Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutPC_2021-06-01_Minutesr r..: CITY OF ATASCADERO PLANNING COMMISSION MINUTES Regular Meeting — Tuesday, June 1, 2021 — 6:00 P.M. City Hall (Teleconference) 6500 Palma Avenue, Atascadero, California CALL TO ORDER - 6:00 p.m. Chairperson van den Eikhof called the meeting to order at 6:02 p.m. and Commissioner Schmidt led the Pledge of Allegiance. ROLL CALL Present: By Teleconference - Commissioners Anderson, Carranza, Schmidt, Vice Chairperson Keen and Chairperson van den Eikhof Absent: Commissioner Randy Hughes (excused absence) Commissioner Jennifer McIntyre (excused absence) Vacant: None Others Present: By Teleconference - Recording Secretary, Annette Manier Staff Present: By Teleconference — Community Development Director, Phil Dunsmore Deputy Director of Economic and Community Development, Loreli Cappel Senior Planner, Kelly Gleason Assistant Planner, Mariah Gasch APPROVAL OF AGENDA MOTION: By Commissioner Schmidt and seconded by Vice Chairperson Keen to approve the Agenda. Motion passed 5:0 by a roll -call vote. PUBLIC COMMENT None Chairperson van den Eikhof closed the Public Comment period. PC Minutes of 6/1/2021 Page 1 of 3 CONSENT CALENDAR 1. APPROVE THE DRAFT MINUTES OF MAY 18, 2021 ■ Recommendation: Commission approve the May 18, 2021, Minutes. MOTION: By Commissioner by Commissioner Consent Calendar. Anderson and seconded Carranza to approve the Motion passed 5:0 by a roll -call vote. PLANNING COMMISSION BUSINESS None. COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT STAFF REPORTS None. PUBLIC HEARINGS 2. AMENDMENT TO DEL RIO ROAD COMMERCIAL AREA SPECIFIC PLAN The proposed project is located at the South East corner of Del Rio Road and EI Camino Real and includes retail/commercial/mixed-use buildings, a conference building, outdoor amphitheater, RV lodging site, hotel and relocation and expansion of the residentially -zoned portion of the site. The project is consistent with the previously certified EIR and subsequent addendums completed for the Del Rio Road Commercial Area Specific Plan. Ex Parte Communications: Recommendation: Recommend the project move forward to the City Council for approval. (AMND21-0020 EX PARTE COMMUNICATIONS Commissioner Schmidt heard this item at the Design Review Committee and read the letters sent prior to the meeting. Chairperson van den Eikhof heard this item at the Design Review Committee. Planner Gleason presented the staff report, and she and Director Dunsmore answered questions from the Commission. PUBLIC COMMENT The following members of the public spoke: Ted Lawton (who presented Exhibit A), Jeni Kim, Jack Phelan, Mike Mancack, and Wade Kelley. The following emails were read into the record by Recording Secretary Manier: Brian Gordon Kennelly (Exhibit B) Scott Huffman (Exhibit C) PC Minutes of 6/1/2021 Page 2 of 3 Chairperson van den Eikhof closed the Public Comment period. MOTION: By Commissioner Schmidt and seconded by Commissioner Anderson to adopt PC Draft Resolution recommending the City Council approve General Plan Amendments, Specific Plan Amendments, a Zoning Map Amendment, Concept Master Plan of Development, and Conditional Use Permit for the Del Rio Ranch project, based on findings and subject to conditions of approval, and is recommending that the City Council work on trying to provide temporary use as discussed. Motion passed 5:0 by a roll -call vote. COMMISSIONER COMMENTS AND REPORTS None DIRECTOR'S REPORT Director Dunsmore stated that the next meeting may be cancelled because there are no items ready for that date. Director Dunsmore introduced Loreli Cappel, the City's new Deputy Director of Economic Development. Director Dunsmore and Deputy Director Cappel answered questions in regards to future projects, especially around Sunken Gardens. ADJOURNMENT — 8:07 p.m. The next regular meeting is scheduled for June 15, 2021, at City Hall, Council Chambers, 6500 Palma Avenue, Atascadero. MINUTES PREPARED BY: Annette Manier, Recording Secretary Administrative Assistant Adopted July 20, 2021 The following Exhibits are available in the Community Development Department: Exhibit A — Presentation by Cal Coastal Communities Exhibit B — Email from Brian Gordon Kennelly Exhibit C — Email from Scott Huffman PC Minutes of 6/1/2021 Page 3 of 3 x .I m o N 00 O co n rn 114 '1e= Lr)oo Iq O �o two - m o N 00 O co n rn 114 Lr)oo Iq O �o I m o N 00 O co n rn Lr)oo Iq O �o Z O Y O o 40 J �ti t t V z a J W L � c 0 its �E 00 �o co 0 tS5 U c Q Co VV'i Ll L C CO 0 v 47 0 0 0 V V v tz o �.o U Lu Ln 0 to co 06 n C O Oft 0 W a w v L Co c� x v b' L Z g s MAO V cl CI r --q u m �■ 1 ,rock ��ps�llr,• .6w 4, 0 11tp�I jW� Aw -H -H -H - LO ., 0)(DCvw toj Itt co tit I%- Sf� MC. mt,� 0) CL Pool 3 0 f4p I. tt v 0 t' LY. �# 1 9 cr ... 0 17 WY i S CL 02 CL y hr� W� I CL W tm 1 C"3 C • Oji` ,. ,rock ��ps�llr,• .6w 4, 0 11tp�I jW� Aw -H -H -H - LO ., 0)(DCvw toj Itt co tit I%- Sf� MC. mt,� 0) CL Pool 3 0 f4p I. tt v 0 t' LY. �# 1 9 Ll L O 4.1 N r- m {A ILA CA d �� E •�+I ai O ov �, L D O U. O i w w +I 3 0 M +I 00-0 R* r j W' C M N +I Ab =4 fi NO ir -L rmlL- iALAW! 'vp Z =4 fi NO ir -L rmlL- iALAW! M 'vp M a L E 3 O L 4J V L E O 4a C. L 47 X W m E N bb >, o � •� � � � o � ani � � � � o •� � U � � a ` cd U a. vUi O Q, cd� v c i "3 a C cd bz CZI cn bn to bO Ln c ZZ Cd cd co In p Cd G 4-� �, U U -� +� cn U 1,3 to cd O U O _ b-0 40. cd sZ..cd -PI-I 00csgz o cd TIA U O U � 0 cn- 0 - u �; � cC > r. C O CZ O p U U cn n CZ, Cd to cd a bh cd Ici cd cd N C cn Q En U cd rZ m`-' O O p '� O O O U p U a Q cd cd bA Q - s. U = cd, En ' 7:1 cn 00 O O U O `! O O = M� 0� Cd �� C bA bA O'dCd lz� "� U • ., "o �" v C/1 cd iia cd O cd O O vUi C/� bA m cn 3 L O L- CL a V i E E V 1 V z Q oc �1 L•J J W X 1 SAF+ O L Q v UC6 N U m N Q a—' a L O O OCL N : cn i Q c O cn > N a c/1 cn 4-J N > 'U aJ cz U 73 Ln CU o4-j o 4 cu V) }' C6 0 �O U O Q� N N Q Q Z a.) N a) Q `+- Z) v 4J O _ Nd1 V) O V) v v Ll-- o > o CL E }' aA °N' L+. -N 0 ro 0 v o w+� s -0C o 4— E� m ° Ln .> +, O o o ,� Ln w Ln C 4 O Q) L ate-+ O N 1 N O U O L E o N `^ CL) u � > > � o �avo-a0 L7 LL. U Q cn E 1 I 1 I 1 I I I SAF+ c m : b.0 ca cu a U .O i CL .on. J W 0 N U � O Q E E g +w.+ C10 � O U N � ca E J � C6 O N U f]A Q Q) N w m � _ L a mE mE O v � U Q v) E J O 0- Z5 N C7 m E s v -W CL l ._ c O m D U i U i (1) O ;L' 4- N 4- 0 0 v L D a--+ V v 4.1 E Q � O o v Q v v � a-' n.o +� O v 0� (1) tw ca v 4-J O i 4 Q) > (AE o a > CL . aj a V z 0 �c J W 4i6 to QJ o V) +J a--+ Qj Etw � Q •}, pp o v Z5a--+ a.,., a- J CU U > $� i QJ (n Q) Q) i—J O Q} 7!'' .x m � � Q Q 0 Ln U 0 }' 07 fZ a -J QJ W J (� i tLp Ln p— - U U QJ Q N +� QJ QJQj c`n6 a V) Z a w +, Ln L U p U d w� _ Ali A 0 m Ll m H O O(u d o6 y w w N m h0 Y 2 O w 4-1 o Y j I. U _ CL U Ln m w a w w w n. ii Q a I •, � � �Fp i't I 1 J # ♦ 1 + i # r♦ e r b ! b e r t s r♦ /� r♦ /f� is 4 s fi • �#ia� f// / R r� f s i f 4 � /�,� `•fl 7 ♦♦♦ ♦♦,♦` Y �/r 1. +f `� � -`+� �``• '^ ! 4 ♦ ? f F ♦ ! t 'fi • 4 "ti / a j♦ }f J 8 'SSS Y � I ^� i ♦f b + s ! \ � t JJ 777 ,� �+r ♦ e r a � 1 b } +(}+Y +tea r• t i t �J[ ' l ■■1irL •• r f f f ♦ t li♦k •♦JJI f�F—✓Jl+l ♦ fi #♦sJfJf♦1}tf.ibJf Jfaf k#f`fy�}lf +i `f i} ♦ i�� ♦ i+'��'1 a Y a A rf f + 1•F�rr4ile.t�ii� .�.1,.•y.W 4 �I! r • a i : ! a . a a f # /// `� 7f '�, ♦ i � I 018 -13C3 `--�--�_ � N L V _ L t V U E CubC N U O O W U c N H O O(u d o6 y w w N m h0 Y 2 O w 4-1 o Y j I. U _ CL U Ln m w a w w w n. ii Q a I •, � � �Fp i't I 1 J # ♦ 1 + i # r♦ e r b ! b e r t s r♦ /� r♦ /f� is 4 s fi • �#ia� f// / R r� f s i f 4 � /�,� `•fl 7 ♦♦♦ ♦♦,♦` Y �/r 1. +f `� � -`+� �``• '^ ! 4 ♦ ? f F ♦ ! t 'fi • 4 "ti / a j♦ }f J 8 'SSS Y � I ^� i ♦f b + s ! \ � t JJ 777 ,� �+r ♦ e r a � 1 b } +(}+Y +tea r• t i t �J[ ' l ■■1irL •• r f f f ♦ t li♦k •♦JJI f�F—✓Jl+l ♦ fi #♦sJfJf♦1}tf.ibJf Jfaf k#f`fy�}lf +i `f i} ♦ i�� ♦ i+'��'1 a Y a A rf f + 1•F�rr4ile.t�ii� .�.1,.•y.W 4 �I! r • a i : ! a . a a f # /// `� 7f '�, ♦ i � I 018 -13C3 `--�--�_ V0 i . i 4 A; W-1 C J r-7 go Ji QQy EL ppk L -E 21, II Ifi�lii moi.. sELL -i fir II Ifi�lii moi.. sELL W m O L_ U_ �V i N E E V 1 m Z Q O E cc E J -0 W a R� 1 STAN.— , I. L& un " .1 .. r law .� s';w NJ i J W >' O +1 +_' Q +—� O � cB tvo 0 �_ V 4c: L (D O U r O m c i = m V v i dA >• ._ N is3 •L L H O c > E +� 'L. a, m ++ V C7 o 0 a o i O 0 H OC •� N Q v� Q M O t m ~ LGAO LJ d�0 •� _ O C ++ vOi L u r_ —ao O = 40- c o 0 u `1� ti r 5P W V Z 0 Ji W •N s U N � � 4, C:v � a7 O 4=r Vf N t1,0 C: O U .� Ov N O cr- > (1) co O CL rB O O -Q N LLO O +� v W < U J O v dJ Q Q = V > >- CU � W10 _ O cr W Co N 41 N N N w CUO N = +, 4- LL v p 0 0 oac a,z 4 0 > Cov V . -0 a� a7 y 3 0 � L N ,y U Cov w E �( •� Vf 'i W GJ i GC L W U '� � u O 0 w cc dA , W0 U U LL m IJ5 Q O F- bbo bio ba c 2 41 =3 T C N O a m _ E tw m + v cn > m i o c c O > Q m 47 1.4 N lY I Q -r Al �a �r � •''`�� •err �:;. t � a ��,`�`�;':,'� � s t .� - l� I r 'ti• , � P T�t� ��.. -r Al �a �r Fri 4'® V m I I i. Ln N� V z 0 J W a V z OC W-. ��J ,J s r � s r AL ra�, d air 00 %ft.wo Ul E 0 M oc t)LO 40 oc 4-J LLI CL m I k�w. 09 N Q.1 CB In Q) > Qtb Q m H i u 4 OQ) s O E V) > [� `~ O U 4' 4, Q U v tb O U C Ln Ln 0a M E 5 Oo GJ O ca o + -= + _� c� 0 L U ._ 09 n OC J W 0 v Q) U u o L v F- <— a� �o�_ o U = O Ln o = a, ii a 4.1. 8-0 W 0 m te. Li iso it Id Li it Id V Z d DC 2 cc .jW 0 i I a .I 4 r y v ew - v � � U 4� O .� — O — Q � L O Q1 4' O �^ Q) U Y 41 U fB V ° O O Q o X O O w E n O n LnO o O v o - Q) O �- a v E V v E Q) Ln taA _ruu L U a �0> c U co O +' +-C: X W U x Z5 J O Z W X o � — Q Z 0 m r y J W 0 r un ate+ M > O — oo o v Q L) OU unf6 i U N p Cl) QJCDQJ a } Q) L � � Q) p cn cn O � p p U ca p � L CL) 0 (B Ln Xp O V LE o C ano Q Z o2S = +, v o � C6 U V O -0 N U O Qi E a ' 4-1 - v N V Q r- > o E+; °J Q c 0 E tab r V Z Q 0 w J W 0 V z CC 0 oc J W 0 a _ _ V Z Q VRA J W O r-1 O O Ol i G1 a O a .E O a O U W E tw r_ O J i 4 - Ln OI Ca 4- L _z U O CB V Q � O O v > O z3 /� � Q) o }' /fit / /vRTS V � L o o > a O � •— vi V O fB U U Q) N C: ro f6 0- O Q) U N Q) a-1 Q) Q) ro Ln Q) E C6 U ++ U 4 Q N Ln Ln N O- N ca Q) > i .� Ln :3 ® ru O > i C: CU v +� m a, o Q1 o V c M +ted U U V p > Q O 4— Q) V Ln QJ m E m =-s— o'W � E��mN� do ru V� ��� =N _ 0 0 w O �� QJ O 4 Lu Fu c E 0 � � 4- o '�� a) U Ln t c O O +�� -0-� O-0 O +- 4 Q) E L U _= = m O M N Q) Q) � O f6 Q) O Qo +m' = +m- O o " v O � } E — o Q o ai m ru X Z X = U m V -0 u_ u_ w (.no � -0 Lu +� v i cB qA iJ 0 4-J ^� 0 W � E E 0 U � v o L U r� L � N s }' Y O Ln � U 0 Y .4- U -U N s Q) 0 tL0 � N L _0 U L- W 0 U L a1 Q r OO L Y O E ^ (O (6 O N U • i O Oaj O E N Y a— [O U U C OCL u a) N c`�Lo N O a) O *' V1 t6 a C f0 U O C O Q)o 0 -C z Q co c 3 L a� o E cu Y I--cCL o OL C) Q) CO v Q .— O T U Q u Y i = cc u > Y > co N C O a) +' O O Q C o E > u ~ n3 � —_ Q o fl Y o v a " c o O p O fa = Y .cD a) (C6 N C U OQ •Q O O N 3 s M a) 775 E Y > O v v v E '� N u L aa) C Q O a) ca cn = o w L N o v v v) O CL N Q) 4- Ln ru m Q- Y C Q) N CO N N N 7 (6 O O Y 0 S (D w n3 N f0 > N tYn LY +�, L f6 0 3 N S v +� c `^ o on Q o u Q > L N•Y > • C p u 'F w c O ca c ro -1O 0 to ti.o C v O U L U Q W Ou 'Q O > OL O �-- u O > _ w O O a) O Q _ = OA Q N Q 3:cr Y a) .. cB @ O C E O O N� W w O Q N S_ N a"' N a N d tB Q C Q 0 j L Y CL N a) Y -6 ' N C Q L ^, W O 0 > L p N v) E a) N i= +' � bA L Q U p �O L '- Q C E O a) a) Y = c6 w r4 m L N a'' N O cNa C _0 C v- Q O a) "a O m O N N C N- M O Q Cua) O {Nn > a) •� L 3 N N u N C N O .- ca > m _ 'i ca Y L Y C N C O O A\ m 0) L L L o y Y C O Q (p a1 u Va � T a) a) Q �' U v o oA D 'a E v Y L v o ar' m w E 0 aa) v E '� o pa 0 3 _ O n3 = _ — '� v O i 2 ID pQ n3 Y 6 N _ 3 @ _ C Q O 0) Q O coV L O 0 Q Q CL a% 0-0 = L V N �_ ca O L C Q E - E a) . L= N v N >- a) 3 a°°E Y Q u YO o 5 m Q) Q� o O— o N C a) > Z m a) 0, 70 > 13) o O o z N a) LD O Y cr U Q Y Y= ' .0 E a) tO Q)ro N N O- o a) a) _ () p a C a) N N O L i WO O N N cn C N L. O > a) O N bA O O p YO CL Y sz vLO r�Co O7i CL Q CL Y v a� Q a) a) h -a '3 u > o� a ns .L o a .� O a) — 3 v �_ Q N v u u Q ro ss `^ •N +� Q _� -O O C hA fl- aY' N co O p% O L 2� n3 p J O C a) ', v c4 a) cu u —Y c6 _ aJ O O O O W Y U Y N = !n Q < Q Q N Q I Z Q 'O — ❑ C CL -U a) O� U Q m I- r -i N M � l0 n 00 m -1-1 v i cB qA iJ 0 4-J ^� 0 W � E E 0 U � v o L U r� L � N s }' Y O Ln � U 0 Y .4- U -U N s Q) 0 tL0 � N L _0 U L- W N W V L N cu E C6 � M Ol U V �^ v � 0 0 Q °y, CCN C6 a O7 0 O J � W o Lo O1 00 I LEM, 0 Exhibit 6 PC Meeting of 6/1/2021 From: Brian Gordon Kennelly Sent: Tuesday, June 1, 2021 10:50 AM To: Planning Commission Public Comments Cc: Brian Gordon Kennelly Subject: Del Rio Ranch (amphitheater) I would like to learn more about how sound mitigation is being thought through for the proposed amphitheater and what the schedule of operation might be. As a resident whose property is a couple of blocks away from the proposed site, I am concerned that this may impact my right to quiet enjoyment. Given that noise pollution from sports events at Templeton High School already drifts to my neighborhood and that Templeton High School is more than one mile away, the potential negative impact of this amphitheater concerns me. Brian G. Kennelly I Professor of French http://sites.p,00gle.com/view/briangkennelly JUN 1 2U21 Freedom of expression matters LCOMM17UMINTTY ;I—doSAL POLY pEVELOP MENT World Languages & Cultures�C COLLEGE OF LIBERAL ARTS j7 . ATTENTION: This email originated from outside the City's network. Use caution when opening links and attachments. Exhibit C PC Meeting of 6/1/2021 From: Scott Huffman Sent: Tuesday, June 1, 2021 3:51 PM To: Planning Commission Public Comments Cc: Kasara Mena Subject: Del Rio Ranch PC Hearing June 1, 2021 Dear Chairperson van den Eikhof, Vice Chairperson Keen and Commissioners: We own and manage the Mission Oaks Plaza shopping center directly across the street from this project. We have reviewed the proposed design concepts and would like provide the following comments: 1. Calibration of the phasing will be essential to the success of the project and we recommend the City mandate the amount of each product type that can be developed before other portions must commence construction (resort vs. residential vs. commercial). We also suggest the City include a timeframe for when the parking garage would need to be constructed in any phasing matrix. We believe setting triggers for parking improvements will be important to the success of the project and ensures all components can be served effectively. 2. Based on the Staff Repot, the applicant will install a signalized intersection aligning the RV resort access road with the Mission Oaks service driveway. We fully support this improvement and believe it will be essential for the proper functioning of the primary entrance to the RV resort. 3. This ownership fully supports the adjustments to the residential district and changes to the circulation plan. We feel the proposed development provides a variety of destination uses that complement the existing neighborhood while providing new and exciting reasons to visit the area. Thanks, Scott J. Huffman %EIV v E AD JUN 1 2021 rr N � ZI -oU Zo (510) 704-5702 Office (310) 699-1466 Mobile COMMUNITY DEEL®pMENT www.readinvestments.com WE" c Pj) .. ATTENTION: This email originated from outside the City's network. Use caution when opening links and attachments.