 1% 151 1% -12% Total 12,456 100% 12,828 100% 3% Source: U.S. Census, 2000 and 2006-2010 ACS (5 year estimates) In 2010, 40 percent of Atascadero residents held managerial/professional jobs, representing a continuing trend from 2000. Managerial/professional occupations increased 27 percent from 2000 to 2010, growing from 4,015 to 5,105 jobs. Occupations in the sales and office sector also increased from 3,064 to 3,326 jobs during this period, an increase of 9 percent. Occupations in services; production, transportation, and material moving occupations; and natural resources, construction, and maintenance occupations experienced decreases for the period. Table V-7 provides additional information on occupation trends. Table V-6.Table V-7. Trends in Occupations Occupations of Residents 2000 2010 Percent Change Persons Percent Persons Percent Managerial/Professional 4,015 33% 5,105 40% 27% Sales and Office 3,064 25% 3,326 26% 9% Services 2,428 20% 2,091 16% -14% Natural resources, construction, and maintenance occupations 1,540 13% 1,308 10% -15% Production, transportation, and material moving occupations 1,237 10% 998 8% -19% Total 12,284 100% 12,828 100% 4% Source: U.S. Census, 2000 and 2006-2010 ACS (5 year estimates) Public Review Draft Page 24 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element The distribution of class of workers in Atascadero remained similar from 2000 to 2010. As of 2010, the private sector employed 64 percent of Atascadero workers, the government sector employed 24 percent, 12 percent were self-employed and less than one percent were unpaid family workers. Refer to Table V-8 for trends in class of worker. Table V-7.Table V-8. Class of Worker Trends Employment Sector 2000 2010 Percent Change Number Percent Number Percent Private wage and salary workers 7,408 60% 8,187 64% 11% Government workers 3,190 26% 3,045 24% -5% Self-employed workers in own (not incorporated) business 1,665 14% 1,566 12% -6% Unpaid family workers 21 <1% 30 <1% 43% Total 12,284 100% 12,828 100% 4% Source: U.S. Census, 2000 and 2006-2010 ACS (5 year estimates) Public Review Draft Page 25 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element D. Housing Characteristics 1. Households Household composition and size are often interrelated and are indicators of the type of housing appropriate for residents of Atascadero. The majority of householders in Atascadero are 35 to 65 years old. This age group represented 60 percent of householders in Atascadero in 2010. From 2000 to 2010, the number of householders over the age of 65 increased from 20 to 22 percent, representing the highest percent growth between 2000 and 2010. The percentage of family households fell slightly from 71 percent in 2000 to 69 percent in 2010, while the percentage of single person households increased over the same period. The average household size dropped from 2.62 in 2000 to 2.51 in 2010. There was a 34 percent increase in household types of the “other” category from 2000 to 2010. See Table V-9 for detailed figures on household structure in Atascadero Table V-8.Table V-9. Trends in Households 2000 2010 Percent Change Number Percent Number Percent Avg. Household Size 2.62 2.51 Households by Age Householders < 35 yrs 1,650 17% 1,953 18% 18% Householders 35-65 yrs 5,968 63% 6,465 60% 8% Householders 65+ yrs 1,913 20% 2,319 22% 21% Household Types Family Households 6,812 71% 7,404 69% 9% Married Couple 5,286 78% 5,681 77% 7% Other Families 1,526 22% 1,723 23% 13% Single Persons 2,094 22% 2,497 23% 19% Other 625 7% 836 8% 34% Total 9,531 100% 10,737 100% 13% Source: U.S. Census, 2000 and 2010 Household Income According to the U.S. Census, the median household income in Atascadero increased 34 percent from $48,725 in 2000 to $65,479 in 2010. The largest increases were in the $75,000 to $99,999 and $100,000 or more income brackets, with the latter increasing over 100 percent for the period. The $10,000 to $14,999 income category also grew, while the remaining income brackets decreased, with the less than $10,000 income category experiencing the largest decrease. Refer to Table V-10 for trends in Atascadero household income groups. Public Review Draft Page 26 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element Table V-9.Table V-10. Trends in Household Income Groups Income Group 2000 2010 Percent Change Households Percent Households Percent Less than $10,000 619 7% 355 3% -43% $10,000 to $14,999 480 5% 556 5% 16% $15,000 to $24,999 1,066 11% 817 8% -23% $25,000 to $34,999 1,175 12% 957 9% -19% $35,000 to $49,999 1,560 17% 1,409 13% -10% $50,000 to $74,999 2,407 25% 2,070 20% -14% $75,000 to $99,999 1,147 12% 1,533 15% 34% $100,000 or more 1,044 11% 2,756 26% 164% Total Households 9,498 100% 10,453 100% 10% Median household income $48,725 $65,479 34% Source: U.S. Census, 2000 and 2010 Tenure and Vacancy Housing tenure refers to the occupancy of a housing unit – whether the unit is owner-occupied or renter-occupied. Housing tenure is influenced by demographic factors (e.g., household income, composition, and age of the householder) as well as the cost of housing. As of 2010, 7 percent of Atascadero’s housing units were vacant. This is 4 percent higher than 2000, when the vacancy rate was 43 percent. It is generally accepted that a vacancy rate of 5 to 6 percent is healthy, thus Atascadero’s higher vacancy may be an indicator of economic problems associated with the recession. Indicators of a strengthening housing market are seen with the increasing home price and value, as discussed under housing affordability, in section 5 below. Among occupied units, the percentage of owner-occupied homes decreased from 66 percent in 2000 to 59 percent in 2010. See Table V-11 for detailed figures on housing tenure. Table V-10.Table V-11. Trends in Housing Tenure Tenure 2000 2010 Number Percent Number Percent Occupied Units 9,531 97% 10,737 93% Owner 6,249 66% 6,827 59% Renter 3,282 34% 3,910 34% Vacant Units 317 3% 768 7% Total 9,848 100% 11,505 100% Source: U.S. Census, 2000 and 2010 Public Review Draft Page 27 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element 2. Housing Units Housing Type and Age The majority of Atascadero homes are single-family detached. The variety of housing types has remained similar over the period from 2000 to 2010, with growth in single-family homes detached and slight decline in single-family homes attached. Slight increases can be seen in multi-family units and mobile homes with a complete loss of other housing types. Table V-12 shows trends in housing units by type. Table V-11.Table V-12. Trends in Housing Type Housing Type 2000 2010 Units Percent Units Percent Single-Family Detached 6,797 69% 8,068 72% Single-Family Attached 441 4% 427 4% Multiple-Family 2-4 Units 862 9% 1,030 9% Multiple-Family 5+ Units 1,200 12% 1,241 11% Mobile Homes 507 5% 517 5% Other (e.g., R.V Park) 44 <1% 0 0% Total Units 9,851 100% 11,283 100% Source: U.S. Census, 2000 and 2010 According to the U.S. Census, 49 percent of Atascadero’s housing stock was built after 1980. Housing construction slowed from 1990 to 2010. There were 2,876 units constructed during this period, down from 2,782 in the 1970s, but slightly higher than the 2,647 housing units constructed in the 1980s. See Table V-13 for a breakdown of Atascadero housing units by year constructed. Table V-12.Table V-13. Housing Units by Age Year Built Units Percent Built 2005 or later 506 4% Built 2000 to 2004 967 9% Built 1990 to 1999 1,403 12% Built 1980 to 1989 2,647 23% Built 1970 to 1979 2,782 25% Built 1960 to 1969 1,048 9% Built 1950 to 1959 911 8% Built 1940 to 1949 548 5% Built 1939 or earlier 471 4% Total 11,283 100% Source: U.S. Census, 2010 Public Review Draft Page 28 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element 3. Housing Conditions City staff conducted a visual housing conditions survey in June 2009. To complete the survey, the City randomly selected and evaluated 200 properties and found that all but three were structurally sound. Utilizing the same methodology, Staff re-reviewed the same 200 properties from the 2009 survey. A total of two properties were found not to be structurally sound, yet required only minor repairs. The survey was conducted through a windshield assessment that rated the physical condition of a unit in one of the following categories: - Foundation, - Roofing, - Siding/Stucco, - Windows, and; - Electrical. 4. Housing Costs Median Home Price According to the real estate website, Trulia.com, the median home sales price in Atascadero between January and April, 2014, was $365,000. Historical home price data from Central Coast Lending shows that home sales prices have remained relatively steady since 2013, when median price in April 2013 was $368,000, a 16.9 percent increase from 2012. Overall, the housing market is recovering from the overall price floor in 2011, of $302,500, a 41.8 percent drop from peak prices in 2005 ($520,000). See Figure V-1 for a comparison of median home prices in Atascadero and San Luis Obispo County from 2003 to 2012. Figure V-1. Median Home Price, 2003-2013 Atascadero and SLO County Public Review Draft Page 29 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element Median Rent According to the 2010-2012 U.S. Census ACS 3-year estimates, the median rent in Atascadero was $1,109 per month. More than half of all renters in Atascadero are cost burdened. See Table 15 for more information on renter cost burden. Low and Extremely Low-Income Housing Needs Lower income households (earning 80 percent or less of the area’s median household income) generally have higher incidence of housing problems and overpayment (paying 30 percent or more of income for housing costs). Table V-14 shows what percentages of low, very-low, and extremely low-income (ELI) households in Atascadero have housing problems, as well as those overpaying for housing. Extremely low-income households earn 30 percent or less of median household income. Of the 10,737 households in the City, 960 households (620 renters and 340 owners) have household incomes less than 30 percent of median income (about 8.9 percent of total households). As Table V-14 illustrates, these households have a high percentage of housing problems, with the majority (80 percent) cost burdened, and between 60 and 70 percent extremely cost burdened (greater than 50 percent of household income on housing costs). Very-low income households are similarly cost burdened, with over 90 percent of very-low income renters spending greater than 30 percent of household income on housing costs. Tables V-15 and V-16 discuss the overpayment in Atascadero by tenure. The current RHNA estimates the City of Atascadero will need to accommodate 98 very-low income housing units between 2014 and 2019. Based on the State law methodology, the City estimates that 50 percent of very-low-income households are extremely low-income (ELI) households. Therefore, it is projected that the City will need to accommodate 49 ELI households. Table V-13.Table V-14. Housing Problems for All Lower Income Households Renters Owners Total Households Housing Income <= 30 Percent MFI 620 340 960 (Extremely Low Income) % With any Housing Problems 86.29% 79.41% 83.85% % With Housing Cost Burden > 30% 83.87% 80.88% 82.81% % With Housing Cost Burden > 50% 70.16% 60.29% 66.67% Household Income >30% to <= 50% MFI (Very Low Income) 645 420 1,065 % With any housing problems 82.95% 83.33% 88.26% % With Housing cost burden > 30% 91.47% 83.33% 88.26% Household income > 50 to <= 80% MFI (Low Income) 820 670 1,490 % With any housing problems 65.24% 52.24% 59.40% % With Housing cost burden > 30% 64.02% 52.99% 58.39% Source: CHAS Databook, 2014 Public Review Draft Page 30 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element Overpayment According to federal government standards, paying over 30 percent of income for housing costs is considered to be cost-burdened, and spending more than 50 percent of household income is extremely cost burdened. In Atascadero, overpayment is particularly problematic for renters. An estimated 8.4 percent of renters pay between 30 and 34.9 percent of household income on rent and 47 percent of renters pay more than 35 percent of household income on rent. See Table V-15. Table V-14.Table V-15. Gross Rent as a Percent of Income 2012 Unit Type Total Percent Gross Rent $1,109 / Less than 15 % 417 10.4% 15% to 19.9% 489 12.2% 20% to 24.9 % 446 11.1% 25% to 29.9% 438 10.9% 30% to 34.9 % 338 8.4% More than 35% 1,888 47.0% Overall 4,106 100% Source: U.S. Census, ACS 2010- 2012 (3-year estimates) Among homeowners, 48.4 percent of owners with a mortgage and 12.1 percent of owners without a mortgage were overpaying for housing. See Tables V-16 for monthly housing costs a percentage of household income for homeowners. Table V-15.Table V-16. Monthly Owner Costs as a Percentage of Household Income Number of Households With a Mortgage Without a Mortgage Total Percent Total Percent Less than 20 % 1,472 27.7% 1,160 75.8% 20 % to 24.9 % 669 12.6% 126 8.2% 25 % to 29.9 % 609 11.4% 59 3.9% 30 % to 34.9 % 620 11.7% 62 4.0% More than 35 % 1,951 36.7% 124 8.1% Total 5,321 100% 1,531 100% Source: U.S. Census, ACS 2010-2012 (3 year estimates) Public Review Draft Page 31 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element 5. Housing Affordability Housing affordability in Atascadero can be inferred by comparing the cost of renting or owning a home with the income levels of households of different sizes. Table V-17 shows the annual income ranges for extremely low-, very low-, low-, and moderate-income households. Table V-18 shows the maximum affordable monthly rental payment based on the standard of 30 percent (as defined by HUD) of household income going towards housing costs. The table also displays the maximum affordable home sale or rental price based on income category and unit size. Homes priced at the 2014 median sales prices of $365,000 for Atascadero are affordable only to households in the upper end of the moderate-income range. Thus home ownership is out of range for many moderate and all low-, very low- and extremely low-income households. Average rents are affordable for moderate income households but are unaffordable without overpayment or overcrowding for households earning at the extremely low-, very low-, and low-income levels. Table V-18. San Luis Obispo County Maximum Sales and Rental Prices HCD Income Limits Monthly Housing Costs Maximum Affordable Price Max Annual Income Affordable Total Payment Utilities Taxes & Ins. (for ownership) Own Rent Income Group Very Low One Person $26,400 $660 $75 $184 $66,950 $585 Two Person $30,200 $755 $100 $205 $75,079 $655 Three Person $33,950 $849 $125 $226 $83,066 $724 Four Person $37,700 $943 $150 $247 $91,051 $793 Low One Person $42,250 $1,056 $75 $310 $111,905 $981 Two Person $48,250 $1,206 $100 $349 $126,270 $1,106 Three Person $54,300 $1,358 $125 $388 $140,783 $1,233 Four Person $60,300 $1,508 $150 $427 $155,156 $1,358 Moderate One Person $64,700 $1,618 $75 $489 $175,692 $1,543 Two Person $73,900 $1,848 $100 $553 $199,169 $1,748 Three Person $83,150 $2,079 $125 $618 $222,796 $1,954 Four Person $92,400 $2,310 $150 $683 $246,419 $2,160 Table V-16.Table V-17. San Luis Obispo County Income Limits Persons in Family Extremely Low Very Low Low Moderate One $15,850 $26,400 $42,250 $64,700 Two $18,100 $30,200 $48,250 $73,900 Three $20,350 $33,950 $54,300 $83,150 Four $22,600 $37,700 $60,300 $92,400 Source: HCD, 2014 Public Review Draft Page 32 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element Notes: 1. Utility costs assumed at $75 per month for one person households and an additional $25 for each additional person. 2. Taxes and insurance include property taxes, private mortgage insurance, and homeowners insurance. 3. Total affordable mortgage based on an annual six percent interest rate, 30-year mortgage, and monthly payment equal to 30 percent of income (after utilities, taxes, and insurance). Even though interest rates are at historic lows (four to five percent) for a 30-year conventional mortgage, six percent was used as a more conservative estimate over time. 4. Monthly affordable rent based on 30 percent of income less estimated utilities costs. Source: HCD Income Limits 2014, Lisa Wise Consulting, Inc., 2014 6. At-Risk Units State law requires that Housing Elements include an inventory and analysis of assisted multi- family housing units “at risk” of conversion to market-rate housing. The inventory must account for all units for which subsidies expire within the planning period for the Housing Element update. The potential loss of existing affordable housing units is an important issue to the City due to potential displacement of lower-income tenants and the limited alternative housing options available for such persons. It is typically less expensive to preserve the affordability of existing units than to subsidize construction of new affordable units due to the rising cost of land and construction. In Atascadero, there are no units currently at risk of converting from affordable to market rate. In 2011, the new owner of California Manor, a 95-unit, multi-family rental property formerly at risk of converting from affordable units to market rate, was awarded 9 percent State Low- Income Tax Credit financing for acquisition and rehabilitation to maintain the unit affordability. Currently, the tax credits have been awarded, but the owners have not submitted documentation signifying the completion of rehabilitation. As part of the purchase agreement for financing of the transfer of ownership, the owner agreed to maintain the affordability of the units for an additional 30 years. Renovations will include the installation of a new roof, ADA accessibility upgrades, concrete siding, energy-efficient appliances, carpet, linoleum, cabinets, countertops, HVAC, and lighting. Public Review Draft Page 33 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element E. Special Housing Needs Certain members of the population encounter unique difficulties in finding appropriate housing due to special circumstances. Special circumstances may be related to one’s employment type and income, family characteristics, medical condition or disability, and/or household characteristics. Table V-19 lists special needs populations. This section discusses the housing needs for each group and identifies the major programs available to address their housing and services needs. Table V-19. Special Needs Populations, 2000 and 2010 Special Needs Group 2000 2010 Number Percent Number Percent Senior Households 1,935 20% 2,319 19% Persons with Disabilities1 4,437 19% 3,092 12% Single-Parent Households 1,565 23%1,723 16% Large Households 941 10%940 9% Residents Employed in Farming <139 <1%180 1% Homeless 184 1% 96 <1% Note: 1. Civilian non-institutionalized population ages 5 and above. Source: U.S. Census, 2000and 2010and EOC 2009, Homeless Services Oversight Council, 2013 1. Senior Households Senior households are included in those with special housing needs due to the likelihood of limited income, physical disabilities, or higher health care costs. As illustrated in Table V-20, 2,319 Atascadero households (22 percent) were headed by seniors (persons age 65 years and older) in 2010. The number of seniors is expected to continue to grow as the percentage of residents in the 55 to 64 year age range increased by21 percent in the period from 2000 to 2010. In Atascadero, about 64 percent of senior householders were homeowners in 2010. Table V-20. Senior Households, 2010 Householder by Age Owner Renter Total Number Percent Number Percent Number Percent Total 65 and over 1,820 27% 499 13% 2,319 22% 65 to 74 years 1,011 15% 226 6% 1,237 12% 75 to 84 years 589 9% 144 4% 733 7% 85 years & over 220 3% 129 3% 349 3% Total 64 and under 5,007 73% 3,411 87% 8,418 78% Total (all ages) 6,827 100% 3,910 100% 10,737 100% Source: U.S. Census, 2010 Public Review Draft Page 34 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element According to the 2006-2010 ACS, approximately 53 percent of senior households earn less than $50,000 annually, with 28 percent earning less than $30,000 per year. This is less than 50 percent of the median household income for the City of Atascadero, $65,479 (Table V-21). The same report estimates 5.1 percent of senior households are living below the poverty line. As stated above, seniors typically have special needs due to disabilities, health care needs, and fixed incomes. Seniors may also require assistance with domestic chores and activities such as driving, cooking, cleaning, showering, or climbing stairs. For elderly people who live alone or don’t have relatives to care for them, the need for assistance may not be met. The special needs of seniors can by met through congregate care, rent subsidies, shared housing, and housing rehabilitation assistance. For the frail or disabled elderly, housing with architectural design features that accommodate disabilities can help extend the ability to live independently. In addition, seniors with mobility/ self-care limitations benefit from transportation options. As of 2014, there are twelve residential and group care facilities offering 171 units in Atascadero. The facilities offer a range in level of assistance and community structure. Refer to Table V-22 for a detailed list of senior housing facilities. In meeting the needs of the increasing elderly population, the following factors must be considered: • Limited remaining sites suitably zoned for senior housing; • Decreasing State and Federal funding to provide additional housing for seniors; and • Physical and/or other restrictions that may limit seniors’ ability to maintain their own health and the condition of their home. Table V-17.Table V-22. Senior Housing Facilities, 2014 Facility Capacity Location A Touch Above Care, Inc 6 5800 Llano Road A Touch Above Care, Sycamore 6 7150 Sycamore Road Atascadero Christian Home 64 8455 Santa Rosa Road C.A.L.L. – Carmelita House 6 2660 Ferrocarril Table V-21. Households by Income Level, 2006-2010 Income Level Percent of Elderly Household Under $30,000 28.1% $30,000 to $49,999 24.8% $50,000 to $74,999 19.5% $75,000 to $99,999 8.0% More than $100,000 19.7% Total 100% Source: U.S. Census 2006-2010 ACS Public Review Draft Page 35 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element Country Living Senior Home 8 4930 Sycamore Road Garden View Inn 15 7105 San Gabriel Road Horizon Hills Retirement Home 6 10775 San Marcos Road Ingleside Assisted Living 16 10630 West Front Road Ingleside By the Lake 6 9375 Mountain View Drive Paradise Valley Care 15 9525 Gallina Court Paradise Valley Care at the Lake, Inc 11 9220 Mountain View Drive Park Place 12 9435 El Bordo Avenue Total 171 Source: CA Department of Social Services, 2014 2. Persons with Disabilities Persons with disabilities have special housing needs because of employment and income challenges, the need for accessible and appropriate housing, and higher health care costs. A disability is defined broadly by the U.S. Census Bureau as a physical, mental, or emotional condition that lasts over a long period of time and makes it difficult to live independently. The U.S. Census collects data for several categories of disability. These categories are defined below: General disabilities: • Sensory disability: Blindness, deafness, or a severe vision or hearing impairment. • Physical disability: A condition that substantially limits one or more basic physical activities such as walking, climbing stairs, reaching, lifting, or carrying. Disabilities lasting six months or more: • Mental disability: Difficulty learning, remembering, or concentrating. • Self-care disability: Difficulty dressing, bathing, or getting around inside the home. • Independent- living disability: Difficulty going outside the home alone to shop or visit a doctor’s office. In 2010, there were 2,053 non-institutionalized persons in Atascadero living with a disability (Table V-23). Approximately 50 percent of all persons with disabilities are over the age of 65, and thus face additional housing needs, as described in the previous section. Table V-23. Persons with Disabilities by Type Total disabilities for people 5 to 64 years 2,053 66% Sensory disability 523 17% Physical disability 1,091 35% Mental disability 897 29% Self-care disability 592 19% Independent-living disability 932 30% Total disabilities for people 65 years and over 1,039 34% Public Review Draft Page 36 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element Sensory disability 932 30% Physical disability 440 14% Mental disability 203 7% Self-care disability 120 4% Independent-living disability 373 12% Total disabilities for all ages 3,092 100% Source: 2008-2010 ACS (3-year estimates) Persons with Developmental Disabilities According to Section 4512 of the Welfare and Institutions Code a “dDevelopmental disability” means a disability that originates before an individual attains age 18 years, continues, or can be expected to continue , indefinitely, and constitutes a substantial disability for that individual, which includes mental retardation, cerebral palsy, epilepsy, and autism. This term shall also include disabling conditions found to be closely related to mental retardation or to require treatment similar to that required for individuals with mental retardation, but shall not include other handicapping conditions that are solely physical in nature. Many persons with developmental disabilities can live and work independently within a conventional housing environment. Individuals with more severe developmental disabilities require a group living environment where supervision is provided. The most severely affected individuals may require an institutional environment where medical attention and physical therapy are provided. Because developmental disabilities exist before adulthood, the first issue in supportive housing for the persons with developmental disabilities is transition from the person’s living situation as a child to an appropriate level of independence as an adult. The State Department of Developmental Services (DDS) currently provides community-based services to approximately 243,000 persons with developmental disabilities and their families through a statewide system of 21 regional centers, four developmental centers, and two community-based facilities. The Tri-Counties Regional Center (TCRC) is one of 21 regional centers in the State of California that provides point of entry to services for people with developmental disabilities who reside in Ventura, Santa Barbara, and San Luis Obispo Counties. TCRC is a private, non-profit community agency that contracts with local businesses to offer a wide range of services to individuals with developmental disabilities and their families. As of 2014, TCRC served approximately 11,500 people in their three-county area, with 280 staff members. Table V-24 shows the number of individuals served by TCRC in the 93422 zip code, which includes the City of Atascadero. (Note: The boundary of this zip code extends beyond the borders of Atascadero city limits.) There are a number of housing types appropriate for people living with a development disability: rent subsidized homes, licensed and unlicensed single-family homes, inclusionary housing, Section 8 vouchers, special programs for home purchase, HUD housing, and SB 962 homes. The design of housing-accessibility modifications, proximity to services and transit, and availability of group living opportunities represent the types of considerations important in serving this need group. Incorporating ‘barrier-free’ design in all, new multifamily housing (as required by California and Federal Fair Housing laws) is especially important to provide the Public Review Draft Page 37 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element widest range of choices for disabled residents. Special consideration should also be given to affordability of housing, as people with disabilities may be living on a fixed income. Table V-24. Number of Persons with Developmental Disabilities, 2014 0-14 years 15-22 Years 23-54 years 55-65 years 65+ years Total 93422 118 43 101 29 21 312 Source: Tri-County Regional Center, 2014 3. Large Families and Overcrowding A household of five or more persons is considered to be a large family. In 2010, nine percent of Atascadero households had five or more persons. Large households may experience difficulty in finding suitable units, particularly renter-occupied households, which are much less likely to find three or more bedroom units. See Table V-25 for household size by tenure for Atascadero. Table V-25. Household Size by Tenure in Atascadero 1-4 Persons 5+ Persons Total Owner Occupied 6,243 (58%) 584 (5%) 6,827 (64%) Renter Occupied 3,554 (33%) 356 (3%) 3,910 (36%) Total 9,797 (91%) 940 (9%) 10,737 Source: U.S. Census, 2010 Overcrowding is defined as more than one person per room not including kitchens and bathrooms. Overcrowding can occur when housing costs are high relative to income where families must double up or reside in smaller units, which tend to be more affordable, to devote income to other basic living needs. This is often a problem for large families but can also occur in smaller households when income is too low to afford adequate housing. Overcrowding also tends to result in accelerated deterioration of homes, a shortage of off-street parking, increased strain on public infrastructure, and additional traffic congestion. As illustrated in Table V-26, in 2010, 0.9 percent of owner-occupied households in Atascadero were overcrowded and 6.3 percent of renter-occupied households were overcrowded, of these less than one percent was extremely overcrowded. Table V-26. Overcrowded Households in Atascadero, 2010 Owner Occupied 6,970 units Percent 0.50 or less occupants per room 5,260 75% 0.51 to 1.00 occupants per room 1,648 24% 1.01 to 1.50 occupants per room 62 1% 1.51 to 2.00 occupants per room 0 0% 2.01 or more occupants per room 0 0% Percent Overcrowded by Tenure 62 (0.9%) total overcrowded owner-occupied units Public Review Draft Page 38 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element Renter Occupied 3,483 units Percent 0.50 or less occupants per room 1,893 54% 0.51 to 1.00 occupants per room 1,370 39% 1.01 to 1.50 occupants per room 206 6% 1.51 to 2.00 occupants per room 0 0% 2.01 or more occupants per room 14 <1% Percent Overcrowded by Tenure 220 (6.3%) total overcrowded renter-occupied units Total 10,453 Source: U.S. Census, 2006-2010 ACS (5-year estimates) 4. Single-Parent Households As of 2010, sixteen percent (1,723) of Atascadero households were single-parent families, 69 percent (1,185) of which are headed by women with no husband present. Housing problems for this group can be significant. Any household with only one person able to earn wages is at a significant disadvantage in the housing market and single parents may have to take more time off from work to care for their children. Single-parent households are at a higher risk of becoming homeless because of lower incomes and the lack of affordable housing and support services. Planning for housing development to serve single-parent families may require on-site child-care facilities. Housing needs of single-parent households is an important issue in Atascadero. Table V-27. Single Parent Households, 2010 Owner-occupied housing units Renter-occupied housing units Total Total Percent Total Percent Family households [1] 5,172 75.8 2,232 57.1 7,404 Female householder, no husband present 484 7.1 701 17.9 1,185 Male householder, no wife present 236 3.5 302 7.7 538 Single Parent Households 720 10.6 1003 25.6 1,723 Nonfamily households [2] 1,655 24.2 1,678 42.9 3,333 Male householder 726 10.6 787 20.1 1,513 Female householder 929 13.6 891 22.8 1,820 Total Households 6,827 100 3,910 100 10,737 Source: U.S. Census, 2010 Female Head of Households According to the U.S. Census, Atascadero had 3,005 female head of households in 2010. Female householders made up 37 percent of all householders in Atascadero in 2010. Female-headed households have unique housing needs due to a single source of income and greater cost burden. More female-headed households live below the poverty line than other family type, which emphasizes their need for affordable housing. The U.S. Census estimates 17.2 percent of single parent female- headed households in Atascadero are living below the poverty line, 11 percent higher than family households. Public Review Draft Page 39 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element Table V-28. Female Headed Households, 2010 2010 Number Percent Female Family Householder, no husband present 1,185 20% With children under 18 years 778 65.7 Female Non-Family Householder 1,820 17% Total Female Householders 3,005 37% Family Households Below Poverty Level 6.1% Female Households Below Poverty Level 17.2% With Children under 18 years 18.7% Total Households 10,737 100% Source: U.S. Census, 2010 5. Persons in Need of Emergency Shelter State housing element law requires the analysis of the special housing requirements of persons and families in need of emergency shelter and identification of adequate sites that will be made available with appropriate zoning and development standards, and with public services and facilities needed to facilitate the development of emergency shelters and transitional housing. According to the 2000 U.S. Census, there were approximately 184 homeless persons in Atascadero. More recently, initial data from the January 2013 San Luis Obispo County Homeless Enumeration Report Point in Time Survey estimates a homeless population of 2,186 in San Luis Obispo County. This represents a 3 percent increase in the homeless population in San Luis Obispo County from 2011. Based on this count, the Homeless Services Oversight Council (HSOC) estimates 3,497 persons will be without shelter at some point during the year. Of those surveyed in the County, 571 were chronically homeless, 71 percent lived in San Luis Obispo County before becoming homeless, 82 percent were unsheltered, 49 percent indicated having some mental illness, 12 percent were minors, and 9 percent were between 18 and 24 years old. Note: Consistent with HUD definition of homeless, the HSOC did not include families living doubled up with other families or those living in RV or trailer parks in the count of homeless. There were 466 homeless identified in (21 percent) located in North County, including 96 in the City of Atascadero. The majority of homeless in North County were living on the streets, with 16 percent in an emergency or transitional shelter. Atascadero participates in local efforts to assist the homeless and those in need of temporary shelter. Atascadero amended its Zoning Ordinance to allow for an Emergency Shelter Overlay Zone. This Zone provides an area where an emergency shelters may be permitted without a Conditional Use Permit in compliance with Senate Bill 2. Currently, one site is zoned and operating under the Emergency Shelter Overlay Zone (APN 030-341-013) with a maximum capacity of 50 beds. Prior to the Zoning amendment to permit emergency shelters at this site, Public Review Draft Page 40 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element the emergency shelter was ‘at risk’ of permanent closure. To ensure the new ordinance was not overly restrictive, the City worked closely with El Camino Housing Organization (ECHO), a non-profit organization that addresses homelessness issues and, operates this facility. 6. Farmworkers The number of farmworkers in Atascadero is difficult to quantify as U.S. Census data frequently underestimates this population. However, according to 2010 U.S. Census data, 180 members of the Atascadero population were employed in agriculture, forestry, fishing and hunting, and mining. This represents approximately one percent of the total population. From 2000 to 2010, the number of residents working under this Census category increased about 53 percent. The City has approximately 43.82 acres of designated “agriculture”, comprising of 5 separate parcels currently under one owner. These parcels are being utilized as a Christmas tree farm to grow and sell seasonal Christmas trees. Atascadero Municipal Code section 9-3.122 (o) allows for “farm labor quarters” as a permitted use, where no Conditional Use Permit (CUP) is required, in all Agriculture zones. Agriculture uses are conditionally allowed in the RS zone for uses such as crop production and grazing. This category is defined as “Agricultural uses including the production of grains, field crops, vegetables, melons, fruits, tree nuts, flower fields and seed production, tree and sod farms, crop services and crop harvesting. Also includes the raising or feeding of beef cattle, sheep and goats by grazing or pasturing.” This type of use may require farm labor quarters and may be included as a part of a CUP. Program 4.1.6 has been included to ensure the City complies with the Employee Housing Act, and permits farmworker housing for six or fewer employees as a single family residential use and for up to 12 units, or 36 beds, as an agricultural use subject to same level of review as other agricultural uses in the same zone. While there are very few agricultural parcels in the city, Atascadero is surrounded by land devoted to agricultural uses, including vineyards. It is likely that farmworkers may be housed on-site at agricultural operations outside Atascadero. Because of the limited need for farmworker housing, the City’s current method of permitting Farmworker housing and the overall approach to affordable housing meets existing need. Public Review Draft Page 41 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element F. Housing Resources As part of housing element law, the State has adopted a process for determining each local jurisdiction’s fair share of regional housing needs. The process begins with the State Department of Housing and Community Development (HCD) meeting with each regional council of governments to determine the need for new housing in that region. The regional council of governments is then required to determine the share of the housing need that should be assigned to each city and county in the region. The allocation includes a share of housing needs for all income levels (California Health and Safety Code Section 50079.5): very low income (less than 50 percent of the area median income); low income (50-80 percent of median income); moderate income (80-120 percent of median income); and above moderate income (more than 120 percent of median income). 1. Regional Housing Needs Allocation SLOCOG and HCD determined that the County has a need for 4,090 new housing units during the period from January 1, 2014 to June 30, 2019. SLOCOG allocated shares of this need to cities by calculating each city’s share of the projected increase in the number of jobs and households during that period. This is called the regional housing needs allocation (RHNA). Cities are not expected to actually produce this number of units; it is assumed that housing production will be carried out primarily by the private sector and will be affected by market conditions and other factors beyond a city’s control. However, the City must create conditions through zoning and land use policies that would allow the private sector to construct the targeted number of units. Cities can employ a variety of strategies to meet their RHNA housing production goals, as provided in Government Code Section 65583(c)(1)). 2014 – 2019 Regional Housing Needs Allocation The 2014 -2019 Regional Housing Needs Allocation (RHNA) for Atascadero is shown in Table V-29. The number of new units approved or constructed since the start of the projection period, starting January 2014, can reduce the Regional Housing Needs Allocation. Since January 2014, there have been 81 units constructed or approved in the City of Atascadero, including 30 units affordable to moderate income households. See Section B. for a discussion on units constructed or permitted during the previous cycle, including 24 very-low and low-income units in 2013 as part of the People’s Self-Help Housing (PSHH) project in Oak Grove. Public Review Draft Page 42 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element Table V-29 shows that the City has a remaining State allocation of 312 units, 160 for very-low and low-income housing, after accounting for the 81 units constructed or approved.. Table V-18.Table V-29. City Share of Regional Housing Need, 2014-2019 Very Low Low Moderate Above Moderate Total 2014 - 2019 RHNA 98 62 69 164 393 Units Constructed/Approved1 0 0 30 51 81 2014-2019 Subtotal RHNA 98 62 39 113 312 Notes: 1. Affordability determined by deed restriction or based on sales price of home Source: CA Dept. of Housing and Community Development, SLOCOG, 2013, City of Atascadero, 2014 2. Site Inventory and Analysis Local governments can employ a variety of development strategies to meet their RHNA housing production goals, as provided in Government Code Section 65583(c)(1)). In addition to identifying vacant or underutilized land resources, local governments can address a portion of their adequate sites requirement through the provision of second units. This section summarizes the vacant land inventory, underutilized sites, and second unit potential. Vacant Sites Table V-30 shows a summary of vacant land in Atascadero. A complete list is available in Appendix I. The table shows that there are 578 vacant parcels on approximately 1,857 acres suitable for residential development that have the capacity to accommodate approximately 1,353 homes at 80 percent of maximum buildout, or maximum allowed per a Specific Plan, for the multi-family parcels and 100 percent buildout for the single-family parcels where one house per lot is assumed. The 80 percent buildout factor is based on historical trends and the assumption that development standards combined with unique site features may not always lead to 100 percent buildout. There may also be political barriers to full development. There are adequate vacant sites to meet the City’s RHNA of 312, including the 160 very-low and low income units at minimum densities of 20 units per acre in the High Density Residential Multi- Family (HD-RMF) zone. See Table V-31 for a summary of vacant land by income category to satisfy the RHNA. Table V-19.Table V-30. Summary of Vacant Parcels, Atascadero 2014 Zone Land Use Acres # of Parce ls Density** Max du/ac 80% du/ac Infrastructure Residential Multi-Family – 24 HDR 34.11 17 24 units/acre 819 560 Yes Subtotal High Density 34.11 17 560 Residential Multi-Family – 10 MDR 8.16 5 10 units/acre 74 58 Yes Commercial Professional GC 7.56 9 16 units/acre 120 94 Downtown Commercial D 6.12 7 20 units/acre 122 95 Public Review Draft Page 43 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element Subtotal Medium Density 21.84 21 247 Residential Single-Family – LSF-X SFR-X 1.28 6 1 unit/parcel 6 6* Yes Residential Single-Family – LSF-Y SFR-Y 16.29 42 1 unit/parcel 42 42* Yes Residential Single-Family – RSF-X SFR-X 9.30 17 1 unit/parcel 21 21* Yes Residential Single-Family – RSF-Y SFR-Y 56.36 60 1 unit/parcel 60 60* Yes Residential Single-Family – RSF-Z SFR-Z 65.66 45 1 unit/parcel 45 45* Yes Residential Single-Family – RS RE 1,651.87 370 1 unit/parcel 1 372 372* Yes Subtotal Low Density 1,800.76 540 546 Yes Total 1,856.71 578 1,681 1,353 * Parcels in single family zones are not calculated at 80% as density is calculated per parcel rather than per acre. **Density for some parcels has been reduced due to slope. Source: City of Atascadero, 2014 Table V-20.Table V-31. RHNA Summary, 2014-2019 Very Low Low Moderate Above Moderate Total 2014 - 2019 Subtotal RHNA 98 62 39 113 312 Vacant Land Inventory 560 247 546 1,353 Remaining RHNA 0 0 0 0 Source: CA Dept. of Housing and Community Development, SLOCOG, 2013 3. Infrastructure Resources Infrastructure adds to the cost of new construction (e.g. major and local streets, water and sewer lines, and street lighting). Water and sewer service capacity is discussed below. Water Service Water service in the City is supplied by the Atascadero Mutual Water Company (AMWC). AMWC manages the water supply that consists of 17 active wells that pump from the Atascadero sub-basin of the Paso Robles Ground Water Basin and both riparian and appropriated Salinas River underflow. Maximum well production is 12.9 million gallons per day. AMWC service area encompasses hundreds of undeveloped parcels, AMWC’s future plans include a reliable water supply for an increased population. With approval of the Nacimiento Water Project, the AMWC has been allocated an additional 3,000 AFY, with a flow rate of 3.48 million gallons per day (mgd). The Nacimiento Water Project broke ground in 2007 and the 1 One parcel in this zone allowed 2 units Public Review Draft Page 44 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element construction of the infrastructures needed to deliver water to the Atascadero area is complete. AMWC began taking deliveries of water in the summer of 2012. The City analyzed the capacity of existing water resources and determined that gGiven the existing water supply and that which will result from the Nacimiento Water Project, the existing water supply is not a constraint to growth in the City and is available for all vacant zones within the City to accommodate the City’s RHNA. However, as a result of the Nacimiento Water Project connection fees, water rates have increased gradually 2 to help pay for the cost of the additional water source. The City recognizes that the region is currently going through a period of extreme drought in 2012 through the beginning of 2014. While the primary basin, the Paso Robles Ground Water Basin, is experiencing decline in many areas, the Atascadero Sub-basin is a hydro-geologically distinct sub-basin that is separated from the primary basin by the Rinconada Fault line and has not experienced the level of decline when compared to the Paso Robles Ground Water Basin Due to the increase in the cost of water service to ensure a reliable water supply, the City recognizes that the connection fees for water is critical for the development of affordable housing. Program 1.1-9 is proposed by the City to work with AMWC to explore possible options to ease the burden of water service fees for second units and other affordable housing projects. Wastewater Residential development in the City of Atascadero relies on both the City’s wastewater treatment facilities and on-site septic systems. Approximately 50% of Atascadero’s residents use the Collection and Treatment service. The City’s Wastewater Division maintains a 2.39 million gallon-per-day (mgd) wastewater treatment facility, over 40 miles of pipeline, and 13 wastewater-pumping stations. The treatment plant operates at approximately 60 percent capacity, which results in an average daily flow of 1.4 mgd. Minor upgrades have been approved for the treatment plant facility,3 but no expansions are planned for increasing the treatments capacity. Average daily flow for residential use is 100 gallons per capita per day. Based on the average household size of 2.02 persons, the daily flow is 0.0002 mgd per household. The average daily flow of the projected housing need (RHNA) is well within the capacity of the upgraded wastewater treatment system. 4. Administrative Resources El Camino Homeless Organization (ECHO) 2 Water rates are planned to increase by 8% (net) per year over four years beginning on January 1, 2008. There are two more years of 8% rate increases. After that, water rates will increase based on inflation or other typical increases in operation and maintenance costs (i.e. increase energy costs, treatment chemical costs, labor rates, etc.) (Source: pers. comm. John Neil, Atascadero Mutual Water Company General Manager, July 22, 2009.) 3 Headworks/Barscreen project approved during the 2009/2011 Budget (City of Atascadero, 2008). Public Review Draft Page 45 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element ECHO is a non-profit organization serving the homeless population of Northern San Luis Obispo County. The organization also assists those in need with obtaining permanent housing and developing skills necessary to lead a more stable life. ECHO recently purchased the former First Baptist Church and operates a permanent shelter in Atascadero at 6370 Atascadero Avenue, under the City’s Emergency Shelter Overlay Zone. The shelter can accommodate up to 50 persons per night. ECHO has commenced an upgrade of their facility to accommodate the additional persons including installation of new restrooms, accessibility upgrades, and other facility renovations as part of its acquisition of the former church. El Camino Homeless Organization, Atascadero Shelter. Community Action Partnership San Luis Obispo (CAPSLO) The EOC CAPSLO provides a wide variety of social services in San Luis Obispo County. Their divisions are Homeless Services, Head Start, Health and Prevention, Family Support, Adult Day Center, and Energy Conservation Services. CAPSLO operates the Maxine Lewis Memorial Homeless Shelter and the Prado Day Center in San Luis Obispo. They also operate Head Start and Migrant Head Start programs and two health centers in San Luis Obispo and Arroyo Grande. The Energy Conservation division provides weatherization and home repairs throughout the County. Habitat for Humanity Habitat for Humanity is an international non-profit organization dedicated to partnering with those in need of safe and affordable homes. Habitat for Humanity has constructed over 300,000 homes for families around the world. The San Luis Obispo County Habitat chapter has been active since 1997 and is involved in several development projects throughout the Central Coast. In 2008, Habitat for Humanity constructed four very low-income homes in Atascadero. Public Review Draft Page 46 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element Housing Authority of San Luis Obispo County (HASLO) The Housing Authority of San Luis Obispo County was created to provide housing assistance for the County's lower-income residents. The Housing Authority administers the Section 8 rental assistance program and manages public housing developments. The Housing Authority also administers the Tenant Based Rental Assistance (TBRA) Program for the San Luis Obispo Supportive Housing Consortium and established the San Luis Obispo Non-Profit Housing Corporation to take advantage of federal tax credits. The Non-Profit Housing Corporation has since helped with the development of the low-income Atascadero Senior Housing Project in 2008 and owns two housing complexes in Atascadero. Public Review Draft Page 47 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element People’s Self-Help Housing (PSHH) People's Self-Help Housing is a diverse, nonprofit organization committed to furthering opportunities for decent, safe, affordable housing and support services in San Luis Obispo, Santa Barbara, and Ventura Counties. PSHH has two primary programs – Self Help Homeownership Program and a Rental Housing Development and Construction Services Program. Additionally, PSHH also administers the Supportive Housing Program assisting residents with accessing community services and provides home ownership counseling. Since its inception in the 1960s, PSHH has developed more than 1,100 homes and 1,400 rental units and assisted in the rehabilitation and repair of more than 3,000 housing units. PSHH has constructed 15 affordable home-ownership properties and currently owns and operates Atascadero Gardens, a 17-unit affordable rental complex. The purchase of this building in 1999 prevented a pending conversion to market rate units and tenant displacement. PSHH also assisted in the development of 15 homes in 1975. Since 2012, PSHH has been developing a tract of 24 single-family residential homes in El Camino Oaks subdivision (Oakgrove Phase II) that fell into foreclosure. Since 2013, PSHH has purchased an 11 unit subdivision tract on Atascadero Avenue from a bankruptcy auction and is working with City Staff to commence construction for additional very-low and low-income housing units. It is estimated construction for the additional 11 affordable single-family residential units will begin in late 2014/early 2015. Transitional Food and Shelter Transitional Food and Shelter is a charitable organization operating throughout San Luis Obispo County. The organization has three primary programs, shelter, food, and family-to- family assistance. The organization provides temporary, emergency shelter in motels and apartments in the North County, for homeless persons who are fragile, sick, and/or disabled. The program provides relief for those who cannot be accommodated in more traditional Public Review Draft Page 48 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element homeless shelters. The organization also operates “The People’s” kitchen of Paso Robles, serving food nightly to homeless and/or hungry. 5. Financial Resources Availability of Financing The availability of financing affects the ability to purchase or improve homes. In the Atascadero area 4, 2,851 applications for loans were received in 2012, of which 2,324 were conventional loans. Of the 2,324 conventional loan applications, 1,906 were refinancing, 379 were for home purchase, and 39 were for home improvements. Of the 418 conventional loan applications for home purchase or repair, only 2 percent were denied, 13 percent were withdrawn or not accepted by applicant, and 53 percent were approved and accepted. There were 296 applications for government assisted home purchase or improvement loans (VA, FHA, FSA/RHS) in 2012. This is significantly higher than the number of applicants in 2007, 7 total. Of these, 176, or 60 percent of government assisted loans were approved and accepted by the applicant. Most (60 percent) applicants for government assisted loans had an annual income of less than the median income of $75,400 in 2012. Conversely, over 62 percent of conventional loan applicants earned greater than the County median income. However, 46 percent of all originated loans were awarded and accepted by applicants with less than median household income, demonstrating equal availability of financing for upper and lower-income households and there are no mortgage deficient segments of the community. Local Housing Funds Inclusionary Housing In-Lieu Fee Funds The City’s inclusionary housing program offers the option of paying a fee in lieu of building affordable housing for projects of 10 units or less. Fees deposited into the account may be used in the acquisition, construction, or rehabilitation of affordable housing. Following the March 2012 dedication of $100,000 to the North County Connection and $255,000 to El Camino Homeless Organization to support property acquisition for emergency, transitional, and affordable housing services, the Fund has a remaining balance of approximately $82,000. San Luis Obispo County Housing Trust Fund Another source of local housing funding is through the San Luis Obispo County Housing Trust Fund (SLOCHTF), which is a private nonprofit corporation created to increase the supply of affordable housing in San Luis Obispo County for very low, low, and moderate income households. SLOCHTF provides financing and technical assistance to help private developers, nonprofit corporations and government agencies produce and preserve homes that working families, seniors on fixed incomes and persons with disabilities can afford to rent or buy. More information on SLOCHTF can be found at www.slochtf.org. 4 Home Mortgage Disclosure Act data is based off census tracts. The census tracts that cover the City of Atascadero also encompass the unincorporated area surrounding the City. Public Review Draft Page 49 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element 5.6. Other Resources Many programs within the State of California exist to provide financial assistance to the City and to individual developers for the development, preservation, and rehabilitation of residential development; primarily affordable units. The Department of Housing and Community Development identifies and provides detailed information on the grants and loans available for affordable housing, which include: Affordable Housing Innovation Fund The Affordable Housing Innovation Fund provides funding for pilot programs to demonstrate innovative, cost-saving approaches to creating or preserving affordable housing. Legislation in 2007 (SB 586, Chapter 652) allocated these funds to four new activities and to the revival of the Local Housing Trust Fund program originally created by Proposition 46. Key programs are: o Golden State Acquisition Fund (GSAF) Affordable Housing Innovation Program: This program provides quick acquisition financing for the development or preservation of workforce housing. Provides loans for developers through a nonprofit fund manager. http://www.hcd.ca.gov/fa/ahif/ahip-l.html o Local Housing Trust Fund Program: Matching grants (dollar-for-dollar) to local housing trust funds dedicated to the creation or preservation of affordable housing that are funded on an ongoing basis from private contributions or public sources that are not otherwise restricted in use for housing programs. http://www.hcd.ca.gov/fa/ahif/lhtf.html CalHome Program: Provides grants to local agencies and nonprofit developers to assist very- low income homeowners through deferred payment loans as well as direct, forgivable loans to assist development projects. www.hcd.ca.gov/fa/calhome Emergency Solutions Grant (ESG): Provides grants to fund projects that serve homeless individuals and families with supportive services, emergency shelter/transitional housing, assisting persons at risk of becoming homeless with homelessness prevention assistance, and providing permanent housing to the homeless population. http://www.hcd.ca.gov/fa/esg/index.html Enterprise Zone Program: Provides incentives such as sales tax credits and operation deductions for business investment. www.hcd.ca.gov/fa/cdbg/ez/#EZ Governor’s Homeless Initiative: Provides loans and grants for the development of permanent supportive housing for chronically homeless residents who suffer from severe mental illness. www.hcd.ca.gov/fa/ghi Public Review Draft Page 50 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element HOME Investment Partnerships Program: Provides cities, counties, and nonprofit organizations with grants and low-interest loans to create and retain affordable housing. http://www.hcd.ca.gov/fa/home/ Infill Infrastructure Grant Program: Provides grants to assist in the creation and rehabilitation of infrastructure that supports higher-density affordable and mixed-income housing in places designated for infill. http://www.hcd.ca.gov/fa/iig/ Mobilehome Park Resident Ownership Program: Provides loans to finance the preservation of affordable mobilehome parks by conversion to ownership or control by resident organizations, nonprofit housing sponsors, or local public agencies. http://www.hcd.ca.gov/fa/mprop/ Multifamily Housing Program: Provide deferred payment loans to fund the construction, rehabilitation, and preservation of permanent and transitional rental units for supportive housing. This includes housing for low-income residents with disabilities, or those who are at risk of homelessness. www.hcd.ca.gov/fa/mhp Office of Migrant Services: Provides grants to local government agencies that contract with HCD to operate OMS centers in California. OMS centers provide safe and affordable seasonal rental housing and support services for migrant farmworker families. www.hcd.ca.gov/fa/oms Predevelopment Loan Program: Provides short-term loans for financing low-income housing projects. www.hcd.ca.gov/fa/pdlp State CDBG Program Economic Development Allocation: Provides grants for planning and technical assistance and the creation or maintenance of jobs for rural low-income workers. http://www.hcd.ca.gov/fa/cdbg/EconDevelopment.html State CDBG Program Community Development Allocation: Provides grants to fund housing, public improvement, community facilities, public services, and planning and technical assistance that benefit lower-income residents in rural communities. http://www.hcd.ca.gov/fa/cdbg/CommunityDevelopment.html Public Review Draft Page 51 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element This Page Intentionally Left Blank Public Review Draft Page 52 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element G. Constraints on Housing Production Government policies and regulations impact the price and availability of housing and, in particular, the provision of affordable housing. Constraints include residential development standards, fees, and permitting procedures. Providing infrastructure and services also increases the cost of producing housing. This Chapter addresses potential governmental and nongovernmental constraints and focuses on mitigation options available to the City. 1. Governmental Constraints Although local governments have little influence on such market factors as interest rates and availability of funding for development, their policies and regulations can affect both the amount of residential development that occurs and the affordability of housing. Since governmental actions can constrain development and affordability of housing, State law requires the Housing Element to “address and, where appropriate and legally possible, remove governmental constraints to the maintenance, improvement, and development of housing.” Land Use Controls The City’s primary policies and regulations that affect residential development and housing affordability include: Title 9 (the City’s Planning and Zoning Regulations), the General Plan, the Atascadero Downtown Revitalization Plan, the Appearance Review Manual, development processing procedures and fees, on and off-site improvement requirements, and building codes. In addition to a review of these policies and regulations, an analysis of governmental constraints on housing production for persons with disabilities is included in this Section. Planning and Zoning Regulations Title 9, the City’s Planning and Zoning Regulations, allows residential development in the agriculture zone, 4 residential zones, 2 downtown zones, 4 commercial zones, 2 industrial zones, and 3 recreation and public zones. The maximum residential density allowed is 24 units per acre. Title 9 does not include specific development standards for the Rural Residential zone that is identified on the Zoning Map. Program 1.1-6 has been proposed to codify the Rural Residential zone into Title 9 and include zoning standards that distinguish it from the Residential Suburban zone. Agriculture (A) Zone. This zone is established to protect, preserve, and encourage agriculture on suitable land. Agriculture related residential uses are permitted including single-family dwellings, primary family housing, and farm labor quarters. The A zone corresponds to the Agriculture (AG) land use designation of the General Plan. Public Review Draft Page 53 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element Rural Residential (RR) Zone. This zone is established for large lot single-family residential uses. The General Plan details a maximum allowable density of 0.4 units per acre. The RR zone corresponds to the Rural Residential (RR), Rural Estate (RE), Suburban Estate (SE), and Agriculture (AG) land use designations of the General Plan. Residential Suburban (RS) Zone. This zone is established for large lot single-family residential uses. Second units are permitted by right in the RS zone, subject to specific development standards identified in Chapter 5 of Title 9. The maximum allowable density is 0.4 units per acre. The RS zone corresponds to the Rural Residential (RR), Rural Estate (RE), Suburban Estate (SE), and Agriculture (AG) land use designations of the General Plan. Residential Single Family (RSF) Zone. This zone is established to provide for single-family residential areas within the urban service line. Second units are permitted by right in the RSF zone, subject to specific development standards identified in Chapter 5 of Title 9. The RSF is divided into 3 categories based on minimum lot sizes, RSF-X, RSF-Y, RSF-Z; and density ranges from 0.5 - 2.0 units per acre. Density may be increased to 4 units per acre with a Planned Development in the RSF-X zone. The RSF zone corresponds to the Single-Family Residential (SFR) land use designation of the General Plan, which includes the sub-land use designations SFR-Z, SFR-Y, SFR-X. Limited Single Family (LSF) Zone. This zone is established for single-family residential where raising of farm animals is not allowed. Second units are permitted by right in the LSF zone, subject to specific development standards identified in Chapter 5 of Title 9. The LSF is divided into 3 categories based on the minimum lot size, LSF-X, LSF-Y, LSF-Z; and density ranges from 0.5 - 2.0 units per acre. The LSF zone corresponds to the Single-Family Residential (SFR) land use designation of the General Plan, which includes the sub-land use designations SFR-Z, SFR- Y, SFR-X. Residential Multiple Family (RMF) Zone. This zone is established for apartment, condominium, and townhouse development. The maximum allowable density for areas designated Low Density Multiple Family Residential (RMF-10) is 10 units per acre; for areas designated High Density Multiple Family Residential (RMF-1620) is 16 24 units per acre; and for hillside areas the density ranges from 1 - 20 units per acre depending on average slope (density exceptions exist for group quarters and nursing facilities). The RMF zone corresponds to the Medium-Density Residential (MDR) and High-Density Residential (HDR) land use designations of the General Plan. Downtown Commercial (DC) Zoning District. This zone is established to enhance the economic viability and pedestrian-oriented character of downtown. Residential uses are permitted on upper floors in the DC zoning district. Home occupations and live/work projects are also encouraged in the DC zoning district. The maximum allowable density is 20 units per acre. The DC zone corresponds to the Downtown (D) land use designation of the General Plan. Downtown Office (DO) Zoning District. This zone is established for professional and other office uses close to the services provided in the DC zoning district. Residential uses are permitted on upper floors in the DO zoning district. The maximum allowable density is 20 Public Review Draft Page 54 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element units per acre. The DO zoning district corresponds to the Downtown (D) land use designation of the General Plan. Commercial Professional (CP) Zone. This zone is established for limited retail shopping and personal service facilities. It allows mixed-use with residential up to 24 units per acre with a conditional use permit. Caretaker residences are also permitted conditionally. The CP zone corresponds to the General Commercial (GC) and Mixed Use (MU) land use designations of the General Plan. Commercial Retail (CR) Zone. This zone is established for a wide range of commercial uses to accommodate retail and service needs; however, it does allow residential care facilities for the elderly (RCFE) and conditionally permit caretaker residences, mixed-use with residential up to 24 units per acre, and single room occupancy. The CR zone corresponds to the General Commercial (GC) and Mixed Use (MU) land use designations of the General Plan. Commercial Service (CS) Zone. This zone is established for light manufacturing and large lot service commercial, however it does conditionally permit caretaker residences or multifamily dwellings within an existing structure of historical significance. The CS zone corresponds to the Service Commercial (SC) land use designation of the General Plan. Commercial Tourism (CT) Zone. This zone is established for limited commercial uses for Highway 101 travelers; however, it does conditionally permit caretaker residences. The CT zone corresponds to the General Commercial (GC) land use designation of the General Plan. Industrial Park (IP) Zone. This zone is established for light manufacture and large lot service commercial; however, it does conditionally permit caretaker residences. The IP zone corresponds to the Industrial (IND) land use designation of the General Plan. Industrial (I) Zone. This zone is established for heavy manufacture and industrial uses; however, it does conditionally permit caretaker residences. The I zone corresponds to the Industrial (IND) land use designation of the General Plan. Recreation (L) Zone. This zone provides suitable locations for recreational facilities; however, it does conditionally permit caretaker residences. The L zone corresponds to the RR, RE, SE, SFR, MDR, HDR, Public Recreation (REC), Public Facilities (PUB), and Open Space (OS) land use designation of the General Plan. Special Recreation (LS) Zone. This zone provides suitable locations for recreational facilities on land in private ownership. This zone also provides for residential uses where intensive recreational activity may not be appropriate. The maximum allowable density for residential is 0.7 unit per acre (sewer not available) or 1 unit per acre (sewer is present). Additionally, the LS zone allows caretaker residence with a conditional use permit. The LS zone corresponds to the Commercial Recreational (CREC) land use designation of the General Plan. Public (P) Zone. This zone provides suitable locations for public and quasi-public facilities, however, it does conditionally permit single family, residential care, and caretaker residences. The maximum allowable density for residential is 0.4 unit per acre. The P zone corresponds to Public Review Draft Page 55 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element the RR, RE, SE, SFR, MDR, HDR, CREC, REC, PUB, and OS land use designation of the General Plan. Planned Development (PD) Overlays. The City has established 30 overlays (PD 1 - 12 and 14 - 31) to allow for special use standards that differ from those established by the underlying zone. The maximum allowable density is 24 units per acre. Planned Development Overlays are typically used to allow for individual lot ownership units in multi-family zones and clustered residential development in rural areas to achieve minimal environmental impacts and reduced infrastructure costs. Emergency Shelter (ES) Overlay. The City established an emergency shelter overlay zone in 2013 which allows emergency shelters by right on specific sites, subject to operational and development standards. In 2013 one ES site was designated at 6370 Atascadero Avenue for the El Camino Homeless Organization (ECHO) shelter. Table V-32 summarizes the General Plan land use designations and the zoning districts that either allow by right or conditionally permit residential development. In 2013, the City amended the zoning ordinance to allow residential densities up to 24 units per acre in the RMF- 20 Zone and up to 20 units per acre in the DC and DO zones. Table V-21.Table V-32. General Plan Land Use Designations and Zoning District Comparison General Plan Land Use Designation Density Corresponding Zoning Districts RR/RE/SE 0.1 - 0.4 unit/acre gross1 RR, RS, P, L SFR-Z 1.0 unit/acre gross1 RSF-Z, LSF-Z, P, L SFR-Y 2.0 unit/acre gross RSF-Y, LSF-Y, P, L SFR-X 4.0 unit/acre net2 RSF-X, LSF-X, P, L MDR 10 unit/acre net RMF-10, P, L HDR 16 24 unit/acre net RMF-16 20 P, L GC 16 unit/acre net CP, CR, CT SC (0.4 FAR) CS D 16 20 unit/acre net DC, DO MU 16 24 unit/acre net CR, CP: (MU/PD overlay) CREC 10 unit/acre net LS, P IND (0.4 FAR) I, IP AG 0.1 - 0.4 unit/acre gross1 RR, RS, A REC -- L, P PUB -- L, P Notes: 1. Density is adjusted by performance standards in this land use designation. The maximum density may be lower based on the application of performance standards. 2. The maximum density sets a limit to the number of units that may be developed in each land use designation. The General Plan also sets minimum lots size areas that are allowed through the subdivision process consistent with the "Elbow Room" principle. The minimum lot sizes are more restrictive than the maximum densities in order to reflect historic small lot development densities and to allow for new planned development projects that incorporate smaller lot sizes with innovative design concepts. Public Review Draft Page 56 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element Table V-33 summarizes the housing types permitted by zone. Each use is designated by a letter denoting whether the use is permitted by right (P) or conditionally permitted (CUP). Table V-22.Table V-33. Zoning District’s Permitted Land Uses in 2014A Land Uses A RR RS RSF LSF RMF DC DO CP CR CS CT IP I L LS P Single-family dwelling P P P P P P P2 P2 -- -- -- -- -- -- -- P CUP Multiple family dwelling -- -- -- -- -- P2 P2 P2 CU P7 CU P7 CU P7 -- -- -- -- -- -- Live/work projects -- -- -- -- -- -- P3/ CU P4 -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- Secondary residential units -- P P P P -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- Residential accessory uses P P P P P P -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- P -- Temporary dwelling P P P P P P -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- P -- Mobilehome dwelling P P P P P -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- Mobilehome developments -- CU P CU P CU P CU P CU P -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- Primary family housing P -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- Farm labor quarters P -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- Home occupations P P P P P P P P -- -- -- -- -- -- -- P -- Caretaker residence C U P CU P CU P CU P CU P -- -- -- CU P CU P CU P C U P C U P C U P C U P C U P CUP Residential care, ≤ 6 clients -- P P P P P -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- CUP Residential care, > 6 clients -- CU P CU P CU P CU P P -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- CUP Residential Care for the Elderly -- -- -- -- -- CU P -- -- -- P P -- -- -- -- -- -- Organizational houses -- CU P CU P CU P CU P CU P -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- Medical extended care5, ≤ 6 clients -- -- --P P P CU P -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- CUP Medical extended care5, > 6 clients -- -- -- CU P CU P CU P CU P -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- CUP- - Age restricted housing -- -- -- -- -- -- CU P6 -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- Public Review Draft Page 57 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element Table V-22.Table V-33. Zoning District’s Permitted Land Uses in 2014A Land Uses A RR RS RSF LSF RMF DC DO CP CR CS CT IP I L LS P Notes: A. Not regulatory. For reference only, refer to Zoning Ordinance for the latest official zoning designations. Zoning Ordinance may be amended independently of this table. 1. RSF-Y only, see Section 9.6106 2. RMF Zone – CUP required for projects over 12 units, excluding RMF-20 properties identified in Appendix I. RMF-20 properties identified in Appendix I are allowed by right, not subject to a CUP or specific plan. DC and DO Zones - Residential uses allowed only on second and third floor, except sites north of Olmeda Avenue. If project is required to provide a unit in compliance with Americans with Disabilities Act, the handicapped accessible unit may be located on a first floor. A first floor unit shall be located in a non-storefront location within a tenant space. 3. Permitted use if the residential quarters are located on the second or third floors. 4. Conditional Use Permit required if the residential quarters are located on the first floor. 5. A skilled nursing facility (also referred to as medical extended care) is a board and care home for residents, where no medical care is provided, and is subject to all applicable standards for multiple family dwellings. 6. Use allowed only on sites north of Olmeda Avenue. 7. When located on second floor or above As shown in Table V-33, zoning regulations are not a constraint to development of multi-family or affordable housing. The Conditional Use Permit (CUP) requirement for mutli-family projects greater than 12 units does not apply to multi-family projects in the RMF-20 zone under single property ownership or when used as income property. CUP requirements in the RFM-20 zone apply for subdivisions and planned development. Program 1.1.20 has been included to amend the zoning ordinance to require a CUP only for multi-family housing projects greater than 50 units, to ensure minimum densities are achievable in the RFM-20 zone. Table V-34 provides development standards for the residential zones and Table V-35 provides the development standards in the Downtown Zones. Minimum parcel size and setback requirements in Atascadero are not unusually strict and are not considered a constraint to the development of affordable housing. The height limit in residential zones has proven not to impede development or discourage density. The Hidden Oaks Apartments and Southside Villas condominium projects, 90 and 86 units, respectively, achieved densities over 20 units per acre while meeting the 30 foot, two story height restriction. The Emerald Ridge condominium development, approved in 2004, also met the height requirement while achieving a density of 18 units per acre with 132 units on 7.3 acres. Program 1.18 proposes to amend the Zoning Ordinance to allow a waiver of the two-story height limit in the RMF Zone through the Minor Use Permit process. Its process is similar to that of a major CUP but the fee of a MUP is substantially decreased from a CUP ($1,090 and $3,910, respectively)5. Both a MUP and a CUP go through the Design Review Committee then the Planning Commission for approval. The MUP process normally takes between two to six months and allows for review of the building height by the City’s Fire Department for health, safety, and welfare reasons. A typical major CUP may take six months up to one year. With the reduction of fees and expedited processing, the MUP allows for the proper review by departments. 5 A. Not regulatory. For reference only. Planning and development fees display current rates at the time of publication. Fees are subject to change at the discretion of the City Council. Public Review Draft Page 58 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element Table V-23.Table V-34. Residential Zones Development StandardsA Development Standard Zone RS RSF LSF RMF X Y Z X Y Z Min lot size (acres)1,2 2.5 - 10 0.5 1 1.5 -2.5 0.5 1 1.5 - 2.5 .53 Max Height (feet) 30 ft. max. 30 ft. (2 stories max.) Setbacks4 (feet) Front 25 ft. min Exceptions for shallow lots, flag lots, sloping lots, and variable block. 15 ft Side 5 ft. min Exceptions for corner lots, key lots, small corner lots, accessory buildings, common wall development5, zero lot line development6, access easements. Rear Principle residential building - 10 ft. min Accessory building - 3 ft. min if under 12 ft in height and under 120 sf Interior Principle residential buildings - 10 ft Accessory building - 10 ft.(some code exceptions apply) Notes: A. Not regulatory. For reference only, refer to Zoning Ordinance for the latest official development standards. Zoning Ordinance may be amended independently of this table. 1. Depending upon conformance with performance standards set in each zone. 2. Smaller lot sizes allowed with a Planned Development. 3. Smaller lot sizes allowed for PD projects, including condominiums and mobile home developments, provided that the overall density within the project conforms with Section 9-3.17 (RMF Zone - Density). 4. Except for 2nd story dwellings over commercial and industrial uses. 5. Two dwelling units, and/or their accessory garages constructed on adjoining lots with minimum building code separation. 6. A group of dwelling units on adjoining lots may be established so that all units about 1 side property line. . Table V-24.Table V-35. Downtown Zones Development StandardsA DC DO Min lot size No minimum Density 20 du/acre 20 du/acre Setbacks Minimum and maximum setbacks required. See Section 9-4.103 for setback requirement, allowed projections into setbacks, and exceptions to setbacks. Front None allowed, except for building insets designed to accommodate outdoor eating and seating areas, and except for East and West Mall between El Camino Real and Palma Avenue, where a minimum of twenty (20) feet is required. As required by Section 9-4.106 when adjacent to a residential zone, none required otherwise. Sides (each) None required Rear None required Creek 20 ft. Height limit 45 ft. not to exceed 3 stories; 18 ft. on the west side of El Camino Real1 25 ft. Public Review Draft Page 59 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element Off-street parking See Section 9-4.114 for residential uses and for development east of Atascadero Creek. All other uses - none required. As required by Sections 9-4.114 et seq. Notes: A. Not regulatory. For reference only, refer to Zoning Ordinance for the latest official development standards. Zoning Ordinance may be amended independently of this table. 1. Between Atascadero Creek and lot line common to Lots 19 and 20, Block H-B, Atascadero Colony Map. Historical Preservation To promote the conservation, preservation, protection, and enhancement of Atascadero’s historical and architecturally significant structures, the City adopted a Historic Site Overlay (HS) zone. The standards are intended to protect historic structures and sites by requiring new uses and alterations to existing uses to be designed with consideration for preserving and protecting the historic resource. Given the quality of Atascadero’s historical and architecturally significant structures, and the contribution of these structures to the image and quality of life in Atascadero, the historic preservation policies and regulations are reasonable and appropriate and do not pose an unreasonable constraint to residential development in the City of Atascadero. Only one site identified in the vacant land inventory (Appendix I) contains a designated colony house, but is not subject to the HS overlay. No other sites identified in the vacant land inventory are subject to the HS overlay. Sensitive Resources The City adopted a Sensitive Resource Overlay (SR) zone to protect areas with special environmental resources and to protect areas containing unique or endangered vegetation or habitat. The purpose of these standards is to require that proposed uses be designed with consideration of the identified sensitive resources, and the need for their protection. Development that falls within a SR overlay zone does require additional measures to ensure environmental protection, which can add to the cost of development. It is in the best interest of the community, and also is mandated by State and Federal laws to protect sensitive environmental resources. The City’s regulations do not pose an unreasonable constraint to residential development in the City. No sites identified in the vacant land inventory are subject to the SR overlay. Mobile and Manufactured Homes State law requires that mobile and manufactured homes be allowed in residential zones. These units cannot be regulated by any planning fees or review processes not applicable to conventional single-family dwellings. However, the architectural design of manufactured or mobilehomes can be regulated by the City. Under the City’s zoning regulations mobilehome developments are permitted with approval of a Conditional Use Permit in all residential zones. Individual mobilehome dwellings are permitted by right in all single-family residential zones (RS, RSF, LSF) and in the Agriculture zone. The City’s zoning regulations address manufactured homes in section 9-6.142 of the Atascadero Municipal Code. In order be in compliance with State law, the City should clarify that the terms “mobilehome” and “manufactured home” are essentially the same and should be Public Review Draft Page 60 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element considered a single-family dwelling and permitted in all zones that allow single-family housing. Manufactured housing can be subject to design review. Program 1.1-5 3 is recommended to encourage a variety housing options within the City. Mixed-Use Development Atascadero encourages mixed-use development in the downtown districts (DC and DO). As stated in Title 9: The downtown zoning districts are intended to develop an attractive, pedestrian-oriented, and economically successful downtown area by providing for a mixture of commercial, office, and residential land uses… The development of mixed-use projects provides more housing opportunities by permitting residential uses on the upper floors. Mixed-use development also enhances economic viability, pedestrian-oriented character, and the overall downtown environment. Table V-35 provides the development standards for mixed-use developments in the downtown area. In addition, mixed- use is allowed in all areas with a General Commercial land use designation. In 2013, the City amended the Zoning Ordinance to allow vertical mixed-use with a Conditional Use Permit in General Commercial land use designations and horizontal mixed-use subject to a zone change (PD overlay) and General Plan Amendment. This is a reduction in previous requirements for horizontal or vertical mixed-use. Secondary Residential Units To encourage establishment of second units, State law requires cities to either adopt an ordinance authorizing second units in residentially zoned areas, or, where no ordinance has been adopted, to allow second units if they meet standards set out in the State law. State law requires ministerial consideration of second unit applications in zones where single-family dwellings are permitted. Local governments are precluded from totally prohibiting second units in residentially zoned areas unless they make specific findings (Government Code § 65852.2). Second units can be an important source of affordable housing since they are smaller than primary units and they do not have direct land costs. Supporting the development of second units expands housing opportunities for very low-, low-, and moderate-income households by increasing the number of rental units available within existing neighborhoods. Second units are intended to provide livable housing at lower cost while providing greater security, companionship, and family support for the occupants. Second units, or secondary residential units, are defined within the Atascadero zoning regulations as residential occupancy constructions (R) with a kitchen and full bathroom that is accessory to the primary unit and intended for permanent occupancy by a second household. Second residential units provide quarters for independent living areas, sleeping, cooking, and sanitation facilities. Second residential units are permitted by right in the single-family residential zones (RS, RSF, LSF). Second units are also allowed in single family planned development overlay districts only when consistent with an approved Master Plan of Public Review Draft Page 61 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element Development. Second units are subject to all development standards of the underlying zoning district and/or planned development overlay districts, with a few minor exceptions: o Floor Area. The total floor area shall not exceed 1,200 square feet. o Private Open Space Requirement. A second unit shall have a minimum private open space area of 250 square feet. No portion of an open space area shall have a dimension of less than 10 feet in width. o Attached Second Units. If the second unit is attached to the primary dwelling, each shall be served by separate outside entrances. o Second units are permitted on lots greater than 1 gross acre in size if on a private septic system or connected to City sewer. o Second units are permitted on lots less than 1 gross acre in size if connected to City sewer only. Second units, whether attached or detached, are considered as single-family units for purposes of determining impact fees. This has been identified as a potential constraint to development of second units. Programs 1.1-12 considers reduction of impact fees for second units as part of an AB1600 study and 6.1-8 has been introduced to index fees based on size of the unit to encourage affordability by design. Parking requirements for second residential units are shown in Table V-36. For a second unit to be approved, it must be served by a public water system and the City sanitary sewer system or an engineered septic system (depending on lot size), and allow for the installation of separate utility meters. Atascadero Mutual Water Company (AMWC) establishes the water connection fees and these have been identified as a constraint to the development of second residential units due to the disproportion of fees to actual development costs.6 Program 1.1.12 is recommended to establish a program that would address second unit fees and create an incentive program to encourage the development of second units. (See Section F – Housing Resources (Infrastructure Resources - Water Service) for additional information on water service from AMWC.) Group Homes and Residential Care Facilities The Lanterman Development Disabilities Services Act declares that persons with mental or and physical disabilities are entitled to live in normal residential surroundings. A State-authorized, certified, or licensed family care home, foster home, or group home serving six or fewer disabled persons or dependent and neglected children on a 24-hour-a-day basis is considered a residential use that is permitted in all residential zones. No local agency can impose stricter zoning or building and safety standards or require variances on these homes than those required for homes in the same zone. 6 City of Atascadero, Planning Commission/City Council meeting, June 16, 2009. Public Review Draft Page 62 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element The City’s Planning and Zoning Regulations accommodate housing for group living situations. Residential care facilities serving six or fewer residents (small) are permitted by right in all residential zones. Residential care facilities serving more than six residents (large) are permitted by right in the RMF zone and conditionally permitted in the RS, RSF, and LSF zones. Program 4.1.3 is recommended to allow large residential care facilities by right in additional zones. See the section below Housing for People with Disabilities, for additional discussion on housing for special needs. Emergency Shelters and Transitional Housing State legislation SB 2 requires jurisdictions to permit emergency shelters without a Conditional Use Permit (CUP) or other discretionary permits, and transitional housing and supportive housing must be considered residential uses and must only be subject to the same restrictions that apply to the same housing types in the same zone. Transitional and supportive housing are considered single family or multi-family uses under Title 9. Transitional and supportive housing are permitted in all residential zones and thus held to the same development standards as other residential uses of the same type in the same zone. Additionally, the City has an Emergency Shelter (ES) Overlay Zone, which allows emergency shelters on a specific site subject to the development and operational standards outlined in the zoning ordinance. The ES Overlay Zone was applied to the property where El Camino Homeless Organization (ECHO) runs and operates a homeless shelter with a maximum of 50 occupants. The ECHO shelter does not typically operate at capacity. The As a shelter was not a permitted use in the base zone, the Overlay protects the operation and establishes operational guidelines. The site of ECHO shelter has the capacity to expand to accommodate an additional 60 beds, for a total capacity of 110 beds at the single ES overlay site. With the existing site not operating at capacity, with the ability to expand up to 110 beds, the shelter meets the City’s need for emergency shelters. Program 4.1-4 is proposed to identify additional sites for emergency shelters, should a need arise for these facilities. Building Codes And Site Improvements Building codes and site improvements can also increase the cost of developing housing, particularly affordable rental housing. The following examines the City’s building codes and site improvement standards. Building Codes and Enforcement Atascadero implements the 2013 edition of the California Building Code and other model construction codes, with amendments adopted by the California Building Standards Commission. These model codes establish standards and require inspections at various stages of construction to ensure code compliance and minimum health and safety standards. Although these standards and the time required for inspections increase housing production costs and Public Review Draft Page 63 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element may impact the viability of rehabilitation of older properties, the codes are mandated for all jurisdictions in California. The City has also adopted an ordinance requiring fire sprinklers in all newly constructed residential units and substantially remodeled units, adding to the cost of construction. The ordinance was instated for the protection of Atascadero residents because most residential sites in Atascadero are in a high or very high fire hazard severity zone. With the very hot summers in Atascadero and abundance of dry brush and native vegetation located in the residential zones, there is a high potential for fire. The installation of fire sprinklers adds approximately $2 per square foot to the cost of construction of single-family homes. The additional cost is likely to be passed along to the homebuyer as part of the final cost of the home or to renters in the form of a higher monthly rental price. The added cost does not pose a significant constraint to the construction of new units and second units. Aside from this ordinance, the City has not adopted local amendments to the model codes that increase housing costs (the Plumbing Code has been amended to address large-lot development with septic systems). Building inspectors are responsible for ensuring that proposed projects meet State and local codes. Site Improvements The City of Atascadero, along with other agencies, requires the installation of certain on- and off-site improvements to ensure the safety and livability of residential neighborhoods. On-site improvements typically include private or shared driveways, parking areas, drainage, sections of underground pipe, swales, ponding areas, and amenities such as landscaping, fencing, open space, and park facilities. Off-site improvements typically include:  Sections of roadway, medians, bridges, sidewalks, and bicycle lanes;  Sewage collection and treatment;  Water systems, including lines, storage tanks, and treatment plants (Atascadero Municipal Water Company); and  Public facilities for fire, school, and recreation. The costs of on- and off-site improvements, which average about $35.00 per square foot for single family residential construction and $28.00 per square foot for multi-family residential construction are usually passed along to the homebuyer as part of the final cost of the home. The on- and off-site improvement standards imposed by the City are typical for most communities and do not pose unusual constraints for housing development. Parking Standards The City’s parking requirements are based upon unit type and size. As shown in Table V-3836, parking requirements are typically two spaces per single-family residential unit. Multi-family residential units generally average 2.25 spaces per unit after accounting for guest parking. The City has several exceptions for parking. Bicycle parking may substitute parking spaces in lots with 20 or more spaces. A bicycle rack providing for at least five bicycles at a ratio of one Public Review Draft Page 64 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element bicycle rack for each 20 spaces is allowed. For compact car spaces, lots with 20 or more spaces may substitute compact car spaces for up to 20 percent of the total number of spaces. For motorcycle parking, lots with 20 or more spaces may replace regular spaces with motorcycle spaces at a ratio of one motorcycle space for each 20 spaces. Table V-25.Table V-36. Parking Requirements A Land Use Parking requirement Single-family dwellings (including mobilehomes) 2 spaces per du, except 1/du on lots < 4,000 s.f. in area Second unit 1 covered space for each 1 bedroom unit 2 covered or uncovered for 2 or more bedrooms Multifamily dwellings (including condominiums and attached ownership dwellings) 1 bedroom unit: 1.5 spaces 2 bedroom unit: 2 spaces, each add. bedroom: 0.5 space Guest parking: 1 space per 5 units, or fraction thereof Skilled nursing facility 1 space per 4 beds Group quarters 1 space per bedroom, plus 1 per eight beds Single room occupancy 1 space per 4 units and 1 space per employee, plus 0.5 space per 2 units Notes: A. Not regulatory. For reference only, refer to Zoning Ordinance for the latest official development standards. Zoning Ordinance may be amended independently of this table. In certain situations, parking requirements may be reduced or waived. This includes some alternative parking arrangement options: o Tandem Parking. Tandem parking permitted for single-family dwellings and individual mobilehomes upon meeting appropriate performance criteria. o Parking Districts. Parking requirements may be modified within a parking district where adequate parking is provided within the limits of the district and the parking requirements of a new use are accommodated by the parking district. o Shared Peak-Hour Parking. Where two or more uses have distinct and differing peak traffic usage periods the required number of parking spaces may be reduced through conditional use permit approval. o On-Street Parking Adjustment. In the case that a new driveway eliminates on-street parking spaces, the requirement for off-street spaces may be adjusted. o Planning Commission Modification. The required parking standards may be modified through Conditional Use Permit approval by the Planning Commission. Public Review Draft Page 65 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element Permit Processing And Fees Development Fees The City charges various fees and assessments to cover the costs of processing permits and providing services. Impacts fees are also charged to cover the cost or providing municipal services or mitigating project impacts. These fees are summarized in Table V-37. The total amount of fees varies from project to project based on type, existing infrastructure, and the cost of mitigating environmental impacts. Atascadero does not control school and water impact fees. These services are managed by separate districts. Table V-26.Table V-37. Planning and Development Fees*A Fee Category Fee Amount Planning Fees (cost recovery) - Adopted May 1 , 2014 Administrative AUP Review $665 per application Minor CUP Review $1,090 per application Major CUP Review $3,910 per application Variance Application $1,725 per application Development Agreement $12,000 deposit, plus additional fees (staff charges, etc) Specific Plan $9,000 deposit, plus additional fees (staff charges, etc) General Plan Amendment $6,895 per application PD Zone Change $6,810 per application Rezoning (Map or Text) $3,785 per application ($7,235 rezoning with GP amendment) Tentative Parcel Map $4,080 per application Tentative Tract Map $5,615 per map, plus $40 per lot over 15 lots Condominium Conversion Tentative Map $4,920 + $64 per unit over 15 units if converting over 4 units Precise Plan $2,045 per application Annexation $15,000 deposit, plus additional fees (staff charges, etc) Lot Line Adjustment Review $1,295 per application historic lot line $2,170 for others Lot Merger $1,315 per application Temporary Occupancy Review $345 per application (Residential) Administrative Time Extension Review $395 per application Planning Commission Time Extension Review $725 per application Appeal to Planning Commission (not full cost recovery) $695 per application Appeal to City Council (not full cost recovery) $935 per application Planning Review/Approval of Building Permit Minor $90 per application Major $315 per application CUP/PD Compliance $415 DRC Review $355 Affordable Housing Unit Fee Process $285 per application plus $190/unit and any plus legal costs Environmental Review Environmental Impact Report Review 10% of contract consultant amount of City staff review Environmental Negative Declaration $1,455 per application in addition to other application fees, where applicable Capital Facilities Fees - Adopted June 30, 2007 SFR MFR Law Enforcement Facilities $574 $334 Fire Protection Facilities $950 - $955 $516 - $550 Fire Aerial Response Vehicle -- $242 Circulation System $5,597 $2,822 - $5,597 Storm Drainage Facilities $777 - $2,000 $314 - $499 General Government Facilities $1,036 $1,036 Public Review Draft Page 66 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element Library Expansion Facilities $532 $323 - $418 Public Meeting Facilities $1,084 $660 - $852 Parkland $4,775 $2,906 - $3,754 Open Space Acquisition $1,660 $1,011 - $1,305 Sewer $573 plus admin fee of $5 plus $1210 extension fee A. Not regulatory. For reference only.* Planning and development fees display current rates at the time of publication. Fees are subject to change at the discretion of the City Council. Zoning Ordinance may be amended independently of this table. Please check with the City of Atascadero Community Development Department for a current fee schedule. Source: City of Atascadero, 2014 City records provided examples of fees charged on new housing projects (see Table V-38). Fees collected by the City in the review and development process are limited to the City's costs for providing these services, and approximately 48 percent of development fees are imposed by agencies outside the City’s control (i.e. school district impact fees and water connection fees). Table V-27.Table V-38. Development Fees for New Housing, 2014A Development Fee Category Single Family Unit Multi-Family Unit Building and Planning fees $4,500 - $7,500 $4,000 - $6,000 School District - Atascadero Unified School District $6,7201 $4,3682 Water Connection3 - Atascadero Mutual Water Company $21,270 $13,700 Impact Fees $16,900 - $18,200 $11,700 - $14,550 Miscellaneous $1,000 $2,000 Total $50,400 - $54,690 $35,768 - $40,618 Notes: A. Not regulatory. For reference only, refer to City’s website for latest fee schedule. City fee schedule may be amended independently of this table. 1. Assumes a 2,000 square foot single family dwelling with the impact fee at $3.36 per square foot. 2. Assumes a 1,300 square foot multi-family unit with the impact fee at $3.36 per square foot. 3. Meter installation and connection fee rates are based on meter size or Equivalent Dwelling Unit (EDU), whichever is greater. Meter installation fees start at $1,670.00 for 3/4" meter (standard residential size) or 1.00 EDU. Secondary Residential units are assessed 65% of the fee charged for the primary residence and may connect an additional meter for a charge of $1,670.00. Connection fees (system impact fees) range from $19,600.00 for 3/4” (residential) meter to $49,000.00 for a 1” meter, which may be required due to fire flow. Connection fees vary for multi-family projects. Residential Multi-Family projects without a dedicated landscape meter are charged 0.5 EDU. Residential Multi-Family projects with a dedicated landscape meter are charged 0.25 EDU. Source: City of Atascadero, 2014; Atascadero Mutual Water Company, 2014. Development fees make up approximately 13 to 20 percent of a home purchase price (see Table V-39). The City of Atascadero fees are comparable to those of surrounding communities. Table V-28.Table V-39. Proportion of Fee in Overall Development Cost for a Typical Residential Development, 2014 Development Cost for a Typical Unit Single Family Multiple Family Total estimated fees $50,400 - $54,690/unit $35,768 - $40,618/unit Estimated sale price/value1 $379,830 $184,660 Estimated proportion of fee cost to overall development cost/unit 13.3- 14.4% 19.4-21.9% 1. Based on one (1) year median sales price from January – December 2013 Zillow home value index. Public Review Draft Page 67 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element Inclusionary requirements and fees also add to housing development costs. In 2003, the City Council approved an Inclusionary Housing Policy for all developments requiring a legislative approval i.e. Zone Change or General Plan Amendment. The Policy requires an in-lieu fee of five percent of the construction valuation of the market rate unit within a project that does not provide 20 percent of the units as affordable. All inclusionary units shall be deed restricted for a period of 30 years. All residential projects under legislative approval are subject to the inclusionary requirement as follows: o Projects of 1-10 units: pay in-lieu fee or build units. o Projects of 11 or more units must build units or receive a Council approval to pay in- lieu fees. The Inclusionary Housing Policy requires that all affordable units in single family land use areas be designated for moderate-income households. The distribution of affordable units in multi-family and mixed-use commercial land use areas area: 20 percent very low-income, 37 percent low-income, and 43 percent moderate-income. Affordable units must be constructed at the same time as the market-rate units and affordable units must be physically distributed throughout the project site, rather than concentrated in one area. To ensure compliance with these requirements, a construction timeline detailing the development of affordable units and a site map must be approved by the City Council. With City Council approval alternatives to on-site construction or payment of in-lieu fees for inclusionary units may be allowed, including: off-site construction, land dedication, or combinations of construction, fees, and land dedications. As an incentive to provide affordable units, all inclusionary units shall be treated as density bonus units that are not counted as part of the maximum density entitlement of a site. As an increasing number of inclusionary units move toward construction, the development community has raised concerns regarding the financing and resale of these units. In an attempt to mitigate some of these financing issues, the City Council approved an equity-sharing program for the moderate-income homes. The equity- sharing program calls for the home to eventually be re-sold at the fair market value, with the City receiving its share of the sales proceeds to re-invest in affordable housing. Permit Processing Housing production may be constrained by development review procedures, fees, and standards. Residential projects proposed in Atascadero may be subject to design, environmental review, zoning, subdivision and planned unit development review, use permit control, and building permit approval, which together can take up to 24 months for a single family or multi- family projects. Table V-40 displays the review authority required for various planning decisions and permits. Table V-41 displays the typical timelines for approvals and permits for the City of Atascadero. Minor residential projects typically take from one to three months from submittal of the application through completion of the approval process. Larger residential projects can take six to twelve months. Permit processing is a time consuming and costly process, especially for integrated projects such as those involving elements of affordable housing and mixed-use. City Public Review Draft Page 68 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element Staff adhere to strict review times consistent with State law for entitlement review. Review times are approximately 30 days for most projects. Processing timeframes have been generally predicated on how quickly the applicant can process corrections or changes to the proposed project. The City has proposed Programs 6.1-1 through 6.1-6 to continue to review and revise procedures to streamline the permitting process. Table V-29.Table V-40. Permit Processing ProceduresA Type of Decision Role of Review Authority Director or City Staff Design Review Committee Planning Commission City Council Zoning Review (Administrative) Decision N/A Appeal Appeal Administrative Use Permit Decision/Recommend1 Decision1 Appeal Appeal Variance Recommend N/A Decision Appeal Zoning Map Amendment Recommend N/A Recommend Decision Design Review Approval Recommend Decision Appeal Appeal Planned Development (Master Plan of Development required) Recommend Recommend Recommend Decision Condition Use Permit Recommend Recommend Decision Appeal Subdivision Maps Recommend Recommend Decision Appeal Notes: A. Not regulatory. For reference only, refer to Zoning Ordinance for the latest official review procedures. Zoning Ordinance may be amended independently of this table. 1. Design Review may be considered the “hearing officer” for AUP applications for non-residential uses Source: City of Atascadero, 2014 Table V-30.Table V-41. Timelines for Permit ProceduresA Type of Approval, Permit, or Review Typical Processing Time These time periods begin when a complete application is submitted and are extended when additional information is requested by the City. The timeframes below are target issuance date—when the applicant can expect a decision on their application. Zoning Review (Administrative) Concurrent with building permit Administrative Use Permit 1-3 months Variance 1-3 months Design Review Approval Concurrent with building permit Planned Development Review 6-12 months Condition Use Permit, minor 1-3 months Condition Use Permit, major 3-6 months Zoning Amendment 3-6 months General Plan Amendment 6-12 months Subdivision Maps 6-9 months Notes: A. Not regulatory. For reference only. Actual permit review times may vary. Source: City of Atascadero, 2014 Ministerial Review Planning review of ministerial projects, such as building permits, are reviewed concurrently with building, fire, and public works. The City offers pre-project meetings to discuss zoning Public Review Draft Page 69 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element compliance and building code requirements to ensure that the process is streamlined. Planning review of routine over the counter permits is limited to tree protection when trees exist on-site and are within the area of development. Design Review The Atascadero Appearance Review Manual was adopted by the City Council in 1987. The Manual includes direction regarding the relationship of buildings to the site, relationship of buildings and the site to the adjoining area, landscaping, building design, maintenance, and parking. The purpose of Appearance Review is to ensure that the architectural and general appearance of buildings and grounds are in keeping with the character of the neighborhood. The City developed the Downtown Design Guidelines in 2000. The design guidelines were intended to assist in the revitalization of the Atascadero downtown, provide for infill development, and promote the conservation and reuse of existing buildings. The Guidelines provide a basis for review of building orientation, design, architecture, landscaping, and signs of new projects in the downtown. The guidelines were updated in 2011. The Design Review Committee (DRC) was established by the City Council in August 2010. Municipal Code Section 9-2.107 identifies the purpose, authority, and approval criteria for the DRC. The DRC consists of members of City Council and Planning Commission and one member of the public, and has the authority to approve and make recommendation in regards to the architectural appearance, signage, site plans and landscape plans. Appearance approval is based on adherence to policies of the General Plan, compatibility with surrounding uses, and consistency with the guidelines and recommendations in the Appearance Review Manual and Downtown Design Guidelines. All multi-family residential projects, single family residential projects requiring a Planned Development permit, or any projects requiring a precise plan, conditional use permit, zone change or general plan amendment must go through design review prior to Planning Commission or City Council. The DRC has been helpful in project streamlining by working out issues that normally would have been dealt by Planning Commission or simply at a staff level. The Design Review process does not appear to have a significant effect on housing affordability. Staff will continue to provide educational materials and training for the DRC regarding the function and scope to ensure it is not inadvertently used to reduce housing units. Environmental Review Process/Precise Plan A considerable amount of larger-scale developments in the City occur through the use of Precise Plans or other applications that trigger environmental review. Precise plan approval is required when a development or use of land is listed in a particular zoning district as an allowable use and when it is determined by the Director that the project is not eligible for a categorical exemption pursuant to Public Resources Code Section 21084 and the State EIR Guidelines. State regulations require environmental review of discretionary project proposals (e.g., subdivision maps, precise plans, use permits, etc.). The timeframes associated with Public Review Draft Page 70 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element environmental review are regulated by CEQA. In compliance with the Permit Streamlining Act, City staff ensures that non-legislative proposals are heard at the Planning Commission within 60 days of receipt of an application being deemed complete. Precise Plan applications are reviewed and approved by staff concurrently with the building permit review. Housing For People With Disabilities California law requires jurisdictions to analyze potential and actual constraints on housing for persons with disabilities, demonstrate efforts to remove impediments, and include programs to accommodate housing designed for disabled persons. Review of the Municipal Code, permitting procedures, development standards, and building codes revealed the following findings: • The City enforces Title 24 of the California Code of Regulations that addresses access and adaptability of buildings to accommodate persons with disabilities. The City also requires compliance with the 1988 amendments to the Fair Housing Act, which requires a minimum percentage of dwelling units in new RMF housing projects to be fully accessible to the physically disabled. No additional accessibility standards above State and Federal law are required. • In downtown zones, where residential uses are limited to the upper floors, a handicapped accessible unit may be located on a first floor if a project is required to provide a unit in compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act, subject to development standards. Process for Reasonable Accommodation Accessibility improvements to existing structures, such as a ramp, are usually handled ministerially by City staff. The City adopted a reasonable accommodation ordinance in 2013. Table V-42 reviews zoning and land use policies, permitting practices, and building codes to ensure compliance with State and Federal fair housing laws for persons with disabilities. The City has proposed Program 4.2-1 to ensure continued compliance with ADA standards and reasonable accommodation in residential development. Table V-31.Table V-42. Constraints on Housing for Persons with Disabilities General Does the City have a process for persons with disabilities to make requests for reasonable accommodation? Yes. The City adopted a reasonable accommodation ordinance in 2013. Has the City made efforts to remove constraints on housing for persons with disabilities? There are no special permits or requirements for homes or development for disabled persons in zones where the use would be otherwise permitted. In most cases, these developments are permitted use. Does the City assist in meeting identified needs? The City applies Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) funds to accessibility upgrades. The San Luis Obispo Housing Authority recently completed a 19-unit retirement hotel, which contained ADA compliant units. Zoning and Land Use Public Review Draft Page 71 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element Has the City reviewed all its zoning laws, policies, and practices for compliance with fair housing law? Yes, the City has reviewed the land use regulations and practices to ensure compliance with fair housing laws. Are residential parking standards for persons with disabilities different from other parking standards? Does the City have a policy or program for the reduction of parking requirements for special needs housing if a proponent can demonstrate a reduced parking need? Section 9-4.114 of the Planning and Zoning Regulations (Off-street parking required) mandates the provision of disabled parking spaces in accordance with California Building Code (part 2 of Title 24) Chapter 11. The parking requirements also allow flexibility if an applicant can demonstrate a lower parking need. Does the locality restrict the siting of group homes? No What zones allow group homes other than those allowed by State law? Are group home over six persons allowed? Group homes (referred to as residential care facilities in the Planning and Zoning Regulations) of six or less individuals are allowed by right in all residential districts. They are allowed in the Public (P) zone with a Conditional Use Permit. Facilities with greater than 6 persons are permitted, by right, in the Residential Multiple Family (RMF) zone and in the single-family residential zones [Residential Suburban (RS), Residential Single Family (RSF), Limited Single Family (LSF)] and the P zone with a Conditional Use Permit. Does the City have occupancy standards in the zoning code that apply specifically to unrelated adults and not to families? No. Does the land use element regulate the siting of special needs housing in relationship to one another? No, there is no minimum distance required between two or more special needs housing. Permits and Processing How does the City process a request to retrofit homes for accessibility? Atascadero allows residential retrofitting to increase the suitability of homes for people with disabilities in compliance with ADA requirements, as permitted in the 2013 California Building Code. Does the City allow groups homes with six or fewer persons by right in single-family zones? Yes. Does the City have a set of particular conditions or use restrictions for group homes with greater than six persons? Group homes (or residential care facilities) with greater than six persons are permitted, by right, in the RMF zone and in the single-family residential zones (RS, RSF, LSF) and the P zone with a Conditional Use Permit. They are subject design review and are required to be incompliance with the same parking and site coverage requirements as multi-family uses. What kind of community input does the City allow for the approval of group homes? Group homes (or residential care facilities) with greater than 6 persons are permitted, by right, in the RMF zone. No other planning approval is required in the RMF zone other than to ensure that the development conforms to the standards of the Development Code. In the single- family residential zones (RS, RSF, LSF) and the P zone a Conditional Use Permit is required. The Conditional Use Permit provides the public with an opportunity to review the project and express their concerns in a public hearing. Does the City have particular conditions for group homes that will be providing services on site? No, the City does not have special standards for group homes regarding services or operation. Building Codes Has the locality adopted the Uniform Building Code? Atascadero has adopted the 2013 California Building Code, which incorporated the 2012 International Building Code. No amendments have been made that affect the ability to accommodate persons with disabilities. Has the City adopted any universal design element into the code? No, the City has no adopted universal design standards at this time. Does the City provide reasonable accommodation for persons with disabilities in the enforcement of building codes and the issuance of building permits? Yes. The City adopted a reasonable accommodation ordinance in 2013. Public Review Draft Page 72 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element Energy Conservation Planning to maximize energy efficiency and the incorporation of energy conservation and green building features contributes to reduced housing costs. Energy efficient design for sustainable communities reduces dependence on automobiles. Additionally, maximizing energy efficiency reduces greenhouse gas emissions. In response to recent legislation on global climate change, local governments are required to implement measures that cut greenhouse gas emissions attributable to land use decisions (see discussion on Global Climate Change below). The Housing Element programs can support energy efficiency that benefits the market, the environment, and the long-term health of the community by:  Establishing a more compact urban core, bringing residents close to work and services, therefore reducing automobile trips and reducing emissions;  Implementing passive solar construction techniques that require solar orientation, thermal massing, and other energy efficient design standards; and  Encouraging the use of solar water heating and photovoltaics. Executive Order S-E-05 initiated the first steps in establishing greenhouse gas emission reduction targets in California. This was followed by the California Global Warming Solutions Act (AB 32), which required the California Air Resources Board (CARB) to establish reduction measures. There are several areas where programs for energy conservation in new and existing housing units are supported by the City:  Through application of State residential building standards that establish energy performance criteria for new residential buildings (Title 24 of the California Administrative Code). These regulations establish insulation, window glazing, air conditioning, and water heating system requirements. The City also instituted the City Council adopted Energy Conservation Initiative in 2001.  Through appropriate land use policies and development standards that reduce energy consumption. The City of Atascadero’s General Plan is based on the Smart Growth Principles of encouraging infill and reuse of existing land and infrastructure. The Land Use, Open Space, and Conservation Element include goals to preserve a greenbelt around the City, encourage mixed use infill development, revitalize of the Downtown Core, and encourage compact development with a pedestrian scale and trails. Public Review Draft Page 73 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element  Through the implementation of the City Housing Rehabilitation Loan Program and County Neighborhood Preservation Program; which often includes attic and exterior wall insulation, door and window repair or replacement, weather stripping and caulking, duct insulation, and water heater blankets in rehabilitation projects.  City environmental review may also require measures to reduce energy consumption.  GRID Alternatives for low-income families and how the City can perform outreach. Pacific Gas and Electric (PG&E) provides a variety of energy conservation services for residents and provides several other energy assistance programs for lower income households. These programs include their Energy Watch Partnerships and the Charitable Contributions Program. The Energy Watch Partnerships help residents lower their energy bills and promote cleaner energy production. Through this program, PG&E has extended the reach of effectiveness of energy efficiency programs, and provided information about demand responses programs, renewable energy and self-generations opportunities. The Charitable Contributions Program provides millions of dollars each year to non-profit organizations to support environmental and energy sustainability. Projects include residential and community solar energy distribution projects, public education projects, and energy efficiency programs. The goal is to ensure that 75 percent of the funding assist underserved communities, which includes low-income households, people with disabilities, and seniors. PG&E also offers rebates for energy efficient home appliances and remodeling. Rebates are available for cooling and heating equipment, lighting, seasonal appliances, and remodeling (cool roofs, insulation, water heaters). These opportunities are available to all income levels and housing types. Energy Consumption Residential water heating and HVAC systems are major sources of energy consumption. With the application of energy efficient design and the use of solar power systems, home heating and cooling can be operated in a more efficient and sustainable manner. By encouraging solar energy technology for residential heating/cooling in both retrofits and new construction, the City can play a major role in energy conservation. There are two distinct approaches to solar heating: active and passive. The best method to encourage use of solar systems for heating and cooling is to not restrict their use in the zoning and building ordinances and to require subdivision layouts that facilitate solar use. Residential water heating can be made more energy efficient through the application of solar water heating technologies. Solar water heating relies on the sun to heat water, which is then Active Systems use mechanical equipment to collect and transport heat, such as a roof plate collector system used in solar water and space heaters. Passive Systems use certain types of building materials to absorb solar energy and can transmit that energy later, without mechanization. Public Review Draft Page 74 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element stored for later use. A conventional water heater is needed only as a back-up. By cutting the amount of natural gas needed to heat water by 50 to 75 percent per building, solar water heating systems can lower energy bills and reduce greenhouse gas emissions significantly. The City has the opportunity to implement solar technologies with the help of recent legislation. The Solar Water Heating and Efficiency Act of 2007 (AB 1470) has created a $250 million, ten-year program to provide consumer rebates for solar water heating systems. Global Climate Change There are significant areas where Atascadero can do more to encourage energy conservation in new and existing residential development to reduce the demand on energy. There are a variety of energy efficiency and greenhouse gas emission reduction strategies that can be integrated into land use decisions related to housing. Table V-43 lists strategies to address energy conservation and global climate change, developed by the California Environmental Protection Agency’s Climate Action Team. As an active member of Local Governments for Sustainability, Atascadero is also participating in an effort to inventory and reduce greenhouse gas emissions. Through these and other conservation measures, the City seeks to help minimize the percentage of household income required for energy costs as well as minimize the production of greenhouse gases. Programs have been included to incorporate newly adopted State energy efficiency standards and to encourage alternative energy efficient technologies. Table V-32.Table V-43. Strategies to Address Energy Conservation and Global Climate Change Action Team Project Design/Mitigation to Comply with Strategy Housing Element Strategy Building Energy Efficiency Standards in Place and in Progress: Public Resources Code 25402 authorizes the CEC to adopt and periodically update its building energy efficiency standards (that apply to newly constructed buildings and additions to and alterations to existing buildings) Residential development projects have the potential to achieve a greater reduction in combined space heating, cooling and water heating energy compared to the current Title 24 Standards. Ensure all new development is in compliance with CEC energy efficiency requirements as they are updated. Smart Land Use: Smart land use strategies encourage jobs/housing proximity, promote transit-oriented development, and encourage high- density residential/commercial development along transit corridors. Specific strategies include: Promoting jobs/housing proximity and transit oriented development Encouraging high-density residential/commercial development along transit/rail corridor. Encourage compact residential development. Green Buildings Initiative: Green Building Executive Order, S-20-04 (CA 2004), sets a goal of reducing energy use in public and private buildings by 20 percent by the year 2015, as compared with 2003 levels. Residential development projects could increase energy efficiency percentage beyond Title 24 requirements. In addition, the project could implement other green building design (i.e., natural daylighting and on-site renewable, electricity generation). The City has made some efforts towards encouraging green building. In 2006 the City signed a Memorandum of Understanding with SLO Greenbuild. In 2007 the City Hall permit counter installed a kiosk with SLO Greenbuild information and information on environmentally friendly construction methods and materials. Public Review Draft Page 75 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element = California Solar Initiative: Installation of 1 million solar roofs or an equivalent 3,000 MW by 2017 on homes and businesses; increased use of solar thermal systems to offset the increasing demand for natural gas; use of advanced metering in solar applications; and creation of a funding source that can provide rebates over 10 years through a declining incentive schedule. If feasible, the project could install photovoltaic cells or other solar options. The City could access the incentives that will be made available and provide information to developers, to encourage the installation of solar roofs on new residential development. The City has actively promoted solar technology by implementing AB 811. Source: State of California, Environmental Protection Agency, Climate Action Team, 2007 2. Non-Governmental Constraints The availability and cost of housing is strongly influenced by market factors over which local government has little or no control. State law requires that the housing element contain a general assessment of these constraints, which can serve as the basis for actions that local governments might take to offset their effects. The primary non-governmental constraints to the development of new housing are land, construction costs, and environmental constraints. Land And Construction Costs The cost and availability of capital financing affect the overall cost of housing in two ways: first, when the developer uses capital for initial site preparation and construction and, second, when the homebuyer uses capital to purchase housing. The capital used by the developer is borrowed for the short-term at commercial rates, which are considerably higher than standard mortgage rates. Construction financing is sometimes difficult to obtain for multifamily construction, which poses a significant constraint on the production of affordable housing in Atascadero. Land costs include acquisition and the cost of holding land throughout the development process. These costs can account for as much as half of the final sales prices of new homes in small developments or in areas where land is scarce. Land costs in single-family residential neighborhoods of Atascadero range from $8,000 to $395,000 per acre.7 Among the variables affecting the cost of land are the size of lots, location and amenities, the availability and proximity of public services, and the financing arrangement between the buyer and seller. Construction costs vary widely depending on the type, size, and amenities of the development. Based on a recent national survey or residential developers 8, the average cost of construction of a single family home in 2013 was $246,453, or $95 per square foot. This is an increase in typical construction costs over the past few years, $15 more per square foot than in 2011. Environmental And Physical Constraints 7 A review of realtor websites in April 2014 provided 19 vacant lots for sale within the City. Land costs were estimated from this sample. 8 Taylor, H., Economics and Housing Policy National Association of Home Builders, January 2014. Public Review Draft Page 76 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element The following potential physical and environmental constraints may affect development regulated by the City by limiting the development potential and/or adding mitigation costs to a project: Environmental Constraints Several special status species are known to occur in Atascadero, including: dwarf calycadenia, Douglas’ spineflower, Hardham’s evening-primrose, Jared’s pepper-grass, Kellogg’s horkelia, Oval-leaved snapdragon, rayless aphanactis, round-leaved filaree, Salinas milk vetch, Salinas valley goldfields, shining navarretia, and straight-awned spineflower. The City also protects unique vegetation communities that support sensitive species, including wetlands. Wetland habitat types are considered a vegetation community of special concern by the CDFG because of substantial statewide losses. The presence of special-status species and plant communities of special concern may affect development regulated by the City by limiting the development potential and/or adding mitigation costs. The grasslands, riparian habitats, and tracts of undeveloped land provide habitat for a diverse selection of resident and migrant wildlife. Eighteen special status bird and mammal species are known to occur in Atascadero. Barriers to wildlife movement and migration and the removal of raptor nesting sites are to be avoided in future development. The occurrence of any of these species on a site could pose constraints to a housing project. Preservation of natural flora and fauna is a basic community goal and native trees are valued community assets. The City has established regulations for the installation, maintenance, planting, preservation, protection, and selected removal of native trees within the City limits through the adoption of the Native Tree Ordinance. A tree removal permit is required for the removal of native trees (as defined by Chapter 11, Native Tree Regulations) and for pruning of the live canopy in native trees in excess of 25 percent of the existing canopy area. In addition, for each residential building permit issued, the planting of one five-gallon native tree is required. The mitigation requirements may become cumbersome for high-density projects, as tree replacement may be required on-site that is at the sole expense of the applicant. However, native and drought tolerant landscaping may be used to meet landscape requirements and does not specifically add costs above standard Zoning Ordinance landscaping requirements. Physical Constraints Several physical constraints may occur in the City. Parcels with steep slopes may have constraints associated with landslide hazards, grading costs, and access requirements. Landslides are relatively rare in the developed portions of the City, as compared to in the hilly, undeveloped areas. Stationary noise sources near potential sites for development may pose constraints. For example, traffic on U.S. Route 101 exceeds acceptable noise levels. Housing may be limited within 500 feet of U.S. Route 101 under CEQA, due to the health hazards of siting sensitive uses near urban roads with over 100,000 vehicles per day unless appropriate mitigation can be identified and implemented. Operational noise sources near potential sites for development may pose constraints as well; such as the Southern Pacific railroad tracks that run north-south through the eastern portion of the City. Residential uses adjacent to the railroad tracks have the potential to be exposed to noise that exceed acceptable noise levels, although noise incidences are temporary (dependent on railroad operation). In addition, low- Public Review Draft Page 77 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element lying areas of the City may be subject to flooding during a 100-year storm (See Figure IV-1 in the Safety and Noise Element of the General Plan). This Page Intentionally Left Blank Public Review Draft Page 78 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element H. Housing Element Goals, Policies, and Programs The following goals, policies, and programs have been established to address housing issues in Atascadero and to meet State law housing requirements. Programs generally include a statement of specific City action(s) necessary to implement a policy or goal and identify the City department or other agency responsible for implementation, the quantified objectives (where applicable), and a timeframe for completion. Goal HOS 1: Promote diverse and high quality housing opportunities to meet the needs of all segments of the community. Policy 1.1: Encourage new housing, including mixed-use projects in commercial land use areas, to meet the needs of all household types in the City. Programs: 1. Continue street and infrastructure improvement projects to benefit existing high density residential areas. Funding Source: General Fund, Public Works Department Responsible Agency: Community Development Department Timeframe: Ongoing Quantified Objective: n/a 2. Continue to require the use of specific plans for residential projects of 100 or more units. Funding Source: General Fund Responsible Agency: Community Development Department, Planning Commission, City Council Timeframe: Ongoing Quantified Objective: n/a 3. Continue to allow manufactured housing and group housing in accordance with State law. In order be in compliance with State law (Government Health and Safety Code Section 18500), the City should clarify that the terms “mobilehome” and “manufactured home” are essentially the same. Manufactured housing placed on a permanent foundation should be considered a single-family dwelling and permitted in all zones that allow single-family housing. Funding Source: General Fund Responsible Agency: Community Development Department, Planning Commission, City Council Timeframe: Within two years of adoption of the Housing Element Quantified Objective: 20 units Public Review Draft Page 79 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element 4. Support the extension and expansion of sewer service for the Eagle Ranch annexation area by allocating the funding necessary. Funding Source: General Fund Responsible Agency: Community Development Department, Planning Commission, City Council, Public Works Department Timeframe: Ongoing Quantified Objective: 100 affordable units 5. Continue to allow mixed residential and commercial development and promote second- and third-story residential development in the City’s Downtown zoning districts. Taking into account market conditions and development costs, the City will provide, when possible, developer incentives such as expedited permit processing and flexible development standards for units that are affordable to lower income households. The City will publicize these incentives on the City’s website (www.atascadero.org) within one week of a confirmed decision to make them available in a timely fashion. Funding Source: General Fund Responsible Agency: Community Development Department, Planning Commission, City Council Timeframe: Ongoing Quantified Objective: 20 units 6. Adopt a Rural Residential Zone in the Zoning Ordinance consistent with its designation on the Zoning Map and standards that distinguish it from the Residential Suburban zone (to facilitate the development of a variety of housing types). Funding Source: General Fund Responsible Agency: Community Development Department Timeframe: Within three years of Housing Element adoption Quantified Objective: n/a 7. Continue to encourage, where suitable, Planned Unit Development (PD) Overlay Zones, for small lot subdivisions, for higher density attached or row-house style housing in the RMF zoning districts. Funding Source: General Fund Responsible Agency: Community Development Department, Planning Commission, City Council Timeframe: Ongoing Quantified Objective: 75 units 8. Continue to maintain an affordable housing density bonus ordinance that establishes procedures for obtaining and monitoring density bonuses in compliance with State law. Following adoption the City shall regularly update the ordinance to be in compliance with Government Code §65915. Funding Source: General Fund Responsible Agency: Community Development Department, Planning Commission, City Council Timeframe: Ordinance adoption – within two years of Housing Element adoption; updating ordinance for compliance with State law - ongoing Public Review Draft Page 80 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element Quantified Objective: 25 units 9. [Modified] Continue to monitor the impact of the City’s current inclusionary housing policy on production of market rate housing in response to market conditions. If the policy presents an obstacle to the development of the City's fair share of regional housing needs, the City will revise the policy accordingly. Funding Source: General Fund Responsible Agency: Community Development Department Timeframe: On-going Quantified Objective: n/a 10. Adopt an inclusionary housing ordinance that requires residential developments to provide deed-restricted, affordable units or an in-lieu fee. The inclusionary ordinance shall be consistent with State rent control laws for rental housing. Funding Source: General Fund Responsible Agency: Community Development Department Timeframe: Within three years of Housing Element adoption Quantified Objective: 70 units 11. [Modified] To encourage the development of second units, the City will evaluate the development standards and update the Zoning Ordinance for second units (secondary residential units). For example, the City will explore incentives such as eliminating the covered parking requirement for a secondary residential unit. Funding Source: General Fund Responsible Agency: Community Development Department, Public Works Department, City Council Timeframe: Within two years of Housing Element adoption Quantified Objective: 10 units 12. [Modified] To encourage the development of second units, the City should consider reduced development impact fees for second units as part of an AB 1600 study. The City will also work with Atascadero Mutual Water Company to investigate the possibility of reductions to water connection fees for second units. Funding Source: General Fund Responsible Agency: Community Development Department, Public Works Department, City Council Timeframe: Within one year of Housing Element adoption Quantified Objective: 15 units 13. [Modified] The City will consider an amnesty program that would reduce or eliminate fees for unpermitted second units. Funding Source: General Fund Responsible Agency: Community Development Department, Public Works Department, City Council Timeframe: Within three years of Housing Element adoption Quantified Objective: 15 units 14. Continue to maintain Chapter 12 of the Zoning Ordinance (Condo Conversion Ordinance) in order to reduce the impacts of condo conversions on lower cost rental housing. Public Review Draft Page 81 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element Funding Source: General Fund Responsible Agency: Community Development Department, Planning Commission, City Council Timeframe: Ongoing Quantified Objectives: n/a 15.Continue to work with non-profit agencies, such as the County Housing Authority, Habitat for Humanity, the San Luis Obispo County Housing Trust Fund and Peoples’ Self-Help Housing, to preserve existing affordable housing and to pursue funding for new units for extremely low-, very low-, low-, and moderate-income families. Funding Source: General Fund, CDBG, Tax Credits Responsible Agency: Community Development Department Timeframe: Annual meetings, during preparation of annual review of the Housing Element, to discuss funding opportunities, vacant and opportunity sites, and status of affordable housing projects, Ongoing collaboration Quantified Objective: 50 units 16.Continue to encourage developers to work with agencies such as the California Housing Finance Authority (CHFA) and the Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) to obtain loans for development of new multifamily rental housing for low income households. This will be accomplished by working with appropriate non-profit organizations, such as People’s Self Help Housing and the San Luis Obispo County Housing Trust Fund to identify opportunities. Specifically, the City will: • Contact potential affordable housing developers. • Identify funding opportunities and pursue financing. • Assist in preparing applications for funds. • Provide regulatory concessions and incentives, as necessary, to encourage and facilitate the construction of affordable housing. Funding Source: General Fund Responsible Agency: Community Development Department Timeframe: Develop list of potential affordable housing developers within one year of Housing Element adoption, Bi- annually contact potential affordable housing developers to discuss funding opportunities, application and entitlement assistance, including incentives, Ongoing Quantified Objective: n/a 17.Continue to contract with the San Luis Obispo Housing Authority for administration of the Section 8 housing voucher program. The City utilizes this relationship for program implementation and income verifications, and will apply for additional Section 8 vouchers, as appropriate. Funding Source: HUD Section 8 Responsible Agency: Community Development Department, City Council, Housing Authority Timeframe: Ongoing, when eligible Quantified Objective: n/a Public Review Draft Page 82 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element 18. Amend the Zoning Ordinance to allow a waiver of the two- story height limit in the RMF Zone through the Minor Use Permit process, substantially reducing permit fee and review period.. This option applies to projects that are not using the Planned Development option. Funding Source: General Fund Responsible Agency: Community Development Department Timeframe: Within one two years of Housing Element adoption Quantified Objective: n/a 19. [NEW ] To encourage and facilitate development of a variety of housing types, the City should consider amending the Zoning Ordinance to establish standards, policies, and procedures for efficiency or micro detached units consistent with the California Building Code. The ordinance should provide a definition of efficiency or micro detached unit as a single habitable living unit, separate from and not including a single-room occupancy unit. Funding Source: General Fund Responsible Agency: Community Development Department Timeframe: Within three years of Housing Element adoption Quantified Objective: n/a 20. [NEW] To reduce constraints to multi-family housing production the City will amend the zoning ordinance to modify Conditional Use Permit requirements for multi-family housing. A CUP will be required only for multi-family projects greater than 50 units. This will not affect the ‘by right’ approval of multi-family projects in the RMF-20 zone, which are not subject to a CUP or a Specific Plan. The City will periodically evaluate the approval process for projects requiring a CUP and monitor the impact the requirement has on project certainty, cost, and approval time. Funding Source: General Fund Responsible Agency: Community Development Department Timeframe: Modify CUP requirement within two years of Housing Element adoption, monitor CUP impact on housing development on-going Quantified Objective: n/a 21. [NEW] The housing needs of persons with disabilities, including persons with developmental disabilities are typically not specifically addressed by Title 9 Regulations. The housing needs of persons with disabilities, in addition to basic affordability, range from slightly modifying existing units to requiring a varying range of supportive housing facilities. In order to assist in the housing needs for persons with Developmental Disabilities, the City will implement the following programs: • The City shall seek State and Federal monies, as funding becomes available, in support of housing construction and rehabilitation targeted for persons with disabilities, including persons with developmental disabilities. • The City shall provide regulatory incentives, such as expedited permit processing and reduced fee, to projects targeted for persons with disabilities, including persons with developmental disabilities. • The City shall work with local organizations such as the Tri-Counties Regional Center and Transitions Mental Health Association to implement an education and outreach program informing families within the City of housing and services Public Review Draft Page 83 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element available for persons with disabilities, including developmental disabilities. The program will include the development of an informational brochure available on the City’s website or at City Hall, Funding Source: General Fund and other sources, as available Responsible Agency: Community Development Department Timeframe: Apply for funding - at least once during the planning period; develop informational material- within two years of Housing Element adoption; provide incentives for development of housing for persons with disabilities- on- going. Quantified Objective: 10 units Goal HOS 2: Protect and conserve the existing housing stock and neighborhoods. Policy 2.1: Encourage conservation and preservation of neighborhoods and sound housing. Programs: 1. As new projects, code enforcement actions, and other opportunities arise, the City will investigate ways to meet its housing needs through rehabilitation and preservation of existing units. Utilize code enforcement to identify housing maintenance issues and expedite rehabilitation of substandard and deteriorating housing by offering technical assistance to homeowners and occupants. Funding Source: General Fund, CDBG Responsible Agency: Community Development Department, Public Works Department Timeframe: Ongoing Quantified Objective: 30 units 2. Continue to participate in federal grant programs, such as Community Development Block Grants (CDBG), to obtain loans and/or grants for housing rehabilitation. Apply an appropriate amount of the City’s annual share of CDBG funds toward rehabilitation of existing housing units. Funding Source: CDBG Responsible Agency: Community Development Department Timeframe: Ongoing Quantified Objective: 25 units 3. Continue to maintain the sliding density scale for sloped lots in the Zoning Ordinance. Funding Source: General Fund Responsible Agency: Community Development Department Timeframe: Ongoing Quantified Objective: n/a Public Review Draft Page 84 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element 4. The City shall continue to monitor the status of subsidized affordable projects, rental projects, and mobile homes in the City and provide technical and financial assistance, when possible, to ensure long-term affordability. This will involve contacting owner/operators of subsided projects annually to determine the status of the units and their potential to convert to market-rate. If projects are at-risk, the City will maintain contact with local organizations and housing providers who may have an interest in acquiring at-risk units, and, when feasible, keep track of and apply for funding opportunities to preserve at-risk units, and assist other organizations in applying for funding to acquire at-risk units. Funding Source: General Fund Responsibility: Community Development Department Timeframe: Contact owners/operators annually and ongoing Quantified Objective: n/a Policy 2.2 Encourage conservation and preservation of houses that have historical and architectural significance. Programs: 1. Continue to implement the Historic Site (HS) overlay zone to help preserve and protect historic Colony homes. Funding Source: General Fund Responsible Agency: Community Development Department Timeframe: Ongoing Quantified Objective: n/a 2. Continue to maintain a GIS based map of historic buildings and sites. Funding Source: General Fund Responsible Agency: Community Development Department Timeframe: Ongoing Quantified Objective: n/a Goal HOS 3: Encourage energy conservation and sustainable building measures in new and existing homes. Policy 3.1: Continue to make residents aware of available energy saving techniques and public utility rebates. Programs: 1. Promote environmentally sustainable building practices that provide cost savings to homeowners and developers. Funding Source: General Fund Responsible Agency: Community Development Department Timeframe: Ongoing Quantified Objective: n/a Public Review Draft Page 85 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element 2. Make available in the Community Development Department brochures from PG&E and others that detail energy conservation measures for new and existing buildings. Funding Source: General Fund Responsible Agency: Community Development Department Timeframe: Ongoing Quantified Objective: n/a 3. Continue to strictly enforce the State energy standards of Title 24. Funding Source: General Fund Responsible Agency: Community Development Department Timeframe: Ongoing Quantified Objective: n/a 4. [NEW ] Enhance partnerships with GRID alternatives for installation of PV panels and other alternative electrical services for low-income households. Funding Source: General Fund Responsible Agency: Community Development Department Timeframe: Ongoing Quantified Objective: n/a Goal HOS 4: Ensure equal access to sound, affordable housing for all persons regardless of race, religion, age, sex, marital status, ancestry, national origin, color, familial status, or disability. Policy 4.1: Support equal housing opportunities and enforcement of State and federal anti-discrimination laws. Programs: 1. Cooperate with non-profit groups and local religious organizations to allow the temporary use of churches as homeless shelters. Funding Source: General Fund Responsible Agency: Community Development Department Timeframe: Ongoing Quantified Objective: n/a 2. Continue to support local motel voucher programs for temporarily displaced and extremely low-income persons. The motel voucher program is funded through the City’s CDBG funding. Motel vouchers are available to aid residents experiencing emergency situations, such as a house fire, in finding temporary housing. The City works with non-profit organizations (such as Loaves and Fishes) to aid the residents in need and provide technical support for the motel voucher program. Funding Source: General Fund Responsible Agency: Community Development Department Timeframe: Ongoing Quantified Objective: n/a 3. [Modified] Continue to allow small (6 or fewer) group housing (residential care facilities) by right in all residential zones and large (7 or more) residential care Public Review Draft Page 86 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element facilities in the Residential Multi Family (RMF) zone. The City should also consider allowing large residential care facilities by right in additional residential, commercial, public, and/or industrial zones, such as LSFX and RSFX zones, where sewer is available. Funding Source: General Fund Responsible Agency: Community Development Department Timeframe: Ongoing Quantified Objective: n/a 4. [Modified] Consider amending the Zoning Ordinance to expand the Emergency Shelter (ES) Overlay Zone to other appropriate properties, subject to the same or similar, as appropriate, locational and operational criteria as outlined in the Zoning Ordinance. Funding Source: General Fund Responsible Agency: Community Development Department Timeframe: Within one year of housing element adoption Quantified Objective: n/a 5. [NEW] Continue to provide information and complaint referral services for those persons who believe they have been denied access to housing because of their race, religion, sex, marital status, ancestry, national origin, color, or disability, family status, sexual orientation, source of income, or political affiliation. The City will educate Community Development Department staff on how to respond to complaints received regarding potential claims of housing discrimination. Staff will be trained to provide the person with an informational handout detailing the process of reporting and filing a claim through the California Department of Fair Employment and Housing. The staff will notify the City Manager and the City Attorney’s office of the intent to file a claim and will be available to provide assistance to the person filing a claim, as needed. Information on Fair Housing law and how to file a claim will also be made available on the City’s website and at the Community Development Department. Funding Source: General Fund Responsible Agency: Community Development Department Timeframe: Brochures available within one year of Housing Element adoption, assistance to persons filing a claim ongoing Quantified Objective: n/a 6. [NEW] The City will amend the Zoning Ordinance to ensure that permit processing procedures for farmworker housing do not conflict with Health and Safety Code Sections 17021.5, which states that farmworker housing for six or fewer employees should be “deemed a single-family structure with a residential land use designation”, and 17021.6 which states that for "employee housing consisting of no more than 36 beds in a group quarters or 12 units or spaces designed for use by a single family or household...no conditional use permit, zoning variance, or other zoning clearance shall be required of employee housing of this employee housing that is not required of any other agricultural activity in the same zone”. Funding Source: General Fund Responsible Agency: Community Development Department Public Review Draft Page 87 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element Timeframe: Within two years of Housing Element adoption Quantified Objective: n/a Policy 4.2: Ensure that persons with disabilities have adequate access to housing. Programs: 1. Continue to ensure full compliance with the California Disability Guidelines and enforce the complementary provisions of the Uniform Building Code. The Zoning Ordinance will be evaluated on an ongoing basis and amended as necessary, to ensure ADA compliance and remove governmental constraints on the production of housing for persons with disabilities. Funding Source: General Fund Responsible Agency: Community Development Department Timeframe: Ongoing Quantified Objective: n/a Policy 4.3: Leverage State and Federal loans and grants, to assist in providing affordable housing, preserving existing housing, and rehabilitating unsound housing structures. Programs: 1. [NEW ] Adopt a policy to determine allocation of the City Affordable Housing In-Lieu funds to support the creation of new affordable housing units in Atascadero. Funding Source: General Fund Responsible Agency: Community Development Department, City Council Timeframe: Within one year of Housing Element adoption Quantified Objective: n/a 2. Work with nonprofits and identify funding to address the housing needs of extremely low-income households and totally and permanently disabled persons. Funding Source: Redevelopment Agency Set-Aside Funds and HOME, SHOP, HTF, and other funding sources, as appropriate Responsible Agency: Community Development Department, Redevelopment Agency Timeframe: Identify funding sources annually Quantified Objective: 5 units Goal HOS 5: Decrease non-governmental constraints on housing production. Public Review Draft Page 88 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element Policy 5.1: Encourage interplay between lending institutions, the real estate and development community, and the City to better understand and address non- governmental constraints and facilitate production of affordable housing. Program: 1. Continue to facilitate understanding of the impacts of economic issues, employment, and growth on housing needs among financial, real estate, and development professionals in formalized settings, such as the Economic Round Table. Funding Source: General Fund Responsible Agency: Community Development Department, , Planning Commission, City Council Timeframe: Ongoing Quantified Objective: n/a 2. Continue to work with development community to identify and mitigate any constraints on access to financing for multi-family development. The City will conduct regular stakeholder meetings with members of the development community including representatives from local non-profit housing organizations, developers, and real estate brokers to solicit feedback. Funding Source: General Fund Responsible Agency: Community Development Department Timeframe: Ongoing Quantified Objective: n/a Policy 5.2: Help lower development costs where feasible, especially for low- and moderate-income housing units. Programs: 1. Continue to monitor and evaluate development standards and advances in housing construction methods. Funding Source: General Fund Responsible Agency: Community Development Department Timeframe: Ongoing Quantified Objective: n/a 2. Continue to track the affordability of housing projects and progress toward meeting regional housing needs. Reports should be provided semi-annually to the Planning Commission and annually to the City Council and the California Department of Housing and Community Development. Funding Source: General Fund Responsible Agency: Community Development Department Timeframe: Ongoing Quantified Objective: n/a Goal HOS 6: Decrease governmental constraints on housing production. Public Review Draft Page 89 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element Policy 6.1: Review projects in as timely a manner as possible, while maintaining adequate public involvement and fulfilling the appropriate requirements of State and local laws. Programs: 1. Continue to consolidate all actions relating to a specific project on the same Council or Commission agenda. Funding Source: General Fund Responsible Agency: Community Development Department Timeframe: Ongoing Quantified Objective: n/a 2. [Modified] Continue to review minor project modifications through the Design Review Committee and more substantial changes through a conditional use process. Funding Source: General Fund Responsible Agency: Community Development Department, Planning Commission, City Council Timeframe: Ongoing Quantified Objective: n/a 3. Continue to review and revise local review procedures to streamline the process. Funding Source: General Fund Responsible Agency: Community Development Department, Planning Commission, City Council Timeframe: Ongoing Quantified Objective: n/a 4. Continue to maintain pre-approved stock development plans to streamline the plan check process. Funding Source: General Fund Responsible Agency: Community Development Department Timeframe: Ongoing Quantified Objective: n/a 5. Provide pre-application technical assistance to affordable housing providers to determine project feasibility and address zoning compliance issues in the most cost- effective and expeditious manner possible. Funding Source: General Fund Responsible Agency: Community Development Department Timeframe: Ongoing Quantified Objective: n/a 6. Provide, when possible, developer incentives such as expedited permit processing and fee deferrals for units that are affordable to lower income households. Atascadero will promote these incentives to developers on the City’s website (http://www.atascadero.org) and during the application process. Public Review Draft Page 90 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element Funding Source: General Fund Responsible Agency: Community Development Department Timeframe: Ongoing Quantified Objective: n/a 7. [NEW] The City should consider amending the zoning ordinance to allow single-room occupancy units (SROs) by right in the Residential Multi-Family (RMF) zone. Funding Source: General Fund Responsible Agency: Community Development Department Timeframe: Within three years of Housing Element adoption Quantified Objective: n/a 8. [NEW] To encourage affordability by design, the City shall modify the Capital Facility Fee schedule to index fees based on size of unit, providing lower rates for small units. Indexed rate shall apply to apartments and second units. Funding Source: General Fund Responsible Agency: Community Development Department Timeframe: Within three years of Housing Element adoption Quantified Objective: n/a 8.9. [Modified] The City shall continue to monitor impact fees and the Capital Facility Fee schedule to identify barriers to housing development, particularly affordable units. If constraints are identified, the City shall revise the fee schedule accordingly. Funding Source: General Fund Responsible Agency: Community Development Department, Public Works Department, Planning Commission, City Council Timeframe: Ongoing Quantified Objective: n/a Policy 6.2: [NEW] Maintain consistency and compatibility between the Development Code and General Plan. Programs: 1. Following amendment of the General Plan Conservation and Safety Elements to comply with AB 162 related to floodplain mapping, the City will amend the Housing Element, if needed, for consistency. Funding Source: General Fund Responsible Agency: Community Development Timeframe: Within 1 year of updates of the General Plan Conservation and Safety Elements Quantified Objective: n/a Public Review Draft Page 91 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element Table V-33.Table V-44. Summary of Quantified Objectives, 2014-2019 Program Objective Income Level Extremely Low Very Low Low Moderate Total New Construction 1.1-3 Mobile and group homes 5 0 15 0 20 1.1-4 Expand sewer service 0 15 35 50 100 1.1-5 2nd & 3rd story units downtown 2 3 5 10 20 1.1-7 Encourage higher density 0 0 25 50 75 1.1-8 Density bonus 0 5 10 10 25 1.1-10 Inclusionary ordinance 0 5 15 50 70 1.1-11 Second unit development standards 0 0 0 10 10 1.1-11 Second unit impact fees 0 5 5 5 15 1.1-11 Second unit amnesty 0 0 5 10 15 1.1-11 Second unit development standards 0 0 20 20 40 1.1-21 Persons with disabilities, including developmental disabilities 0 5 5 0 10 4.3-2 Extemely low income and disabled 2 3 0 0 5 New Construction Subtotal 9 4136 140135 215 40395 Rehabilitation 2.1-1 Code enforcement rehabs 5 5 10 10 30 2.1-2 Participate in grant programs 2 3 10 10 25 4.3-2 Repairs and retrofits 0 5 35 35 75 Rehabilitation Subtotal 7 13 55 55 130 Preservation 1.1-15 Work with non-profit partners 2 3 15 5 25 Preservation Subtotal 2 3 15 5 25 Conservation 1.1-15 Work with non-profit partners 3 2 15 5 25 Conservation Subtotal 3 2 15 5 25 Totals 21 594 2250 280 5875 Public Review Draft Page 92 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element I. References Center for Universal Design, Principles of Universal Design, www.design.ncsu.edu/cud/ January 27, 2002 City of Atascadero, General Plan, 2002 City of Atascadero, Housing Element, 2011 City of Atascadero, Planning and Development Fee Schedule, 2008 City of Atascadero, Title 9, 2008 Comprehensive Housing Affordability Strategy (CHAS), State of the Cities Data Systems (SOCDS) 2006-2010, retrieved from http://www.huduser.org/portal/datasets/cp/CHAS/data_querytool_chas.html, retrieved April, 2014 County of San Luis Obispo, Homeless Services Oversight Council (HSOC), Point-In-Time Survey, 2013 San Luis Obispo Council of Governments (SLOCOG), Regional Housing Needs Allocation (RHNA) 20014-2019, Regional Housing Needs Plan State of California, Department of Housing and Community Development (HCD), Median Family Income and Household Income Limits, 2014 State of California, Lanterman Developmental Disabilities Services Act, 1969 State of California, Government Code 65915, Density Bonus Program State of California, California Building Code, 2013 State of California, Title 24 of the California Code of Regulations State of California, California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), 1969 State of California, Solar Water Heating and Efficiency Act (AB 1470), 2007 State of California, Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) Climate Action Team, 2007 State of California, Global Warming Solutions Act (AB 32), 2006 State of California, California Coastal Act, 1976 Public Review Draft Page 93 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element United States, Bureau of the Census, SF-1 and SF-3, 2000 United States, Bureau of the Census, SF-1 and SF-3, 2010 United States, American Community Survey, 5- year estimates, 2010 United States, Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) United States, Civil Rights Act of 1968, Title VIII – Fair Housing Act, amended 1988 Public Review Draft Page 94 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element Appendix I Table V-34.Table V-45. Vacant Land Inventory APN Address Acres Land Use Zoning Density Max Realistic (80%) Site Constraints Vacant Residential Parcels – RMF-20 029-271-001 4711 El Camino Real 1.67 HDR RMF-20 24 units/acre 40.08 32.000 Slope 030-101-053 8959 Curbaril 0.87 HDR RMF-20 24 units/acre 20.88 16 030-281-014, 015, 016 6709, 6725, 6735 Atascadero Ave. 0.72 HDR RMF-20 24 units/acre 17.28 13 030-283-007, 008 6905 Navajoa 1.89 HDR RMF-20 24 units/acre 45.36 36 030-341-017 6855 Santa Lucia Rd. 0.21 HDR RMF-20 24 units/acre 5.04 4 Access way too narrow for multiple units without easement 031-241-019 8391 Amapoa Ave. 0.35 HDR RMF-20 24 units/acre 8.4 6 031-244-010 8065 Amapoa Rd. 0.25 HDR RMF-20 24 units/acre 6 4 045-321-021 9355 Avenida Maria 1.95 HDR RMF-20 24 units/acre 46.8 37 045-321-022 9405 Avenida Maria 0.98 HDR RMF-20 24 units/acre 23.52 18 049-042-018 1155 El Camino Real 5.54 HDR RMF-20 24 units/acre 132.96 106 Slope 049-042-025 1055 El Camino Real 1.81 HDR RMF-20 24 units/acre 43.44 34 049-151-011 2705 El Camino Real 2.4 HDR RMF-20 24 units/acre 57.6 46 Slope 049-151-056 23455 El Camino Real 1.95 HDR RMF-20 24 units/acre 46.8 37 Slope 049-151-063 2535 El Camino Real 2.48 HDR RMF-20 24 units/acre 59.52 47 Slope 049-151-009 2605 El Camino Real 2.39 HDR RMF-20 24 units/acre 57.36 45 Existing SFR 045-310-001 through 035 Woodridge Multi- Family Townhomes 5.85 HDR SP-1/ RMF- 20 24 units/acre 140.4 35 100 Apartment Units completed. Proposed 35 units remianing 049-151-005 2405 El Camino Real / Del Rio Road Commercial Area Specific Plan 2.8 HDR SP-2 / RMF-20 24 units/acre 67.2 44 44 Units max per Specific Plan approval Subtotal RMF-20 34.11 818.64 560 Vacant Residential Parcels – RMF-10 029-105-014 5655 Capistrano 0.54 MDR RMF-10 3 units/acre** 1.61 1 Slope, access to stadium park 030-292-065 6340 Alcantara 1.21 MDR RMF-10 7 units/acre** 8.5 6 Slope, creek 030-373-020 6910 Navajoa Ave. 0.5 MDR RMF-10 10 units/acre 4.96 4 030-491-013, 019, 020, 001 9105 Principal Ave. 5.39 MDR RMF-10 10 units/acre 53.86 43 031-231-003 7900 Curbaril 0.52 MDR RMF-10 10 units/acre 5.22 4 Trees Subtotal RMF-10 8.16 74.15 58 Vacant Residential Parcels – LSF-X 028-051-005 3880 Seperado Ave. 0.07 SFR-X LSF-X 1 unit 1 1.00* 028-051-035 4205 Arizona Ave. 0.2 SFR-X LSF-X 1 unit 1 1.00* 028-061-049 4965 Arizona Ave. 0.12 SFR-X LSF-X 1 unit 1 1.00* 029-272-003 5715 Hermosilla Ave. 0.17 SFR-X LSF-X 1 unit 1 1.00* 030-371-015 6920 Santa Ynez Ave. 0.62 SFR-X LSF-X 1 unit 1 1.00* 031-142-031 7503 Curbaril Ave. 0.1 SFR-X LSF-X 1 unit 1 1.00* Subtotal LSF-X 1.28 6 6 Vacant Residential Parcels – LSF-Y 028-213-001 21 Cabrillo Ave. #PR21 0.02 SFR-Y LSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 028-215-017 5225 Mercedes Ave. 0.56 SFR-Y LSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 028-215-021 7000 Cemetery Rd. 1.06 SFR-Y LSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 028-341-009 5230 Ensenada Ave. 0.34 SFR-Y LSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* Public Review Draft Page 95 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element 028-355-010 5235 Mercedes Ave. 0.56 SFR-Y LSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 028-361-034 5350 Ensenada Ave. 0.38 SFR-Y LSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 028-381-002 5327 Magnolia Ave. 0.23 SFR-Y LSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 030-233-008 6625 Marchant Ave. 0.57 SFR-Y LSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 030-242-036 7695 Constancia Ave. 0.09 SFR-Y LSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 030-301-056 6650 Marchant Ave. 0.73 SFR-Y LSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 030-332-002 5650 Aguila Ave. 0.45 SFR-Y LSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 030-332-004 5710 Aguila Ave. 0.21 SFR-Y LSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 030-351-017 7325 Tecordia Ave. 0.53 SFR-Y LSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 028-341-011 5320 Ensenada Ave. 0.06 SFR-Y LSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 028-354-009 5295 Magdalena Ave. 0.21 SFR-Y LSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 031-142-027 7955 Carmelita Ave. 0.45 SFR-Y LSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 031-061-035 7455 Tecorida Ave. 0.53 SFR-Y LSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 031-061-037 7655 Tecordia Ave. 0.55 SFR-Y LSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 031-061-015 7755 Tecorida Ave. 0.48 SFR-Y LSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 031-062-021 7575 Atascadero Ave. 0.4 SFR-Y LSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 031-062-004 7500 Tecorida Ave. 0.35 SFR-Y LSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 031-062-001 7400 Tecorida Ave. 0.39 SFR-Y LSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 031-161-004 8075 Curbaril Ave. 0.67 SFR-Y LSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 031-133-001 8235 Larga Ave. 0.22 SFR-Y LSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 031-133-003 8209 Larga Ave. 0.41 SFR-Y LSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 031-141-040 7205 Curbaril Ave. 0.2 SFR-Y LSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 031-141-030 7215 Curbaril Ave. 0.17 SFR-Y LSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 031-114-001 8370 Alta Vista Ave. 0.2 SFR-Y LSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 031-112-005 8405 Linda Vista Ave. 0.38 SFR-Y LSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 031-112-014 7805 El Retiro St. 0.4 SFR-Y LSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 031-112-013 7855 El Retiro St. 0.42 SFR-Y LSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 031-113-003 8423 Alta Vista Ave. 0.33 SFR-Y LSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 031-124-001 6800 Navarette Ave. 0.37 SFR-Y LSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 031-023-025 7322 Santa Lucia Rd. 0.13 SFR-Y LSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 031-021-007 5961 Chauplin Ave. 0.44 SFR-Y LSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 031-012-018 5880 Corta Ave. 0.35 SFR-Y LSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 031-012-019 5900 Corta Ave. 0.28 SFR-Y LSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 031-021-008 5965 Chauplin Ave. 0.49 SFR-Y LSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 030-352-028 7175 Atascadero Ave. 0.33 SFR-Y LSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 030-352-004 7150 Tecorida Ave. 0.38 SFR-Y LSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 031-062-022 7555 Atascadero Ave. 0.4 SFR-Y LSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 031-062-006 7505 Atascadero Ave. 0.61 SFR-Y LSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* Subtotal LSF-Y 16.29 42 42 Vacant Residential Parcels – RSF-X 030-413-008 8535 El Dorado Rd. 0.48 SFR-X RSF-X 1 unit 1 1.00* 030-413-009 8525 El Dorado Rd. 0.45 SFR-X RSF-X 1 unit 1 1.00* 030-413-014 5575 Santa Fe Rd. 0.3 SFR-X RSF-X 1 unit 1 1.00* 030-413-015 5525 Santa Fe Rd. 0.31 SFR-X RSF-X 1 unit 1 1.00* 030-413-017 8500 El Corte Rd. 0.29 SFR-X RSF-X 1 unit 1 1.00* 030-413-021 5545 Santa Fe Rd. 0.29 SFR-X RSF-X 1 unit 1 1.00* 030-413-022 5555 Santa Fe Rd. 0.2 SFR-X RSF-X 1 unit 1 1.00* 030-413-024 5515 Santa Fe Rd. 0.19 SFR-X RSF-X 1 unit 1 1.00* 030-413-025 8520 El Corte Rd. 0.17 SFR-X RSF-X 1 unit 1 1.00* 031-381-027 9495 Avenal Ave. 0.29 SFR-X RSF-X 1 unit 1 1.00* 049-033-051 3876 Orillas Way 0.52 SFR-X RSF-X 1 unit 1 1.00* 056-111-035 8755 Coromar Ave. 0.57 SFR-X RSF-X 1 unit 1 1.00* 056-121-005 8780 Coromar Ave. 0.97 SFR-X RSF-X 1 unit 1 1.00* 056-181-039 8585 Atascadero Ave. 1.3 SFR-X RSF-X 1 unit 1 1.00* 056-181-040 8587 Atascadero Ave. 1.17 SFR-X RSF-X 1 unit 1 1.00* 049-102-020 1826 El Camino Real 0.63 SFR-X SP-2/RSF-3 units 3 3 Specific Plan Public Review Draft Page 96 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element X approval 6 units max 049-102-035 1843 El Camino Real 1.17 SFR-X SP-2 / RSF-X 3 units 3 3 Specific Plan approval 6 units max Subtotal RSF-X 9.3 21 21 Vacant Residential Parcels – RSF-Y 028-021-004 4541 Sycamore Rd. 0.31 SFR-Y RSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 028-021-018 4755 Sycamore Rd. 0.24 SFR-Y RSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 028-021-021 4559 Sycamore Rd. 0.32 SFR-Y RSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 028-141-002 4070 Estrada Ave. 0.32 SFR-Y RSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 028-162-016 4660 Viscano Ave. 0.36 SFR-Y RSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 028-182-005 5670 San Pedro Ave. 0.32 SFR-Y RSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 028-261-022 4665 San Ardo Ave. 0.5 SFR-Y RSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 028-281-013 4250 Dolores Ave. 1.11 SFR-Y RSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 028-281-015 4815 El Verano Ave. 0.99 SFR-Y RSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 028-292-013 4675 Navidad Ave. 0.82 SFR-Y RSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 028-311-029 4945 Dulzura Ave. 0.69 SFR-Y RSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 028-311-037 5400 Rosario Ave. 0.46 SFR-Y RSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 028-311-038 5457 Bajada Ave. 1.16 SFR-Y RSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 028-322-001 5125 Rosario Ave. 0.37 SFR-Y RSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 028-322-036 5060 Alamo Ave. 0.15 SFR-Y RSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 028-331-006 5155 Rosario Ave. 0.37 SFR-Y RSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 028-332-001 5265 Barrenda Ave. 0.25 SFR-Y RSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 029-062-031 5360 Barrenda Ave 0.1 SFR-Y RSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 029-105-007 7140 Serena Ct. 2.71 SFR-Y RSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 029-105-023 7150 Serena Ct. 4.21 SFR-Y RSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 029-105-032 5495 Mercedes Ave. 0.42 SFR-Y RSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 029-105-035 7110 Serena Ct. 1.06 SFR-Y RSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 029-105-038 7130 Serena Ct. 1.23 SFR-Y RSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 029-121-008 5350 Maleza Ave. 0.97 SFR-Y RSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 029-131-002 5365 Maleza Ave. 0.58 SFR-Y RSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 029-131-033 7400 Castano Ave. 0.97 SFR-Y RSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 029-141-007 7470 Castano Ave. 0.38 SFR-Y RSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 029-142-031 9315 Curbaril Ave. 0.1 SFR-Y RSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 029-142-034 7470 Cortez Ave. 0.22 SFR-Y RSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 029-171-003 7350 Sonora Ave. 0.72 SFR-Y RSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 029-222-018 5660 Encima Ave. 0.92 SFR-Y RSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 029-371-031 7120 Valle Ave. 0.52 SFR-Y RSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 029-371-032 7128 Valle Ave. 0.57 SFR-Y RSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 030-031-009 9045 Curbaril Ave. 1.44 SFR-Y RSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 030-031-012 9065 Curbaril Ave. 1.71 SFR-Y RSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 030-041-006 9025 Curbaril Ave. 0.7 SFR-Y RSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 030-041-005 7521 Sombrilla Ave. 0.75 SFR-Y RSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 030-051-021 9017 Junipero Ave. 0.84 SFR-Y RSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 030-051-035 7950 Valle Ave. 0.92 SFR-Y RSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 030-061-055 8981 Junipero Ave. 1.04 SFR-Y RSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 030-071-062 8980 Junipero Ave. 0.69 SFR-Y RSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 030-111-024 9084 Palomar Ave. 1.89 SFR-Y RSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 030-381-001 9100 Palomar Ave. 3.26 SFR-Y RSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 030-422-010 8500 Pino Solo Ave. 0.68 SFR-Y RSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 030-441-025 9505 Vista Bonita Ave. 0.29 SFR-Y RSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 031-261-005 8475 San Francisco Ave. 0.55 SFR-Y RSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 031-261-023 8255 San Francisco Ave. 0.36 SFR-Y RSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 031-261-028 8215 San Francisco 0.39 SFR-Y RSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* Public Review Draft Page 97 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element Ave. 031-311-002 8655 Azucena Ave. 0.63 SFR-Y RSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 049-072-009 3430 Traffic Way 1.08 SFR-Y RSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 049-072-010 3450 Traffic Way 1.02 SFR-Y RSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 049-075-005 4550 San Anselmo Rd. 1.81 SFR-Y RSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 056-162-046 10300 West Front Rd. 1.01 SFR-Y RSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 056-162-047 10250 West Front Rd. 1.01 SFR-Y RSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 056-162-048 10200 West Front Rd. 1.01 SFR-Y RSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 056-171-043 8333 Atascadero Ave. 0.99 SFR-Y RSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 056-211-037 10085 Atascadero Ave. 3.03 SFR-Y RSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 056-211-038 10075 Atascadero Ave. 3.25 SFR-Y RSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 056-281-009 8705 Marchant Ave. 1.41 SFR-Y RSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* 056-312-007 9015 Lake View Dr. 0.18 SFR-Y RSF-Y 1 unit 1 1.00* Subtotal RSF-Y 56.36 60 60 Vacant Residential Parcels – RSF-Z 030-181-056 5525 Vega Ave. 1.47 SFR-Z RSF-Z 1 unit 1 1.00* 030-251-022 5205 Venado Ave. 1.42 SFR-Z RSF-Z 1 unit 1 1.00* 030-251-030 5055 Venado Ave. 0.84 SFR-Z RSF-Z 1 unit 1 1.00* 030-251-032 5105 Venado Ave. 2.82 SFR-Z RSF-Z 1 unit 1 1.00* 030-261-011 5650 Ardilla Ave. 0.73 SFR-Z RSF-Z 1 unit 1 1.00* 030-261-019 5350 Ardilla Rd. 1.05 SFR-Z RSF-Z 1 unit 1 1.00* 030-311-002 5105 Chauplin Ave. 2.68 SFR-Z RSF-Z 1 unit 1 1.00* 030-311-005 5305 Chauplin Ave. 1.36 SFR-Z RSF-Z 1 unit 1 1.00* 030-391-002 8525 El Corte Rd. 4.85 SFR-Z RSF-Z 1 unit 1 1.00* 030-441-002 9425 La Quinta Ct. 0.14 SFR-Z RSF-Z 1 unit 1 1.00* 030-441-003 9435 La Quinta Ct. 0.15 SFR-Z RSF-Z 1 unit 1 1.00* 030-441-004 9445 La Quinta Ct. 0.15 SFR-Z RSF-Z 1 unit 1 1.00* 030-441-005 9455 La Quinta Ct. 0.16 SFR-Z RSF-Z 1 unit 1 1.00* 030-441-006 9465 La Quinta Ct. 0.15 SFR-Z RSF-Z 1 unit 1 1.00* 030-441-007 9475 La Quinta Ct. 0.16 SFR-Z RSF-Z 1 unit 1 1.00* 030-441-008 9485 La Quinta Ct. 0.15 SFR-Z RSF-Z 1 unit 1 1.00* 030-441-009 9495 La Quinta Ct. 0.19 SFR-Z RSF-Z 1 unit 1 1.00* 030-441-016 9500 Vista Bonita Ave. 1 SFR-Z RSF-Z 1 unit 1 1.00* Telecommunications Site 030-441-024 9550 Vista Bonita Ave. 2.48 SFR-Z RSF-Z 1 unit 1 1.00* Telecommunications Site 030-441-026 9450 Vista Bonita Ave. 1.26 SFR-Z RSF-Z 1 unit 1 1.00* Telecommunications Site 031-091-008 5475 Encino Ave. 0.55 SFR-Z RSF-Z 1 unit 1 1.00* 031-091-009 5470 Chauplin Ave. 1.96 SFR-Z RSF-Z 1 unit 1 1.00* 031-092-016 5460 Encino Ave. 0.29 SFR-Z RSF-Z 1 unit 1 1.00* 031-101-003 5775 Encino Ave. 0.42 SFR-Z RSF-Z 1 unit 1 1.00* 031-101-006 5875 Encino Ave. 0.43 SFR-Z RSF-Z 1 unit 1 1.00* 031-101-011 5820 Chauplin Ave. 0.44 SFR-Z RSF-Z 1 unit 1 1.00* 031-102-017 5870 Encino Ave. 0.32 SFR-Z RSF-Z 1 unit 1 1.00* 031-103-001 6040 Navarette Ave. 2.77 SFR-Z RSF-Z 1 unit 1 1.00* 031-191-009 6370 Navarette Ave. 1.78 SFR-Z RSF-Z 1 unit 1 1.00* 031-192-017 6300 Navarette Ave. 7.22 SFR-Z RSF-Z 1 unit 1 1.00* 031-202-008 8250 San Marcos Rd. 1.6 SFR-Z RSF-Z 1 unit 1 1.00* 049-221-070 3975 Monterey Rd. 1.62 SFR-Z RSF-Z 1 unit 1 1.00* 054-012-041 3862 Ardilla Rd. 0.91 SFR-Z RSF-Z 1 unit 1 1.00* 054-013-025 3861 Ardilla Rd. 1.7 SFR-Z RSF-Z 1 unit 1 1.00* 054-014-004 3955 Maricopa Rd. 2.52 SFR-Z RSF-Z 1 unit 1 1.00* 054-014-005 3825 Maricopa Rd. 1.96 SFR-Z RSF-Z 1 unit 1 1.00* Public Review Draft Page 98 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element 054-051-013 9060 Ramage Ave. 2.62 SFR-Z RSF-Z 1 unit 1 1.00* 054-051-068 4590 Portola Rd. 1.56 SFR-Z RSF-Z 1 unit 1 1.00* 054-061-071 9190 Santa Lucia Rd. 2.42 SFR-Z RSF-Z 1 unit 1 1.00* 054-072-060 6500 Portola Rd. 1.3 SFR-Z RSF-Z 1 unit 1 1.00* 054-072-072 8680 San Marcos Rd. 1.48 SFR-Z RSF-Z 1 unit 1 1.00* 054-072-073 6760 Portola Rd. 1.11 SFR-Z RSF-Z 1 unit 1 1.00* 054-072-078 6150 Portola Rd. 3.85 SFR-Z RSF-Z 1 unit 1 1.00* 054-085-048 7300 Portola Rd. 0.88 SFR-Z RSF-Z 1 unit 1 1.00* 054-085-050 7470 Portola Rd. 0.74 SFR-Z RSF-Z 1 unit 1 1.00* Subtotal RSF-Z 65.66 45 45 Vacant Residential Parcels – RS 055-451-030 11650 Santa Lucia Rd. 9.56 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 049-041-009 5900 Santa Cruz Rd. 1.25 SE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 049-122-010 3375 Falda Rd. 1.98 SE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 049-112-005 4745 Del Rio Rd. 5.71 SE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 049-073-057 3675 La Luz Rd. 1.02 SE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 049-073-046 3625 La Luz Rd. 1.01 SE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 049-073-053 3305 La Luz Rd. 0.98 SE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 049-302-029 3070 Falda Rd. 1.48 SE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 049-152-031 3207 El Camino Real 0.89 SE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 049-152-039 5555 La Uva Ln. 1.55 SE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 028-131-004 7015 Sycamore Rd. 2.35 SE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 028-132-010 7270 Sycamore Rd. 0.94 SE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 028-132-035 7190 Sycamore Rd. 1.18 SE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 028-412-010 7725 Gabarda Rd. 1.53 SE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 028-412-012 7825 Gabarda Rd. 0.83 SE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 028-412-013 7875 Gabarda Rd. 2 SE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 028-412-014 7925 Gabarda Rd. 1.68 SE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 028-412-015 4355 Tampico Rd. 3.53 SE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 045-401-004 11975 Viejo Camino 4.16 SE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 056-481-008 8230 Los Osos Rd. 2.46 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 056-461-003 8330 San Diego Rd. 4.62 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 056-271-001 8985 San Rafael Rd. 25.88 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 050-312-015 14400 El Monte Rd. 4.42 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 050-312-017 14055 Santa Lucia Rd. 2.83 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 050-362-009 13055 Cencerro Rd. 4.45 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 050-362-006 10105 San Lucas Rd. 3.06 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 050-362-011 10355 San Lucas Rd. 4.9 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 050-361-008 10300 San Lucas Rd. 4.9 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 049-302-039 3300 Falda Rd. 0.83 SE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 045-371-006 11655 Atascadero Ave. 3 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 045-341-003 9140 San Diego Rd. 2.39 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 045-431-009 9128 San Diego Rd. 5.06 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 045-302-009 8910 Ortega Rd. 4.8 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 045-302-012 11140 Atascadero Rd. 0.25 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 045-451-004 9014 San Rafael Rd. 1.31 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 045-441-013 10529 Colorado Rd. 1.45 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 056-481-007 8199 San Dimas Rd. 2,27 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 056-391-001 8400 Toloso Rd. 41.02 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 2 lot subdivision potential 056-402-010 8255 San Diego Rd. 1.93 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 056-411-019 8250 Toloso Rd. 2.01 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 056-491-030 8305 Los Osos Rd. 2.49 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 054-231-007 9945 Old Morro Rd. 2.01 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* Public Review Draft Page 99 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element East 054-231-039 8200 San Rafael Rd. 1.56 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 056-451-002 10050 Old Morro Rd. East 4.46 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 054-151-056 8165 San Gabriel Rd. 3.87 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 050-042-002 2655 Alturas Rd. 5.13 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 049-271-002 2555 Alturas Rd. 6.86 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 054-201-044 10330 San Marcos Rd. 2.09 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 054-301-027 10410 San Marcos Rd. 3.39 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 054-301-019 10555 Escondido Rd. 4.32 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 054-121-026 6730 Los Gatos Rd. 4.05 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 056-371-005 8955 San Rafael Rd. 1.88 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 056-371-006 8965 San Rafael Rd. 1.99 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 054-151-036 8255 San Gabriel Rd. 2.53 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-361-013 13660 Palo Verde Rd. 22.61 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 3 lot subdivision potential 055-361-017 13680 Palo Verde Rd. 7.31 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-361-016 13640 Palo Verde Rd. 7.93 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-361-015 13620 Palo Verde Rd. 4.97 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-361-021 13730 Falcon Rd. 24 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 2 lot subdivision potential 055-361-019 13600 Palo Verde Rd. 6.13 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-361-009 13700 Falcon Rd. 8.48 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 050-362-005 14005 El Monte Rd. 3.88 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 050-312-013 13090 Cencerro Rd. 4.31 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 050-324-016 13000 Cencerro Rd. 2.73 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 050-182-006 14255 Santa Ana Rd. 5.43 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 050-172-003 9805 Corona Rd. 5.25 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 050-183-004 14400 Santa Ana Rd. 2.3 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 050-162-016 9605 Santa Cruz Rd. 1.96 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 050-162-021 13950 Santa Ana Rd. 5.68 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 050-161-004 9250 Santa Cruz Rd. 4.79 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 050-091-025 8900 San Gregorio Rd. #2 0.19 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 050-101-002 8875 San Gregorio Rd. 2.03 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 050-091-004 8800 San Gregorio Rd. 2.33 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 050-012-025 8200 San Gregorio Rd. 4.77 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 050-081-001 8550 Santa Cruz Rd. 2.9 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 049-321-020 8060 Santa Cruz Rd. 1.07 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 050-011-010 8050 Santa Cruz Rd. 2.39 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 049-182-017 1200 Garcia Rd. 4.04 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 049-182-004 955 Ropa Ct. 2.14 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 049-172-012 7425 Santa Cruz Rd. 3.78 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 049-172-013 7705 Santa Cruz Rd. 2.91 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 049-182-005 7270 San Gregorio Rd. 1.56 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-251-001 13780 Old Morro Rd. 1.16 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-243-001 13820 Old Morro Rd. 0.44 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-053-005 10655 San Marcos Rd. 2.63 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-053-001 10675 San Marcos Rd. 1.54 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 049-251-017 2340 Monterey Rd. 2.65 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* Public Review Draft Page 100 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element 049-092-044 1335 Garcia Rd. 6.29 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 049-181-013 7020 San Gregorio Rd. 0.9 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 049-181-012 1555 Garcia Rd. 0.6 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 049-181-010 1505 Garcia Rd. 1.15 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 049-092-041 1300 San Ramon Rd. 2.09 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 049-131-043 1855 San Ramon Rd. 1.5 SE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 049-131-052 6020 Del Rio Rd. 1.4 SE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 049-131-058 6010 Del Rio Rd. 8.46 SE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 049-131-066 1505 San Ramon Rd. 2.29 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 050-111-022 13350 Santa Ana Rd. 1.39 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 050-101-012 8365 Del Rio Rd. 7.88 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 050-111-023 13300 Santa Ana Rd. 5.19 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 050-111-020 8315 Del Rio Rd. 5.06 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 050-101-016 13600 Santa Ana Rd. 3.24 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 050-202-013 5800 Bolsa Rd. 5.11 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 050-242-012 7065 Llano Rd. 2.59 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-431-001 12405 Santa Lucia Rd. 3.13 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-431-011 12455 Santa Lucia Rd. 1.53 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-462-005 12503 Santa Lucia Rd. 1.22 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-462-006 12577 Santa Lucia Rd. 2.49 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-462-008 12645 Santa Lucia Rd. 1.05 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-462-012 12655 Santa Lucia Rd. 0.48 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-462-013 12675 Santa Lucia Rd. 0.51 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-462-002 12571 Santa Lucia Rd. 1.51 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-462-010 12579 Santa Lucia Rd. 1.01 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-431-004 11905 Santa Lucia Rd. 3.91 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-231-002 12125 San Marcos Rd. 5.06 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-231-018 11965 San Marcos Rd. 4.81 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-181-009 11950 San Marcos Rd. 4.36 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-181-008 12000 San Marcos Rd. 2.39 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-171-016 12250 San Marcos Rd. 1.98 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-171-004 12260 San Marcos Rd. 2.38 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-231-013 11805 San Marcos Rd. 2.84 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-181-022 11800 San Marcos Rd. 8.36 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-251-006 13750 Old Morro Rd. 3.11 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-331-005 12400 Old Morro Rd. 2.41 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-252-014 11085 San Marcos Rd. 5.19 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-242-010 13790 Morro Rd. 2.96 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* Public Review Draft Page 101 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element 055-252-016 13750 Morro Rd. 2.24 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-242-035 11255 San Marcos Rd. 4.86 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-242-034 11275 San Marcos Rd. 4.28 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-242-006 11285 San Marcos Rd. 1.85 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-191-003 11500 San Marcos Rd. 3.37 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-201-008 10900 San Marcos Rd. 3.84 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-201-002 10950 San Marcos Rd. 2.3 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-151-019 9450 Laurel Rd. 5.56 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-161-031 10890 Vista Rd. 3.04 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-161-032 10880 Vista Rd. 2.26 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-161-033 10870 Vista Rd. 2.84 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-161-036 10840 Vista Rd. 1.48 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-161-035 10850 Vista Rd. 1.45 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-161-038 10820 Vista Rd. 1.7 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-161-039 10810 Vista Rd. 1.59 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-161-040 10800 Vista Rd. 1.86 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-161-029 10910 Vista Rd. 11.8 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-261-004 13600 Morro Rd. 15.58 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-161-041 10930 Vista Rd. 7.8 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-161-024 10945 Vista Rd. 7.79 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-161-019 10825 Vista Rd. 1.74 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-052-010 10785 Vista Rd. 4.4 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-052-011 10775 Vista Rd. 6.01 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-161-020 10835 Vista Rd. 3.2 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-054-001 10645 Realito Ave. 5.43 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 054-311-042 10565 San Marcos Rd. 1.46 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 054-311-003 10475 San Marcos Rd. 2.44 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-102-006 8425 Sierra Vista Rd. 1.71 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-022-012 11505 Santa Lucia Rd. 2.08 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-041-013 10560 San Marcos Rd. 6.92 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-041-015 9610 Laurel Rd. 4.68 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-041-018 9710 Laurel Rd. 3.6 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 054-281-012 10800 Portal Rd. 2.6 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 054-281-001 9800 Laurel Rd. 21.68 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 2 underlying legal lots 054-181-019 10955 Santa Lucia Rd. 44.28 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 054-262-005 10735 Santa Lucia Rd. 7.99 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 054-201-013 6720 San Gabriel Rd. 0.52 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 054-201-037 10205 Escondido Rd. 4.74 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 054-322-012 10055 San Marcos Rd. 2.33 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 054-334-001 8760 Sierra Vista Rd. 1.33 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 054-331-013 8300 Casitas Rd. 1.33 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 054-331-005 8720 Sierra Vista Rd. 0.96 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 050-341-022 6750 Lomitas Rd. 2.01 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 050-341-006 6910 Lomitas Rd. 3.06 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* Public Review Draft Page 102 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element 055-442-004 6250 Lomitas Rd. 3.91 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-451-006 11400 Santa Lucia Rd. 16.43 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-451-011 6170 Llano Rd. 11.1 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-451-033 6805 Lomitas Rd. 3.36 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-451-018 6525 Lomitas Rd. 3.08 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-451-020 7200 Nudoso Rd. 3.03 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-451-019 6435 Lomitas Rd. 3.07 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 050-122-017 9415 Balboa Rd. 4.11 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 050-122-005 12705 Santa Ana Rd. 3.51 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 050-251-022 6805 Llano Rd. 4.74 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 050-251-012 9700 Corriente Rd. 7.86 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 050-041-011 8005 Balboa Rd. 4.12 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 050-121-020 2460 San Fernando Rd. 3.19 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 050-121-013 8315 Balboa Rd. 2.22 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 050-121-002 12600 Santa Ana Rd. 1.02 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 050-121-007 12750 Santa Ana Rd. 2.46 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 050-043-002 8505 Balboa Rd. 4.9 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 050-211-001 12350 Santa Ana Rd. 0.92 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 050-121-017 12400 Santa Ana Rd. 0.83 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 050-262-021 9405 Corriente Rd. 4.07 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 050-262-013 9800 Serrijon Rd. 8.49 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 050-262-001 9900 Serrijon Rd. 7.29 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 050-281-006 10005 Serrijon Rd. 4.62 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 050-281-007 10150 Serrijon Rd. 6.97 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 050-281-008 10750 Serrijon Rd. 8.56 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 054-251-003 5400 Telocote Rd. 9.76 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 050-291-001 10300 Serrijon Rd. 2.07 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 050-291-002 10260 Serrijon Rd. 0.97 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 050-291-008 10220 Serrijon Rd. 2.83 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 050-291-009 10200 Serrijon Rd. 6.03 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 050-291-004 10100 Serrijon Rd. 7.25 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 050-291-005 9950 Serrijon Rd. 7.27 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 050-291-010 6255 Llano Rd. 36.9 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 6 lot subdivision potential 054-251-002 5755 Llano Rd. 30.1 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 7 lot subdivision potential 054-171-034 10400 Serrijon Rd. 44.31 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 050-231-005 3130 San Fernando Rd. 2.92 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 049-142-009 6075 Conejo Rd. 2.1 SE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 049-191-004 6079 Del Rio Rd. 0.33 SE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 054-171-033 9950 Santa Ana Rd. 1.19 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 054-121-032 6653 San Gabriel Rd. 4.66 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 054-121-042 6545 San Gabriel Rd. 3.84 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 054-121-004 6150 Los Gatos Rd. 0.86 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 049-281-005 2145 San Fernando Rd. 1.95 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 050-051-001 2155 San Fernando Rd. 7.47 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 050-141-004 7275 Balboa Rd. 4.7 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 050-153-009 8105 Graves Creek Rd. 0.89 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 054-131-011 9300 San Marcos Rd. 2.12 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 054-131-003 6755 San Gabriel Rd. 7.54 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 054-122-013 6199 Los Gatos Rd. 0.3 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* Public Review Draft Page 103 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element 054-142-012 9330 Carmelita Ave. 1.85 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 054-132-071 9735 San Marcos Rd. 3.92 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 054-132-066 7980 Bella Vista Rd. 1.6 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 054-086-013 7470 Bella Vista Rd. 2.04 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 054-086-005 7110 Bella Vista Rd. 0.94 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 054-132-014 8697 San Marcos Rd. 2.9 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 049-211-038 2945 Ramona Rd. 4.09 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 054-043-012 3695 Ardilla Rd. 0.73 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 054-043-011 3685 Ardilla Rd. 1.36 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 054-043-023 3720 Maricopa Rd. 4.9 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 054-043-006 3625 Ardilla Rd. 5.81 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 054-043-013 3715 Ardilla Rd. 0.62 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 054-043-018 3761 Ardilla Rd. 1.02 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 054-051-044 3640 Ardilla Rd. 2.6 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 054-091-009 3660 Ardilla Rd. 3.53 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 054-061-012 9360 Santa Lucia Rd. 7.83 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-116-013 12610 San Marcos Rd. 5.77 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-115-015 12550 San Marcos Rd. 7.37 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-115-010 12575 San Marcos Rd. 6.78 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-116-003 12649 San Marcos Rd. 2.54 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-114-017 12680 Cabazon Rd. 2.78 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-115-005 12708 San Marcos Ct. 2.53 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-116-012 12620 San Marcos Rd. 2.03 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-116-020 12430 Madrone Rd. 3.41 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-114-023 12607 Cabazon Rd. 7.41 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-116-017 12450 Madrone Rd. 3.86 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-116-011 12612 San Marcos Rd. 4.07 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-114-015 12630 Cabazon Rd. 4.22 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-114-027 12616 Cabazon Rd. 3.39 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-114-014 12628 Cabazon Rd. 6.82 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-115-012 12412 Pecos Ct. 3.08 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-115-011 12610 Cenegal Rd. 3.82 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-114-003 12605 Cenegal Rd. 3.42 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-114-002 12635 Cenegal Rd. 5.28 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-115-007 12485 San Marcos Rd. 3.53 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-116-010 12630 San Marcos Rd. 7.81 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-116-002 12625 San Marcos Rd. 2.68 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-115-023 12420 San Marcos Rd. 2.17 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-114-012 12624 Cabazon Rd. 2.63 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-114-016 12660 Cabazon Rd. 3.63 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 050-173-027 13705 Santa Ana Rd. 5.7 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 050-301-002 14600 Santa Lucia Rd. 27.2 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 4 lot subdivision potential 050-203-002 9675 Otero Rd. 4.63 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 050-241-006 10025 Corona Rd. 4.7 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 050-241-007 10075 Corona Rd. 5.48 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 050-241-010 10200 Corona Rd. 7.16 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* Public Review Draft Page 104 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element 050-201-006 5700 Bolsa Rd. 6.48 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 050-201-007 5600 Bolsa Rd. 6.73 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 050-242-016 5500 Bolsa Rd. 7.32 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 050-192-018 10100 Corona Rd. 4.44 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 050-192-015 10000 Corona Rd. 5.99 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 054-192-008 6445 Alta Pradera Ln. 2.58 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 054-192-006 6425 Alta Pradera Ln. 2.84 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 054-192-021 6452 Alta Pradera Ln. 6.36 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 054-192-002 6305 Alta Pradera Ln. 5.39 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 054-014-005 3825 Maricopa Rd. 4.75 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 028-411-027 9552 Curbaril Ave. 0.3 SE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 054-191-045 6780 San Gabriel Rd. 4.84 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 054-291-022 10620 Portal Rd. 2.87 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 054-192-030 10480 Portal Rd. 4.19 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 049-151-062 2555 El Camino Real 2.24 SE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-341-008 13410 Palo Verde Rd. 0.96 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 056-411-026 10125 Old Morro Rd. East 1.67 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 056-261-013 8925 San Gabriel Rd. 9.97 RE RS 2 units 2 2.0* 2 underlying legal parcels, 8 parcel subdivision potential 054-111-053 9775 Santa Lucia Rd. 2.52 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 054-111-052 9845 Santa Lucia Rd. 2.43 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-311-021 43 Palo Verde Rd. #PR43 0.45 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-113-014 12719 San Felipe Ct. 2.78 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-116-021 12410 Madrone Rd. 3.38 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-115-006 12475 San Marcos Rd. 3.65 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-116-014 12600 San Marcos Rd. 5.82 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-113-006 12715 Escabroso Ct. 6.7 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-114-013 12620 Cabazon Rd. 5.36 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-113-011 12721 San Felipe Ct. 5.01 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-114-022 12617 Cabazon Rd. 3.78 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-116-005 12655 San Marcos Rd. 4.45 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-115-008 12515 San Marcos Rd. 10.46 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-114-025 12612 Cabazon Rd. 2.97 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-115-022 12440 San Marcos Rd. 2.07 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-113-015 12723 San Felipe Ct. 3.35 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-115-014 12419 Pecos Ct. 3.68 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-116-007 12648 San Marcos Rd. 6.7 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-114-026 12614 Cabazon Rd. 7.01 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-113-017 12720 San Felipe Ct. 1.75 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-116-018 12434 Madrone Rd. 4.45 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-114-006 12601 Cenegal Rd. 4.41 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-115-017 12640 Cenegal Rd. 4.41 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-114-028 12604 Cabazon Rd. 4.78 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-114-004 12362 Puente Rd. 2.8 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 045-353-011 9137 San Diego Rd. 2.76 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 045-353-010 9135 San Diego Rd. 2.76 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 045-353-012 9139 San Diego Rd. 2.75 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 045-353-013 9141 San Diego Rd. 2.5 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* Public Review Draft Page 105 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element 045-353-022 9110 San Rafael Rd. 2.53 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 045-353-021 9120 San Rafael Rd. 2.65 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 054-192-032 10470 Portal Rd. 3.97 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 054-192-033 10460 Portal Rd. 3.96 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 054-032-069 3425 Maricopa Rd. 2.71 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-115-009 12555 San Marcos Rd. 9.97 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-114-010 12325 Puente Rd. 3.64 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-116-006 12650 San Marcos Rd. 3.43 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-114-001 12655 Cenegal Rd. 4.62 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-113-024 12300 San Marcos Rd. 2.7 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-116-008 12644 S San Marcos Rd. 4.93 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-115-020 12500 San Marcos Rd. 4.88 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-114-007 12342 Puente Rd. 4.61 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-116-009 12640 San Marcos Rd. 4.09 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-115-016 12415 Pecos Ct. 4.9 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-114-008 12346 Puente Rd. 4.77 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-114-009 12335 Puente Rd. 3.98 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-116-016 12470 Madrone Rd. 3.51 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-113-019 12708 San Felipe Ct. 1.57 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-115-021 12460 San Marcos Rd. 3.04 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-115-013 12416 Pecos Ct. 5.35 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-115-018 12650 Cenegal Rd. 2.53 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-116-019 12436 Madrone Rd. 4.21 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-113-012 12701 San Felipe Ct. 1.52 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-113-018 12712 San Felipe Ct. 1.67 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 045-302-011 11170 Atascadero Ave. 0.25 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 045-353-023 9080 San Rafael Rd. 13.99 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 045-441-021 10765 Colorado Rd. 0.49 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 045-441-025 10825 Colorado R. 1.03 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 045-441-034 9056 San Rafael R. 4.04 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 049-102-058 5255 Carrizo Rd. 2.66 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 049-122-028 3050 Arena Rd. 1.48 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 049-271-024 2027 Alturas Rd. 2.41 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 049-281-016 2139 San Fernando Rd. 3.24 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 050-021-037 9030 La Canada Ln. 4.43 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 050-131-032 7705 Balboa Rd. 3.18 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 050-131-033 7805 Balboa Rd. 2.77 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 054-032-072 3556 Maricopa Rd. 1.84 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 054-091-026 5255 Cascabel Rd. 4.43 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 054-092-026 5150 Cascabel Rd. 2.58 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 054-191-042 6730 San Gabriel Rd. 3.64 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-113-002 12726 Rojo Ct. 2.42 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-113-013 12717 San Felipe Ct. 1.5 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-113-016 12722 San Felipe Ct. 3.82 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-114-005 12382 Puente Rd. 3.92 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-114-011 12618 Cabazon Rd. 3.64 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-114-021 12621 Cabazon Rd. 4.51 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-114-024 12600 Cabazon Rd. 3.96 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* Public Review Draft Page 106 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element 055-115-001 12707 San Marcos Ct. 2.13 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-115-002 12711 San Marcos Ct. 2.47 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-115-003 12713 San Marcos Ct. 2.06 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-115-004 12714 San Marcos Ct. 3.24 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-116-004 12657 San Marcos Rd. 8.13 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-116-015 12490 Madrone Rd. 3.39 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-161-044 10458 Morro Rd. 15.2 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 055-341-009 13025 Old Morro Rd. 3.86 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 056-371-045 8875 San Rafael Rd. 5.34 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 056-371-046 8895 San Rafael Rd. 6.16 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 056-371-047 8905 San Rafael Rd. 5.01 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* 056-371-048 8935 San Rafael Rd. 3.25 RE RS 1 unit 1 1.00* Subtotal RS 1,651.87 372 372 Vacant Mixed-Use Parcels 8725 Arcade 0.7 GC CR 16 units/acre 11.2 9 6600, 6780 Morro Road 1.5 GC CP 16 units/acre 24 19 6955 Morro, 7955 San Andres 1.2 GC CP 16 units/acre 19.2 15 7205 Morro, 7105 Atascadero Ave. 0.92 GC CP/CR 16 units/acre 14.72 11 7100 Morro 0.41 GC CP 16 units/acre 6.56 5 7200, 7250 Morro 0.5 GC CP 16 units/acre 8 6 7475 Morro 0.71 GC CP 16 units/acre 11.36 9 7575 Morro 0.76 GC CP 16 units/acre 12.16 9 7900 Morro 0.86 GC CP 16 units/acre 13.76 11 Subtotal CP 7.56 120.96 94 Vacant Downtown Mixed-Use Parcels 029-322-012 5802 Traffic Way 0.39 D DC 20 units/acre 7.8 6 Slope 030-181-055 5730 El Camino Real 0.18 D DC 20 units/acre 3.6 2 029-344-029 5930 West Mall 0.09 D DC 20 units/acre 1.8 1 029-347-031 5901 A East Mall 0.11 D DC 20 units/acre 2.2 1 029-347-030 5901 B East Mall 0.06 D DC 20 units/acre 1.2 1 029-361-018 6905 El Camino Real 5.28 D DC 20 units/acre 105.6 84 Master Plan of Development Approved. Subtotal DC 6.12 122.2 95 TOTAL 1856.75 1681.95 1,353 *Single Family Parcels are not calculated at 80% of maximum density as the maximum is established per parcel rather than per acre. **Reduced densities based on slope. Public Review Draft Page 107 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B City of Atascadero General Plan Housing Element Appendix II Figure V-2. Vacant Land Inventory Map Public Review Draft Page 108 July 19, 2014 City of Atascadero Resolution No. 2015-007 Exhibit B